• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Integration of princely states: Patel, accession, Hyderabad and Manipur

Explain the problem of the princely states in 1947, the government's approach and considerations, the Instrument of Accession, and the cases of Junagadh, Hyderabad and Manipur.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain paramountcy and why its lapse in 1947 threatened India's unity.
  • State the three considerations that guided the government's approach.
  • Describe how Hyderabad and Manipur joined India, with dates from the chapter.

Partition was only one threat to unity. Inside the new borders lay hundreds of states ruled by princes. If each had gone its own way, India could have broken into many small countries. This lesson explains how that danger was handled.

British Provinces and Princely States

British India had two kinds of territory. The British Indian Provinces were directly controlled by the British government. The Princely States, large and small, were ruled by princes who managed their internal affairs as long as they accepted British supremacy. This supremacy was called paramountcy or suzerainty of the British crown. According to the textbook, princely states covered one-third of the land area of the British Indian Empire, and one in four Indians lived under princely rule.

Paramountcy: the supremacy of the British crown over the princely states, under which rulers kept control of internal affairs but accepted British authority.

The problem

Just before Independence, the British announced that paramountcy would lapse when their rule ended. All the states, 565 in all according to the textbook, would become legally independent and free to join India, join Pakistan or stay independent. Crucially, the decision was left to the rulers, not the people. Trouble began quickly: the ruler of Travancore announced independence, the Nizam of Hyderabad did the same the next day, and rulers such as the Nawab of Bhopal were unwilling to join the Constituent Assembly. Most princely states were run in a non-democratic way, so the prospects of democracy for their people also looked bleak.

The government's approach

The interim government firmly opposed the division of India into small principalities. Under the Mountbatten Plan the princely states were free to join India or Pakistan. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister in this crucial period, negotiated with the rulers firmly but diplomatically and brought most of them into the Indian Union. The task needed skilful persuasion: the book notes, for example, that today's Orissa had 26 small states, and the Saurashtra region of Gujarat had 14 big states, 119 small states and many other administrations.

Three considerations behind the government's approach

  • The people's wish People of most princely states clearly wanted to join the Indian Union
  • Flexibility Willingness to give autonomy to some regions and accommodate plurality
  • Territorial integrity After Partition, integrating and consolidating national boundaries had supreme importance

Before 15 August 1947, peaceful negotiations had brought almost all states whose territories touched the new boundaries into the Union. Most rulers signed the Instrument of Accession, a document by which the state agreed to become part of the Union of India. Four cases were harder: Junagadh, Hyderabad, Kashmir and Manipur. Junagadh's case was settled after a plebiscite confirmed that the people wanted to join India; Kashmir is discussed in Chapter 7.

Hyderabad

Hyderabad, the largest princely state, was surrounded entirely by Indian territory; parts of it are now in Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh. Its ruler, the Nizam, wanted independence and signed a Standstill Agreement with India in November 1947 for a year while talks went on. Meanwhile a people's movement against the Nizam's rule grew. Peasants of the Telangana region, victims of oppressive rule, rose against him, and women joined in large numbers; the Communists and the Hyderabad Congress led the movement. The Nizam unleashed a para-military force, the razakars, whose atrocities, the book says, especially targeted non-Muslims. In September 1948 the Indian army moved in; after a few days of intermittent fighting the Nizam surrendered, and Hyderabad acceded to India.

Manipur

A few days before Independence, the Maharaja of Manipur, Bodhachandra Singh, signed the Instrument of Accession on the assurance that Manipur's internal autonomy would be kept. Under public pressure he held elections in June 1948, and Manipur became a constitutional monarchy; it was thus the first part of India to hold an election on universal adult franchise. In its Legislative Assembly the state Congress wanted merger with India while other parties opposed it. The Government of India persuaded the Maharaja to sign a Merger Agreement in September 1949.

The four difficult cases
StateDifficultyOutcome (as in the textbook)
JunagadhAccession difficultPlebiscite confirmed people's desire to join India
HyderabadNizam wanted independence; Standstill Agreement, November 1947; razakar atrocitiesArmy action, September 1948; Nizam surrendered; accession
ManipurAccession with promise of autonomy; Assembly divided on mergerElections June 1948; Merger Agreement, September 1949
KashmirAccession difficultDiscussed in Chapter 7

Worked example 1: ordering events

Put in order: Hyderabad's Standstill Agreement; Manipur's Merger Agreement; army action in Hyderabad; Manipur's elections. Working: Standstill Agreement, November 1947. Manipur elections, June 1948. Army action in Hyderabad, September 1948. Manipur Merger Agreement, September 1949. So the order is: Standstill Agreement, Manipur elections, Hyderabad action, Manipur merger.

Worked example 2: why the decision rested with rulers

Why was leaving the choice to rulers a serious problem? Working: Step 1, the British allowed each state to choose India, Pakistan or independence. Step 2, the choice lay with rulers, most of whom governed undemocratically. Step 3, rulers like those of Travancore and Hyderabad chose independence even though, as the government believed, most people wanted to join India. Conclusion: India risked being split into many small countries, and the people's democratic wishes could be ignored.

Key takeaways

  • Princely states covered one-third of the land area; one in four Indians lived in them (according to the textbook).
  • With the lapse of paramountcy, 565 states became legally free; the choice lay with rulers.
  • Sardar Patel led negotiations; most rulers signed the Instrument of Accession before 15 August 1947.
  • Junagadh: plebiscite. Hyderabad: army action, September 1948. Manipur: merger, September 1949.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Paramountcy in the context of princely states meant:

    1. the right of princes to make their own foreign policy
    2. the supremacy of the British crown over the princely states
    3. the people's right to choose their ruler
    4. the authority of the Constituent Assembly over provinces
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Princely states managed internal affairs as long as they accepted British supremacy. This supremacy was called paramountcy or suzerainty of the British crown.

  2. 2. Which princely state was the first part of India to hold an election based on universal adult franchise?

    1. Hyderabad
    2. Manipur
    3. Junagadh
    4. Travancore
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under public pressure the Maharaja of Manipur held elections in June 1948, making Manipur the first part of India to hold an election on universal adult franchise.

  3. 3. The para-military force used by the Nizam against the people's movement was called the:

    1. Standstill force
    2. Frontier Guards
    3. razakars
    4. Instrument force
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Nizam unleashed the razakars on the people; the chapter describes their atrocities and communal nature.

  4. 4. How was the issue of Junagadh resolved, according to the chapter?

    1. Through a Standstill Agreement
    2. By a Merger Agreement signed in 1949
    3. By a decision of the States Reorganisation Commission
    4. After a plebiscite confirmed the people's wish to join India
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says the issue of Junagadh was resolved after a plebiscite confirmed the people's desire to join India.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The lapse of British paramountcy in 1947 threatened the unity of India. Reason (R): The British left the choice of joining India, Pakistan or independence to the rulers of the princely states rather than to their people.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because each of the 565 states could choose independence and the choice lay with rulers, India faced the real possibility of being divided into many small countries.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery