• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

India and the reform of the United Nations

Explain India's position on UN reform, the grounds on which it claims a permanent seat in the Security Council, and the objections other countries raise, as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State India's general position on UN reform and the role of development.
  • List the grounds for India's claim to permanent membership given in the textbook.
  • Explain the objections and difficulties the textbook identifies.

India has supported restructuring the UN on several grounds. This lesson sets out India's case and the reasons, given in the textbook, why permanent membership for India or anyone else may not come easily.

India's general position

  • A strengthened and revitalised UN is desirable in a changing world.
  • The UN should have an enhanced role in promoting development and cooperation; India believes development should be central to the UN's agenda because it is a vital precondition for international peace and security.
  • The composition of the Security Council has remained largely static while General Assembly membership has expanded considerably, which India says has harmed the Council's representative character.
  • An expanded, more representative Council would enjoy greater support in the world community; since the success of the Council's actions depends on political support, restructuring should be broad-based, with more developing countries.

A useful fact from the textbook: Security Council membership was expanded from 11 to 15 in 1965, but the number of permanent members did not change, and the Council's size has stayed the same since. The overwhelming majority of General Assembly members are now developing countries, so India argues they should have a role in shaping Council decisions that affect them. India supports an increase in both permanent and non-permanent members.

India's claim to a permanent seat

Grounds for India's claim, as listed in the textbook

  • Population and democracy
    • The textbook describes India as the most populous country, with almost one-fifth of the world's population
    • The world's largest democracy
  • Record at the UN
    • Participation in virtually all UN initiatives
    • A long and substantial role in peacekeeping
    • Regular financial contributions, never faltering on payments
  • Rising weight
    • Economic emergence on the world stage
    • Symbolic importance: a sign of growing status that adds influence in foreign policy

Objections and difficulties

Despite India's wish to be a permanent, veto-wielding member, the textbook notes that some countries question its inclusion:

  • Pakistan, with which India has troubled relations, is not the only country reluctant to see India become a permanent veto member.
  • Some are concerned about India's nuclear weapons capabilities.
  • Others think its difficulties with Pakistan would make India ineffective as a permanent member.
  • Some argue that including India would mean accommodating other emerging powers such as Brazil, Germany, Japan and perhaps South Africa, whom they oppose.
  • Some feel Africa and South America must be represented in any expansion, since they are the only continents without a permanent member.

Given these concerns, the textbook concludes, it may not be easy for India or anyone else to become a permanent member in the near future.

India's case and the counter-arguments

  • India's case
    • Large population and largest democracy
    • Peacekeeping record
    • Reliable financial contributor
    • Growing economy
  • Counter-arguments raised
    • Concern over nuclear weapons
    • Troubled relations with Pakistan
    • Would open the door to other aspirants
    • Africa and South America unrepresented

India's position: a strengthened UN with development at its heart, and a larger, more representative Security Council, with more developing countries and India itself as a permanent member.

— Summary in our words

Worked example 1: building an argument for India's case

Question: Priya, a made-up student, must give a two-minute speech supporting India's claim. Suggest a structure. Working: (1) Open with the principle: the Council should reflect today's world, not 1945; it grew from 11 to 15 in 1965 with no new permanent members. (2) Give India's credentials: population, the largest democracy, peacekeeping, regular payments, economic emergence. (3) Answer one objection fairly, for example that expansion should also include Africa and South America, by supporting broad-based reform. (4) Close with the textbook's point that a more representative Council enjoys greater support.

Worked example 2: sorting strengths and objections

Question: Sort these into 'strengths of India's claim' and 'objections raised by others', as the textbook presents them: (i) never faltering on UN payments; (ii) concern about nuclear weapons capability; (iii) almost one-fifth of the world's population; (iv) the wish to see Africa and South America represented. Reasoning: the book lists population, democracy, peacekeeping, regular payments and economic emergence as India's credentials; it lists nuclear concerns, India-Pakistan difficulties, other aspirants and unrepresented continents as objections. Answer: strengths (i) and (iii); objections (ii) and (iv).

Key takeaways: India wants a strengthened UN with development at its centre and a larger, more representative Security Council, noting that the Council grew from 11 to 15 members in 1965 without new permanent members while the General Assembly grew hugely. India's claim rests on population, democracy, participation, peacekeeping, regular payments and economic emergence. Objections include nuclear concerns, India-Pakistan tensions, the question of other aspirants and the case for Africa and South America.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Security Council's membership was expanded from 11 to 15 in:

    1. 1945
    2. 1992
    3. 1965
    4. 2005
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says membership was expanded from 11 to 15 in 1965, with no change in the number of permanent members.

  2. 2. India believes development should be central to the UN's agenda because:

    1. it is a vital precondition for international peace and security
    2. it replaces the need for peacekeeping
    3. only developed countries benefit from it
    4. the Security Council deals only with development
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says India believes development is a vital precondition for the maintenance of international peace and security.

  3. 3. Which is NOT listed in the textbook as a ground for India's claim to permanent membership?

    1. Its long peacekeeping record
    2. Regular financial contributions to the UN
    3. Being the world's largest democracy
    4. Having the largest army in the world
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook cites population, democracy, participation in UN initiatives, peacekeeping, regular payments and economic emergence. It does not cite army size.

  4. 4. Why do some feel Africa and South America must be included in any expansion of permanent membership?

    1. They contribute the most to the UN budget
    2. They are the only continents without a permanent member
    3. They have the veto already
    4. They proposed the 1992 resolution
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The chapter says some feel these two continents must be represented since they are the only continents not represented in the present permanent membership.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): India argues that developing countries should have a role in shaping Security Council decisions. Reason (R): The overwhelming majority of UN General Assembly members are now developing countries.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since most members are developing countries affected by Council decisions, India argues they should help shape them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery