- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
What makes governments different, and the principles of democracy
Use four key questions to compare governments, and explain the fundamental principles of democracy such as equality, freedom, universal adult franchise and an independent judiciary.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Use four questions to compare any two forms of government.
- Explain the fundamental principles of democracy.
- Show with examples that these principles developed over time and are ideals still being worked towards.
Countries have different histories, cultures and hopes, so it is natural that their governments differ. To compare them fairly, we need a few clear questions that we can ask of any government.
Four questions for comparing governments
- Who decides that 'this is the government'? In other words, where does its authority come from? In a democracy like India it is the people; in a theocracy it is religious belief and the head of a religious institution.
- How is the government formed? In a democracy, usually through elections, and there are many kinds of elections. In a kingdom, someone from the royal family usually continues to rule.
- What are its parts and what do they do? The legislative, executive and judicial functions may be carried out by independent bodies or by the same body. In most democracies, these rules are written in a constitution, the book of a country's fundamental rules; in a monarchy they may be decided by the king or queen.
- What is the government working for? Some, like the government of India, are designed to work for equality and prosperity for all; others may serve only some families or groups.
Comparing governments
-
Source of authority
- The people, religion, or a royal family
-
How it is formed
- Elections or inheritance
-
Parts and their work
- Separate or combined legislature, executive, judiciary
- Constitution or the ruler's will
-
Goals
- Welfare of all, or of a few
Fundamental principles of democracy
| Principle | What it means |
|---|---|
| Equality | Everyone is treated equally, is equal before the law and has equal access to facilities such as education and health |
| Freedom | Citizens may make their own choices and express their opinions |
| Representative participation | Every person may choose and elect representatives, who form the legislature |
| Universal adult franchise | Every citizen above a certain age has the right to vote |
| Fundamental rights | Rights such as equality, freedom of speech and expression, and protection against exploitation are provided and protected |
| Independent judiciary | Courts protect citizens' rights and ensure that both citizens and every part of the government follow the law |
Universal adult franchise means that every adult citizen, above a set age, has the right to vote, whatever their wealth, gender, caste or religion.
Principles that grew over time
These principles did not appear all at once. India gave universal adult franchise from the very start of the Republic in 1950. In contrast, according to the textbook, women in Switzerland got the right to vote only in 1971; effective universal adult suffrage came in the UK in 1928 and in the USA by 1965. So the principles are ideals: not every democracy fully achieves them, but citizens need to keep them in view.
| Country | Year democracy was established (as given in the textbook) |
|---|---|
| USA | 1787 |
| Switzerland | 1848 |
| India | 1947 |
| Germany | 1949 |
| Kenya | 1964 |
| Nepal | 2008 |
Worked example 1: using the table
Question: Democracy in the USA was established in 1787 (textbook table), but effective universal adult suffrage came only by 1965. How many years passed in between? 1965 − 1787 = 178 years. Now compare India: democracy in 1947 and universal adult franchise from 1950, a gap of only 3 years. This shows that early democracies often began with limited voting rights, while India gave the vote to all adults from the beginning of the Republic.
Worked example 2: applying the four questions
Question: Compare a democracy with a kingdom using the four questions. Authority: the people versus the royal family. Formation: elections versus inheritance within the family. Parts: in a democracy, usually separate bodies set up by a constitution; in a kingdom, often decided by the ruler. Goals: a democracy is meant to serve the welfare of all; a kingdom may or may not, depending on the ruler. Asking the same four questions makes the comparison clear and fair.
Key takeaways: Four questions help compare governments: the source of authority, how it is formed, its parts and their work, and its goals. Democracies share principles of equality, freedom, representative participation, universal adult franchise, fundamental rights and an independent judiciary. These principles developed over time; India granted universal adult franchise from 1950.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a theocracy, where does the government's authority come from, according to the chapter?
- The people's votes
- Religious beliefs and the head of a religious institution
- A group of wealthy traders
- The army alone
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter contrasts a democracy, where the people are the source of authority, with a theocracy, where authority comes from religion and religious leaders.
-
2. What is a constitution?
- A book of a country's fundamental rules that sets out how the government works
- A list of a king's ancestors
- A record of trade routes
- A type of election
Show answer
Answer: A. In most democracies the system of government is written down in a constitution, the country's book of fundamental rules.
-
3. Since when has India had universal adult franchise?
- 1971
- 1928
- 1965
- From the start of the Republic in 1950
Show answer
Answer: D. India gave all adults the right to vote from the very beginning of the Republic in 1950; 1971, 1928 and 1965 relate to Switzerland, the UK and the USA.
-
4. Which principle means that courts protect citizens' rights and make sure the government itself follows the law?
- Freedom
- Representative participation
- Independent judiciary
- Universal adult franchise
Show answer
Answer: C. An independent judiciary protects fundamental rights and ensures laws are followed by citizens and by every part of the government.
-
5. Using the textbook's table, how many years passed between democracy being established in Germany (1949) and in Nepal (2008)?
- 49 years
- 59 years
- 69 years
- 61 years
Show answer
Answer: B. 2008 − 1949 = 59 years.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.