• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Democracy and republic: why India is a democratic republic

Distinguish a democracy from a republic, explain why India is both, and show how the Constitution protects the rights of all, including minorities, from the dominance of the majority.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define democracy and republic and give examples of each.
  • Explain why the Constitution makers chose an elected head of state for India.
  • Explain how a constitution protects rights against the dominance of the majority.

The Preamble to our Constitution uses the words 'democratic' and 'republic' together. People often use these words as if they meant the same, so why did the Constitution makers use both? Political scientists discuss this in depth; here we look at it simply.

Democracy and republic

The core idea of democracy is 'rule by the people' (Greek demos = people, kratos = rule). In a democracy, people choose their government through free and fair elections. In a republic, the head of state (the highest office) is elected, directly or indirectly, not inherited by a king or queen. A republic also limits the power of its rulers through a constitution or laws.

After about two centuries of British rule, India did not simply copy the British system. In both India and the UK, people elect representatives and the government answers to parliament. But Britain has had a monarch as head of state for centuries, while India's Constitution makers decided that India's head of state, the President, would be elected - not directly by the people but by elected representatives.

Democracy and republic

  • Democracy
    • Rule by the people
    • Government chosen in free and fair elections
    • Examples: India, USA, UK, Canada, Sweden
  • Republic
    • Head of state is elected, not hereditary
    • Rulers' powers limited by a constitution or laws
    • Examples: India, USA, France

A country can be both: India and the USA are democratic republics. But not every democracy is a republic. The UK, Canada and Sweden are democracies with monarchs, so they are not republics.

Democratic republic: a country where the people choose their government in free and fair elections, the head of state is elected rather than born to the post, and everyone in power works within limits set by a constitution.

A republic that protects the rights of all

India's Constitution guarantees fundamental rights to all citizens. Laws make sure that rule by a majority of representatives cannot violate any citizen's fundamental rights. For example, some areas belong to tribal communities and are protected by law: outsiders cannot buy or lease them without the community's permission and due legal process. When mining was proposed in the sacred hills of the Dongria Kondh tribe in Odisha, the community strongly opposed it and the law protected their rights to their sacred land.

The government may use force to keep law and order, but the Constitution limits its powers; otherwise those in power might act unchecked and threaten citizens' rights. This is how a republic guards against the dominance of the majority, a situation where only the majority's interests are pursued at the cost of minorities' rights. The rule of law is stronger than the wishes of the majority.

Ideas about limiting power are old. In 1782, an officer suggested that George Washington, who had led the American army against Britain, should become king; Washington refused, believing in government by the people under a constitution, and he later became the first President of the USA in 1789. In ancient India, Kautilya's Arthashastra said a king must follow Raja Dharma and keep law and order; without government, society would fall into matsya nyaya, the 'law of the fishes', where big fish swallow small ones.

Worked example 1: a case of majority and minority

Case (retold): a residents' association votes by majority to ban all deliveries after 9 pm. A few residents object that sick and elderly people may need medicines at night, but they are outvoted. One night an elderly resident falls ill and her medicine cannot be delivered in time. The association then changes the rule to allow food and medicines. Lesson: a majority decision can still be unfair to a minority; rules must protect everyone's basic needs and rights. In a country, the Constitution plays this protecting role.

Worked example 2: classifying countries

CountryElections choose government?Head of stateDemocracy?Republic?
IndiaYesElected PresidentYesYes
USAYesElected PresidentYesYes
UKYesHereditary monarchYesNo

Conclusion: the statement 'every democracy is a republic' is false, because the UK is a democracy with a hereditary monarch.

Key takeaways: Democracy means rule by the people through free and fair elections; a republic has an elected head of state and limits on rulers' power. India is both. The Constitution protects fundamental rights, so even an elected majority cannot override the rights of minorities, which prevents the dominance of the majority.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What makes a country a republic?

    1. It has a large population
    2. Its head of state is elected, not hereditary
    3. It has a monarch
    4. It has no constitution
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In a republic the head of state is elected (directly or indirectly), not a king or queen who inherits the post, and rulers' powers are limited by a constitution or laws.

  2. 2. Which country is a democracy but NOT a republic?

    1. The United Kingdom
    2. India
    3. The USA
    4. France
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The UK elects its government but has a hereditary monarch as head of state, so it is a democracy but not a republic.

  3. 3. How is India's President chosen?

    1. By birth in a royal family
    2. Directly by every citizen
    3. By a group of elected representatives
    4. By the Supreme Court
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Constitution makers decided the President would be elected not directly by the people but by elected representatives.

  4. 4. What is 'matsya nyaya' in Kautilya's idea?

    1. A fishing law
    2. A tax on fish
    3. A type of election
    4. A situation without law where the powerful swallow the weak, like big fish eating small ones
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Matsya nyaya, the law of the fishes, describes chaos without government, where the strong prey on the weak; Kautilya argued a king must keep law and order to prevent it.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): In India, an elected majority cannot pass laws that take away citizens' fundamental rights. Reason (R): The Constitution limits the powers of those in government to protect everyone's rights.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Because the Constitution limits government power and guarantees fundamental rights, even a majority cannot override them; this guards against the dominance of the majority. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery