Revision notes

Chapter 1 Challenges of Nation Building: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Independence in 1947 and the three challenges before the new nation

The three challenges of nation-building, as the textbook frames them
ChallengeThe question it raisedWhat the Constitution offeredWhere the book discusses it
1. Shaping a united nationCould a country of continental size, with many languages, cultures and religions, stay together without crushing its diversity? How would its territory be integrated?A single citizenship and a Union of statesChapter 1 (this chapter)
2. Establishing democracyWould democratic practices actually develop, not just exist on paper?Fundamental rights, the vote for every adult citizen, representative parliamentary democracyChapter 2
3. Development and well-being of allHow could the whole society, not only some sections, be lifted out of poverty?Equality, special protection for disadvantaged groups and communities, welfare goals in the Directive Principles of State PolicyChapter 3

Challenges of nation-building after 1947

  • Unity with diversity Keep a diverse country together and integrate its territory
    • Partition and its aftermath
    • Integration of princely states
    • Reorganisation of states
  • Democracy Turn a democratic constitution into democratic practice
    • Elections and party competition (Chapter 2)
  • Development Well-being of the whole society, not only some sections
    • Planning and poverty removal (Chapter 3)
The three branches follow the textbook's own grouping.

Nation-building after 1947 meant meeting three challenges together: holding a diverse country united, making democracy work in practice, and securing development and well-being for the whole society.

  • India became independent at midnight on 14-15 August 1947; Nehru gave the 'tryst with destiny' speech to the Constituent Assembly.
  • Freedom came with partition, so the birth of the nation was marked by violence and displacement.
  • The three challenges were unity with diversity, establishing democracy, and development of the entire society.
  • A democratic constitution is necessary but not sufficient; democratic practices must develop.
  • Chapter 1 covers unity through partition, princely states and reorganisation of states.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Partition: the two-nation theory and the process of dividing British India

Two-nation theory: the claim, put forward by the Muslim League, that Hindus and Muslims of India formed two separate peoples and therefore needed separate countries.

From principle to problems

  1. Principle adopted Muslim-majority areas to Pakistan, the rest to India
  2. Problem 1 No single Muslim-majority belt: two separate areas, west and east
  3. Problem 2 Not every Muslim-majority area wanted Pakistan, for example the NWFP
  4. Problem 3 Punjab and Bengal had large non-Muslim-majority areas, so they were split
  5. Problem 4 Minorities trapped on both sides of the new border
The order follows the textbook; the fourth problem was the most intractable.
The four difficulties of partition
DifficultyRegion or group affectedHow it was handled or what followed
No single Muslim-majority beltWestern and eastern regionsPakistan formed of two separate parts, West and East
Opposition within a Muslim-majority areaNorth Western Frontier ProvinceOpposition of Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan ignored; NWFP merged with Pakistan
Mixed provincesPunjab and BengalDivided by district-level or lower majority; decision not ready by 14-15 August
Trapped minoritiesBoth sides of the border, especially Punjab, Bengal, Delhi areaUnprecedented violence and forced migration
  • Partition created two nation-states, India and Pakistan, on 14-15 August 1947.
  • The Muslim League's two-nation theory said Hindus and Muslims were two peoples; the Congress opposed it.
  • Division followed the principle of religious majorities.
  • Four difficulties: two separate Muslim-majority areas; opposition in the NWFP; the splitting of Punjab and Bengal; and trapped minorities, the most intractable.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Consequences of Partition and the choice of a secular nation

Estimates given in the chapter
MeasureAccording to the textbook
People forced to migrate across the new borderAbout 80 lakh
People killed in Partition-related violenceBetween five and ten lakh
Muslim share of India's population in 1951, after migration10-12 per cent

Consequences of Partition

  • Human
    • Mass migration and refugee camps
    • Killings on both sides
    • Abduction of women; separated children
  • Administrative and financial
    • Assets and liabilities divided
    • Government and railway staff divided
  • Social
    • Communal zones in cities
    • Neighbouring communities separated
  • Political and ideological
    • Question of how to treat minorities
    • Choice between a religious and a secular state

Secular state, as the chapter uses the idea: a state that treats citizens of all religions equally, gives no faith a superior status, and does not make religious belief a test of citizenship.

  • According to the textbook, about 80 lakh people migrated and five to ten lakh were killed.
  • Women and children suffered terribly; survivors called Partition a 'division of hearts'.
  • Gandhi worked for peace in Kolkata and Delhi; his last fast was in January 1948, and he was killed on 30 January 1948.
  • Rejecting the two-nation theory, India's leaders chose the ideal of a secular nation, enshrined in the Constitution.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Integration of princely states: Patel, accession, Hyderabad and Manipur

Paramountcy: the supremacy of the British crown over the princely states, under which rulers kept control of internal affairs but accepted British authority.

Three considerations behind the government's approach

  • The people's wish People of most princely states clearly wanted to join the Indian Union
  • Flexibility Willingness to give autonomy to some regions and accommodate plurality
  • Territorial integrity After Partition, integrating and consolidating national boundaries had supreme importance
The four difficult cases
StateDifficultyOutcome (as in the textbook)
JunagadhAccession difficultPlebiscite confirmed people's desire to join India
HyderabadNizam wanted independence; Standstill Agreement, November 1947; razakar atrocitiesArmy action, September 1948; Nizam surrendered; accession
ManipurAccession with promise of autonomy; Assembly divided on mergerElections June 1948; Merger Agreement, September 1949
KashmirAccession difficultDiscussed in Chapter 7
  • Princely states covered one-third of the land area; one in four Indians lived in them (according to the textbook).
  • With the lapse of paramountcy, 565 states became legally free; the choice lay with rulers.
  • Sardar Patel led negotiations; most rulers signed the Instrument of Accession before 15 August 1947.
  • Junagadh: plebiscite. Hyderabad: army action, September 1948. Manipur: merger, September 1949.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Reorganisation of states on linguistic lines

From Andhra to the 1956 Act

  1. Postponement after 1947 Leaders fear disintegration and delay linguistic states
  2. Vishalandhra movement Telugu speakers of Madras province demand Andhra
  3. Fast of Potti Sriramulu Begins 19 October 1952; dies after 56 days
  4. Andhra announced December 1952
  5. States Reorganisation Commission Appointed 1953; accepts linguistic boundaries
  6. States Reorganisation Act, 1956 14 states and six union territories

The States Reorganisation Commission (1953) accepted that the boundaries of states should reflect the boundaries of languages; the States Reorganisation Act of 1956 put this into effect.

Fears before and outcomes after, as the book presents them

  • Early fears
    • Linguistic states may foster separatism
    • They may pressurise the new nation
    • They may distract from economic challenges
  • Outcomes the book describes
    • Did not lead to disintegration; strengthened national unity
    • Politics opened to people beyond the small English-speaking elite
    • A uniform basis for drawing boundaries
    • Acceptance of the principle of diversity
New states after 1956, according to the textbook
YearChange described in the textbook
1960Bilingual Bombay state divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat after a popular agitation
1963Nagaland became a state
1966Punjab reorganised; Haryana and Himachal Pradesh separated from the larger Punjab state
1972Meghalaya carved out of Assam; Manipur and Tripura became separate states
1987Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh came into being
2000Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand created
2014Telangana became a state on 2 June 2014
  • The national movement promised linguistic states (Congress reorganised itself after the 1920 Nagpur session), but leaders postponed it after 1947.
  • Potti Sriramulu's fast and death led to the announcement of Andhra in December 1952.
  • The SRC (1953) accepted linguistic boundaries; the 1956 Act created 14 states and six union territories.
  • The book concludes that linguistic states strengthened unity and widened democratic participation.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery