- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Why the world needs international organisations
Explain what an international organisation is and is not, why states create them, how they help with war and peace and with shared problems, and why the end of the Cold War raised new questions about their role.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define an international organisation and explain why it is not a super-state.
- Explain how international organisations help states avoid war and cooperate on shared problems.
- Identify the obstacles to cooperation that such organisations help overcome.
The United Nations is often mocked as a 'talking shop' that cannot stop wars. Yet the textbook notes that it is also widely regarded as the most important international organisation in the world, indispensable in the eyes of many, and a great hope for peace and progress. This lesson asks the basic question: why do states need organisations like the UN at all?
Two insiders' views
The textbook quotes two people who worked at the UN. The gist of the first, by Dag Hammarskjold, the UN's second Secretary-General, is that the UN was never meant to create a perfect world, only to save humanity from the worst. The second, by a former UN Under-Secretary-General, accepts that the UN involves many speeches and meetings, but argues that talking, however boring, is far better than fighting, and that it helps to have one place where all countries can meet. Together they suggest that international organisations are not the answer to everything, but they are important.
What an international organisation is
- It is not a super-state with authority over its members.
- It is created by states and responds to them; it comes into being only when states agree to create it.
- Once created, it can help member states resolve problems peacefully.
International organisation: a body created by agreement among states, which serves them and helps them cooperate and settle disputes peacefully, without becoming a government above them.
Two ways they help
First, war and peace. Countries have conflicts and differences, but that does not mean they must go to war. They can discuss contentious issues and find peaceful solutions; indeed, the textbook notes, most conflicts are resolved without war, even if this is rarely noticed. An international organisation provides the place and procedures for this.
Second, shared problems. Some challenges can only be dealt with if everyone works together. The textbook's examples are disease, which some countries cannot eradicate unless all vaccinate their populations, and global warming, where rising greenhouse gases threaten rising sea levels and the flooding of coastal areas and big cities. Each country could try its own remedies, but the more effective approach, stopping the warming itself, needs at least all the major industrial powers to cooperate.
Why cooperation is hard
Recognising the need to cooperate is not the same as cooperating. The textbook lists four problems states face even when they agree that cooperation is needed:
Obstacles to cooperation and how an organisation helps
-
Obstacles
- How best to cooperate
- How to share the costs
- How to divide the benefits justly
- How to stop others cheating on an agreement
-
What an organisation provides
- Information and ideas on how to cooperate
- Mechanisms and rules
- A bureaucracy to administer agreements
- Confidence that members will honour terms
A new question after the Cold War
When the US and its allies emerged victorious from the Cold War, many governments and peoples worried that Western countries led by the US would face no check on their wishes. Could the UN promote dialogue with the US and perhaps limit American power? The chapter returns to this question at the end (lesson 5).
Worked example 1: applying the idea
Question: Suggest a problem, other than disease and global warming, that no single country can handle alone, and explain the role an international organisation could play. Model answer: protecting fish stocks in international waters. One country limiting its catch achieves little if others over-fish. An organisation can gather data on fish numbers (information), set catch limits (rules), share the cost of monitoring (mechanisms), and check compliance so that no member cheats. This mirrors the four obstacles in the chapter.
Worked example 2: testing a claim
Claim (made up for this lesson): 'The UN should simply order countries to stop fighting, like a world government.' Reasoning: Step 1, recall that an international organisation is not a super-state; it is created by and responds to states. Step 2, so it cannot command them as a government commands citizens; it works by agreement, discussion and rules members accept. Conclusion: the claim misunderstands what the UN is.
Key takeaways: an international organisation is created by states and serves them; it is not a super-state. It helps states settle differences peacefully and cooperate on problems, such as disease and global warming, that no one country can solve. It overcomes obstacles to cooperation by supplying information, rules, mechanisms and a bureaucracy. After the Cold War, a new question arose: can the UN check or engage the sole superpower?
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about an international organisation is correct, according to the chapter?
- It is a super-state with authority over its members
- It is created by states and responds to them
- It exists independently of any state's agreement
- It can abolish member governments
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says an international organisation is not a super-state; it is created by and responds to states, and comes into being when states agree to it.
-
2. Which example does the textbook give of a problem needing all major industrial powers to cooperate?
- A school timetable
- Traffic in a single city
- A local election
- Global warming
Show answer
Answer: D. The chapter says stopping global warming itself requires at least all the major industrial powers to cooperate.
-
3. Which is NOT one of the obstacles to cooperation listed in the chapter?
- How to choose a world king
- How to divide the benefits justly
- How to stop others cheating
- How to share the costs
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists agreeing how best to cooperate, sharing costs, dividing benefits justly and ensuring others do not cheat. Choosing a ruler is not among them.
-
4. Source: 'It is better that nations bore each other with speeches than bore holes in each other in battle.' The point of this view is that:
- the UN should stop holding meetings
- wars are necessary to settle disputes
- discussion at the UN, even if tedious, is preferable to war
- only big powers should speak at the UN
Show answer
Answer: C. The idea quoted in the chapter is that talking at the UN, however boring, is far better than fighting on the battlefield.
-
5. Assertion (A): International organisations can help states settle conflicts without war. Reason (R): An international organisation is a super-state that can force its members to obey.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. A is true: they provide a forum to discuss issues and find peaceful solutions. R is false: the textbook says an international organisation is not a super-state.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.