• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reforming the UN: the Security Council, the veto and the UN's jurisdiction

Explain why UN reform was demanded after the Cold War, the complaints and criteria in the debate on Security Council membership, how the veto works and why abolishing it is difficult, and the 2005 decisions on the UN's jurisdiction.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the two kinds of reform and the changes in world politics behind them.
  • Analyse the proposed criteria for new Security Council members and the problems with each.
  • Explain the veto, the arguments over it, and the 2005 decisions on the UN's role.

Every organisation must reform to serve a changing world, and the UN is no exception. The textbook observes that almost everyone agrees reform is needed; what they cannot agree on is exactly what should be done, how, and when.

Two kinds of reform

  • Reform of structures and processes: above all, the functioning and membership of the Security Council; the US and other Western countries also want better budgetary procedures and administration.
  • Review of jurisdiction: which issues the UN should handle. Some want a bigger role in peace and security; others want it confined to development and humanitarian work such as health, education, environment, population control, human rights, gender and social justice.

Why the old structure looks outdated

The UN's organisation reflected the realities of 1945. The textbook lists what changed after the Cold War: the Soviet Union collapsed; the US became the strongest power; Russia-US relations became much more cooperative; China emerged fast as a great power and India grew rapidly; Asian economies grew at an unprecedented rate; many new countries joined the UN; and new challenges arose, including genocide, civil war, ethnic conflict, terrorism, nuclear proliferation, climate change, environmental degradation and epidemics.

The Security Council debate

In 1992 the General Assembly adopted a resolution reflecting three complaints: the Security Council no longer represents contemporary political realities; its decisions reflect only Western values and interests and are dominated by a few powers; and it lacks equitable representation. On 1 January 1997, Secretary-General Kofi Annan initiated an inquiry into how the UN should be reformed.

Criteria proposed for new Security Council members
Proposed criterion for a new memberProblem the textbook raises
A major economic powerHow big an economy is big enough?
A major military powerHow much military power should qualify?
A substantial contributor to the UN budgetCould a state then buy its way into the Council?
A big nation in populationIs a large population an asset or a liability?
Respects democracy and human rightsCountries with excellent records may not be effective Council members
Makes the Council more representative of world diversityRepresent by continent, region, development level or culture? Each choice raises new questions

Membership and the veto

The Security Council has five permanent and ten non-permanent members. The Charter gave the permanent members a privileged position to bring stability after the war; their privileges are permanency and the veto. Non-permanent members serve two years, cannot be re-elected immediately, are elected so as to represent all continents, and do not have the veto.

Veto: the negative vote of a permanent member of the Security Council. Even if every other member votes for a decision, one permanent member's 'no' stalls it.

— Definition in our words

The debate over the veto

  • Case for abolishing or changing it
    • Seen as conflicting with democracy
    • Conflicts with the sovereign equality of members
    • Thought no longer right or relevant after the Cold War
  • Reasons it is likely to stay
    • Permanent members unlikely to agree to its removal
    • The world may not be ready for so radical a step
    • Without it, great powers might lose interest and act outside the UN
    • A UN without great-power support would be ineffective

Jurisdiction: the 2005 decisions

When the UN completed 60 years, leaders of all member states met in September 2005 and decided on steps to make it more relevant:

  • Create a Peacebuilding Commission.
  • Accept the responsibility of the international community when national governments fail to protect their own citizens from atrocities.
  • Establish a Human Rights Council (operational since 19 June 2006).
  • Agree to achieve the Millennium Development Goals.
  • Condemn terrorism in all its forms.
  • Create a Democracy Fund.
  • Agree to wind up the Trusteeship Council.

The textbook points out that these are equally contentious. Which conflicts should a Peacebuilding Commission enter? Who decides what counts as a human rights violation and what to do about it? How realistic are ambitious development goals for so many developing countries? Can states even agree on a definition of terrorism?

Worked example 1: testing a criterion

Question: Take the criterion 'a substantial contributor to the UN budget'. Give one argument for and one against it. For: members that fund the UN heavily have a stake in its success and resources to support its decisions. Against: as the textbook asks, it could let a state buy its way into the Council, rewarding wealth rather than representativeness. Conclusion: each criterion has some validity, which is exactly why agreement is hard.

Worked example 2: a veto scenario (made up)

Scenario: a resolution gets 14 votes in favour in the 15-member Council; one permanent member votes against. Working: Step 1, all members have one vote. Step 2, a negative vote by any permanent member is a veto. Step 3, 14 'yes' votes cannot override it. Result: the resolution fails. If instead a non-permanent member had voted against, the 'no' would not be a veto.

Key takeaways: reform covers structures (above all the Security Council) and jurisdiction (what the UN should do). The 1992 resolution complained that the Council was unrepresentative, Western-dominated and inequitable; Kofi Annan began a reform inquiry in 1997. Every proposed criterion for new members has problems. The Council has 5 permanent members with the veto and 10 non-permanent members elected for two years; abolishing the veto is unlikely. In 2005 leaders agreed on a Peacebuilding Commission, a Human Rights Council, the MDGs and other steps, each contentious in practice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The 1992 General Assembly resolution on reform reflected which complaint about the Security Council?

    1. It no longer represented contemporary political realities
    2. It had too many permanent members
    3. It met too often
    4. It had no non-permanent members
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The resolution reflected three complaints: the Council no longer represents contemporary realities, its decisions reflect only Western values and interests, and it lacks equitable representation.

  2. 2. Non-permanent members of the Security Council serve for:

    1. one year
    2. five years
    3. two years
    4. life
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says non-permanent members serve for only two years at a time and cannot be re-elected immediately after their term.

  3. 3. Which was NOT among the decisions of the September 2005 meeting of world leaders?

    1. Creation of a Peacebuilding Commission
    2. Abolition of the veto
    3. Establishment of a Human Rights Council
    4. Agreement to wind up the Trusteeship Council
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 2005 decisions included a Peacebuilding Commission, a Human Rights Council and winding up the Trusteeship Council, among others. The veto was not abolished.

  4. 4. In a vote, all members except one permanent member vote for a resolution, and that permanent member votes against it. The resolution:

    1. passes, since the majority is in favour
    2. goes automatically to the General Assembly
    3. passes if the Secretary-General agrees
    4. fails, because of the veto
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A negative vote by any permanent member is a veto and stalls the decision even if all other members vote in favour.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): A non-permanent member of the Security Council cannot block a decision on its own. Reason (R): Non-permanent members do not have the veto power.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: only permanent members can stall a decision with a single negative vote; a non-permanent member's 'no' is just one vote among fifteen.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery