• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Forms of democracy: direct, representative, parliamentary and presidential

Distinguish direct from representative democracy and parliamentary from presidential democracy, and use a comparison table of India, the USA, South Korea and Australia to explain legislatures, executives and separation of powers.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the difference between direct and representative democracy.
  • Compare parliamentary and presidential democracy and explain why India is a parliamentary democracy.
  • Explain the terms executive, legislature, upper and lower house, accountability and separation of powers.

Democracy is the most popular form of government in the modern world, but democracies are not all built the same way. This lesson sorts them into types and compares a few real examples.

Direct and representative democracy

In a direct democracy, all citizens take part in every decision themselves. Some forms of this are practised today in a few countries, such as Switzerland. Its limit is that it is very hard to run, especially in large countries, just as a committee of every student in a school would struggle to decide anything.

In a representative democracy, people elect representatives through universal adult franchise, as in India. The people do not govern directly, but the government is always accountable to them. Elections are held at regular, fixed intervals, so people can change their choices: in India, general elections are held every five years, and in the USA every four years. Most democracies today are representative.

Accountability means that the government is answerable to the people who elected it, and can be changed by them at the next election.

Parliamentary and presidential democracy

Two forms of representative democracy

  • Parliamentary (e.g. India)
    • Executive members are also members of the legislature
    • People elect the legislature, not the executive directly
    • Ministers stay in office while they have the confidence of the legislature (in India, the Lok Sabha)
  • Presidential (e.g. USA)
    • Executive works independently of the legislature
    • The president is elected by the people
    • The president does not need the confidence of the legislature to stay in office

In India, the prime minister and the council of ministers are members of Parliament. They remain in office only as long as they have the confidence of the Lok Sabha. That is why India is called a parliamentary democracy. India's states, such as Rajasthan or Kerala, have their own governments too, but these work within the larger national government, the Union Government of India.

Key terms

  • Executive: the organ that implements the law; how it is chosen differs between countries.
  • Legislature: the body that makes laws; called Parliament in India and Congress in the USA. Most have two houses.
  • Upper and lower houses: the lower house is usually directly elected and generally more powerful; the upper house may be elected or nominated. In India, the Lok Sabha is the lower house and the Rajya Sabha the upper house.
  • Separation of powers: the legislature, executive and judiciary work independently and do not interfere in each other's functions.
Different forms of democratic government (based on the textbook's table)
CountryExecutiveLegislatureJudiciary
IndiaPrime minister and council of ministersLok Sabha (lower) more powerful than Rajya Sabha (upper)Independent (separation of powers)
USAPresidentSenate and House of Representatives with equal powerIndependent (separation of powers)
South KoreaPresidentA single house, the National AssemblyIndependent (separation of powers)
AustraliaPrime minister and council of ministersSenate and House of Representatives with equal powerIndependent (separation of powers)

Worked example 1: reading the table

Question: Which two countries in the table are presidential, and what do all four share? Step 1, look at the executive column: the USA and South Korea have a president as executive, so they are presidential. India and Australia have a prime minister and council of ministers, so they are parliamentary. Step 2, look at the judiciary column: all four have an independent judiciary. Step 3, look at the legislature column: South Korea is the odd one out with a single house. Conclusion: democracies differ in structure but share core features such as an independent judiciary.

Worked example 2: counting elections

Question: Over a 20-year period, how many regular general elections would be held in a country with elections every 5 years, compared with one with elections every 4 years (assuming no early elections)? 20 ÷ 5 = 4 elections; 20 ÷ 4 = 5 elections. Either way, people get repeated chances to keep or change their representatives, which is how accountability works in practice.

Key takeaways: In a direct democracy citizens decide everything themselves, which is hard in large countries; in a representative democracy they elect representatives at fixed intervals. Parliamentary democracies (India, Australia) draw the executive from the legislature, which it must keep the confidence of; presidential democracies (USA, South Korea) have an independently elected president. All democracies keep an independent judiciary.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In which form of democracy do all citizens take part directly in every decision?

    1. Representative democracy
    2. Direct democracy
    3. Parliamentary democracy
    4. Presidential democracy
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In a direct democracy all citizens participate in decisions themselves; the textbook mentions Switzerland as following some forms of it.

  2. 2. Why is India called a parliamentary democracy?

    1. Its president is elected directly and does not need Parliament's confidence
    2. It has no legislature
    3. Its prime minister and council of ministers are members of Parliament and stay in office while they have the confidence of the Lok Sabha
    4. Its people vote on every law directly
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In a parliamentary system the executive comes from the legislature and is accountable to it; in India the ministers need the confidence of the Lok Sabha.

  3. 3. In a presidential democracy such as the USA:

    1. the president is elected by the people and works independently of the legislature
    2. the president must be a member of Congress
    3. there is no judiciary
    4. the president is chosen by a religious council
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In the presidential form, the executive works independently of the legislature, and the president does not need its confidence.

  4. 4. What does 'separation of powers' mean?

    1. One person makes, enforces and judges all laws
    2. The army controls the courts
    3. States have no government
    4. The legislature, executive and judiciary work independently without interfering in each other's functions
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Separation of powers keeps the three organs independent, which the table shows is a feature of all four democracies listed.

  5. 5. In India, which house of Parliament is the lower house and more powerful?

    1. Rajya Sabha
    2. Senate
    3. Lok Sabha
    4. National Assembly
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Lok Sabha is the lower house, directly elected and more powerful; the Rajya Sabha is the upper house.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery