- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Partition: the two-nation theory and the process of dividing British India
Explain why British India was divided, the principle of religious majorities used to divide it, and the four difficulties the textbook identifies in applying that principle.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the two-nation theory and the opposing position of the Congress.
- State the principle used to divide British India and why it was hard to apply.
- List the four difficulties of partition in the order the textbook gives them.
On 14-15 August 1947 not one but two nation-states came into being: India and Pakistan. Partition means the division of British India into these two countries. This lesson looks at the idea behind partition and the practical problems of drawing the line.
The two-nation theory
The two-nation theory was advanced by the Muslim League. According to it, India was home to not one but two 'peoples', Hindus and Muslims, and so the League demanded Pakistan, a separate country for Muslims. The Congress opposed both the theory and the demand. The textbook explains that several political developments of the 1940s, the political competition between the Congress and the Muslim League, and the role of the British together led to the decision to create Pakistan.
Two-nation theory: the claim, put forward by the Muslim League, that Hindus and Muslims of India formed two separate peoples and therefore needed separate countries.
The principle of division
It was decided to follow the principle of religious majorities: areas where Muslims were in a majority would form Pakistan and the rest would stay with India. The book points out that this was painful and also very difficult both to decide and to carry out. The idea sounded simple, but it ran into four problems.
From principle to problems
- Principle adopted Muslim-majority areas to Pakistan, the rest to India
- Problem 1 No single Muslim-majority belt: two separate areas, west and east
- Problem 2 Not every Muslim-majority area wanted Pakistan, for example the NWFP
- Problem 3 Punjab and Bengal had large non-Muslim-majority areas, so they were split
- Problem 4 Minorities trapped on both sides of the new border
The four difficulties in detail
1. Two separate areas. There was no single belt of Muslim-majority areas in British India. There were two concentrations, one in the west and one in the east, which could not be joined. So Pakistan was made up of two territories, West Pakistan and East Pakistan, separated by a long stretch of Indian territory.
2. Not all Muslim-majority areas wanted Pakistan. Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan, the undisputed leader of the North Western Frontier Province (NWFP) and known as 'Frontier Gandhi', firmly opposed the two-nation theory. The book says his voice was simply ignored and the NWFP was made to merge with Pakistan.
3. Punjab and Bengal. These two Muslim-majority provinces had very large areas where non-Muslims were in a majority. It was decided to bifurcate them according to the religious majority at the district or even lower level. This decision could not be made by midnight of 14-15 August, so on Independence Day many people did not know whether they were in India or Pakistan. The textbook says the partition of these two provinces caused the deepest trauma of Partition.
4. The problem of minorities. This was the fourth and most intractable problem. Lakhs of Hindus and Sikhs in areas now in Pakistan, and an equally large number of Muslims on the Indian side of Punjab and Bengal (and to some extent Delhi and nearby areas), found themselves trapped, treated as unwanted in the land where their families had lived for centuries. As soon as partition became certain, violence against the smaller community in each area began on an unprecedented scale. No one had anticipated it, there was no plan to deal with it, and leaders at first hoped it would be temporary; it soon went out of control. People were often forced to leave home at a few hours' notice.
| Difficulty | Region or group affected | How it was handled or what followed |
|---|---|---|
| No single Muslim-majority belt | Western and eastern regions | Pakistan formed of two separate parts, West and East |
| Opposition within a Muslim-majority area | North Western Frontier Province | Opposition of Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan ignored; NWFP merged with Pakistan |
| Mixed provinces | Punjab and Bengal | Divided by district-level or lower majority; decision not ready by 14-15 August |
| Trapped minorities | Both sides of the border, especially Punjab, Bengal, Delhi area | Unprecedented violence and forced migration |
Worked example 1: applying the principle
Suppose (made-up case) a province has three districts: District X with a Muslim majority, District Y with a non-Muslim majority, and District Z where the majority is unclear. Working: Under the principle of religious majorities applied at district level, X would go to Pakistan and Y would stay in India. Z needs a finer, lower-level decision, which takes time. While the line is being drawn, people in all three districts do not know where they will belong. This is exactly the uncertainty the textbook describes in Punjab and Bengal.
Worked example 2: why 'East' and 'West'
Why is the Indian state called West Bengal? Working: Step 1: Bengal was divided under partition. Step 2: its eastern, Muslim-majority part became East Pakistan, which (as the textbook's side-note observes) is today Bangladesh. Step 3: the part that stayed with India was the western part, hence West Bengal. The name records the partition of a province.
Key takeaways
- Partition created two nation-states, India and Pakistan, on 14-15 August 1947.
- The Muslim League's two-nation theory said Hindus and Muslims were two peoples; the Congress opposed it.
- Division followed the principle of religious majorities.
- Four difficulties: two separate Muslim-majority areas; opposition in the NWFP; the splitting of Punjab and Bengal; and trapped minorities, the most intractable.
Check your understanding
-
1. The two-nation theory was advanced by:
- the Indian National Congress
- the Muslim League
- the British Cabinet
- the princely rulers
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the two-nation theory, which held that India consisted of two peoples, Hindus and Muslims, was advanced by the Muslim League. The Congress opposed it.
-
2. Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan, known as 'Frontier Gandhi', is mentioned in the chapter because he:
- drew the boundary line in Punjab
- led the Vishalandhra movement
- opposed the two-nation theory, though his province was merged with Pakistan
- signed the Instrument of Accession for his state
Show answer
Answer: C. He was the leader of the North Western Frontier Province and staunchly opposed the two-nation theory, showing that not all Muslim-majority areas wanted Pakistan. His voice was ignored and the NWFP was merged with Pakistan.
-
3. Which two provinces were bifurcated at the district or lower level?
- Sind and Baluchistan
- Bombay and Madras
- Assam and Bihar
- Punjab and Bengal
Show answer
Answer: D. Punjab and Bengal were Muslim-majority provinces with large non-Muslim-majority areas, so they were divided according to religious majority at district or lower level.
-
4. According to the textbook, which was the most intractable problem of partition?
- Joining East and West Pakistan by land
- Choosing a capital for Pakistan
- Dividing the armed forces
- The problem of minorities on both sides of the border
Show answer
Answer: D. The book calls the problem of 'minorities' trapped on both sides of the new border the fourth and most intractable problem, because it led to unprecedented violence and forced migration.
-
5. Assertion (A): On Independence Day many people in Punjab and Bengal did not know whether they were in India or in Pakistan. Reason (R): The decision on bifurcating these provinces could not be made by the midnight of 14-15 August 1947.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since the boundary in these two provinces had not been decided by midnight of 14-15 August, many people did not yet know which country they belonged to.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.