• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Early republics and monarchies, past and present

Describe early republics such as the Vajji mahajanapada and the Uttaramerur elections, explain how Indian traditions limited a king's power through rajadharma, and distinguish absolute from constitutional monarchy.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what a republic is and give early examples from India and elsewhere.
  • Explain how ideas such as rajadharma and the advice of the sabha and samiti limited kings in India.
  • Distinguish an absolute monarchy from a constitutional monarchy.

Elections and people's voices are not only modern ideas. Long before today's democracies, some communities chose leaders and judged them by rules. At the same time, kings ruled most kingdoms. This lesson looks at both.

Early republics

A republic is a form of government in which the head of state is elected, not a hereditary monarch.

At least two of India's ancient mahajanapadas worked this way. In the Vajji (Vriji) mahajanapada, the Lichchhavi clan in particular made decisions collectively. Leaders were chosen on merit rather than birth, key positions were filled by elections, and representatives of different clans met regularly to solve problems for the people's welfare. Such states are called early republics.

Even under kings, people's voices were valued. The Uttaramerur inscriptions of the Chola period, from the 10th century CE in Tamil Nadu, describe elections to the village sabha (local administrative body). They record the voting process, including sealed ballot boxes, the qualifications members needed, their duties, and the conditions for removing them. For example, a member found to be corrupt would be removed at once.

Republics also existed elsewhere. In the 5th and 4th centuries BCE, Rome and Greece had republics. In some Greek regions free men could vote but women, workers and slaves could not; in others only a small privileged group decided.

Kings in India: power with limits

The kings of the mahajanapadas were guided by the sabha and samiti and were expected to take their advice seriously. As empires grew, kings gained great power, but they still relied on a council of ministers and officials, and often sought scholars' advice on dharma. Of course, some kings used power to oppress their people. In some parts of the world kings made the laws, enforced them and decided punishments, sometimes claiming power from God. In many parts of India, however, the king was expected to stay within rajadharma: ruling according to dharma and ensuring the welfare of all. This was an ideal that kings did not always achieve.

In the Shanti Parva of the Mahabharata, Bhishma, lying on a bed of arrows, teaches Yudhishthira about good rule: the people's welfare comes first, the law must be applied without bias, a ruler must not cling to power, should seek wise advice, and must remember that his authority is temporary and bound by dharma. In the 12th century CE, the Kashmiri scholar Kalhana, in the Rajatarangini, tells of King Chandrapida, who wished to build a temple where a cobbler's hut stood. Instead of seizing the hut, the king went himself to ask the cobbler's permission and paid him fair compensation, and the story praises his respect for dharma even towards a humble subject.

Monarchies today

A monarchy is ruled by a monarch, a king or queen, and is usually hereditary: the position passes within the royal family, typically to the eldest son. There are two types today.

Two types of monarchy today

  • Absolute monarchy
    • The monarch makes the laws, enforces them and judges disputes
    • A council may advise, but the monarch is not bound by it
    • Textbook example: Saudi Arabia, governed according to Islamic law
  • Constitutional monarchy
    • The king or queen is head of state with only nominal power
    • Laws are made by an elected parliament
    • Executive power is used by ministers led by a prime minister
    • Textbook example: the United Kingdom

So although Britain has a monarch, it is in practice a parliamentary democracy. A constitutional monarchy keeps the royal title but gives real power to elected bodies.

Worked example 1: is it a republic?

Question: Was the Vajji mahajanapada a republic? Test it against the definition. Is the head chosen by election rather than inheritance? Leaders were chosen on merit and key posts were filled by elections, so yes. Were decisions shared? The Lichchhavis decided collectively, with representatives of clans meeting regularly, so yes. Conclusion: it fits the idea of an early republic.

Worked example 2: reading a source

Question: What does the Uttaramerur record tell us about local government in the Chola period? Step 1, members of the village sabha were elected, using sealed ballot boxes, so there was a voting procedure. Step 2, members needed qualifications and had duties. Step 3, rules allowed corrupt members to be removed at once. Conclusion: even under a king, villages had elected bodies with rules for honesty and accountability, ideas we still value today.

Key takeaways: A republic has an elected head of state. The Vajji mahajanapada (Lichchhavis) was an early republic, and the 10th-century Uttaramerur inscriptions record village elections with sealed ballot boxes. Indian kings were expected to follow rajadharma and heed advisers, though not all did. Today, an absolute monarch holds all power, while a constitutional monarch is a nominal head and elected bodies govern.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A republic is a government in which:

    1. the head of state inherits the position
    2. religious leaders rule for life
    3. the head of state is elected, not a hereditary monarch
    4. one person has unlimited power
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter defines a republic as a government whose head of state is elected rather than a hereditary monarch.

  2. 2. Which clan of the Vajji mahajanapada is known for collective decision-making and leaders chosen on merit?

    1. The Lichchhavis
    2. The Cholas
    3. The Guptas
    4. The Kurus
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Lichchhavi clan of the Vajji (Vriji) mahajanapada practised collective decision-making, making it an early republic.

  3. 3. The Uttaramerur inscriptions describe:

    1. the wars of Samudragupta
    2. elections to a village sabha, with sealed ballot boxes and rules to remove corrupt members
    3. the length of a year
    4. the building of the Iron Pillar
    Show answer

    Answer: B. These 10th-century Chola inscriptions record the election process, qualifications, duties and removal of village sabha members.

  4. 4. What did 'rajadharma' expect of a king?

    1. To claim divine power and ignore advisers
    2. To rule according to dharma and ensure the welfare of all people
    3. To give up all power to the army
    4. To rule only the capital city
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Rajadharma meant ruling within the limits of dharma for the welfare of all, an ideal that kings did not always achieve.

  5. 5. In a constitutional monarchy such as the United Kingdom:

    1. the monarch makes all laws alone
    2. religious clerics choose the ruler
    3. there is no parliament
    4. the monarch has nominal power and elected bodies hold real power
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Laws are made by the elected parliament and executive power is exercised by ministers led by the prime minister, so it is in practice a parliamentary democracy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery