• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

The state and the government: what is the difference?

Name the four features of a state, explain how a government differs from the state, and describe the role of the police as agents of the state.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List and explain the four features of a state.
  • Explain why the government is part of the state but not the same as the state.
  • Describe what the police do and why their power is limited by the Constitution.

In Class 6 you learned that governments make laws (legislature), carry them out (executive) and see that they are followed (judiciary), and that India has three levels of government. Part 1 of this book compared democracies, monarchies, theocracies, dictatorships and oligarchies. Now we ask a basic question: are 'the state' and 'the government' the same thing?

What is a state?

A state (or nation) is a political organisation with the authority to govern a defined territory and the people living in it. Every state has four essential features.

The four features of a state

  • Population
    • People who live there permanently and identify with the place
  • Territory
    • A geographically defined area with agreed boundaries
  • Government
    • The system that makes and carries out laws
  • Sovereignty
    • Full power to make its own laws and decisions without outside control

A permanent population matters because tourists who visit and leave share nothing lasting with a place; people who live together and identify with a territory develop a shared culture and society. A defined territory has clear boundaries, often lines agreed with neighbouring states rather than natural features. Because people live together, they need laws made and carried out, which is the work of the government. Sovereignty means that the state controls its own affairs and no other state or outside body can interfere in its internal matters.

Sovereignty: the complete power of a state to make and carry out its own laws and decisions, free from control by any other state or outside body.

In India the word 'State' is also used for our subnational units, as in 'the State of Kerala'. In this chapter, 'state' mostly means the country as a political organisation.

What is a government?

The government is the group of people and the system that runs the country: leaders, ministers and officials who make laws, enforce them and resolve disputes. It is only one part of the state. A government can change after elections, but the state remains. Think of the state as a school and the government as its principal and teachers: teachers may come and go, but the school continues.

Why do people mix the two words? Because the government acts on behalf of the state and is the face of the state we see every day. We say 'the state did this' or 'the government decided that' because the government runs the state's daily work, and we deal with the government rather than with the whole state.

People, police and the government

The police maintain law and order in each state of India and are part of the state government. They work with local communities in villages, towns and cities. They are agents of the state who may lawfully use force to keep people safe from crime and violence. They work with courts and prisons, investigating crimes and presenting cases to the judiciary. They also run awareness programmes on road safety, drug abuse and women's safety. But they must respect and protect the rights guaranteed by the Constitution.

State and government compared
PointStateGovernment
What it isThe whole political organisation: people, territory, government, sovereigntyThe system and people that run the state
Does it change?Remains the sameCan change after elections
AnalogyThe schoolThe principal and teachers

Worked example 1: applying the four features

Question: a popular hill station is visited by thousands of tourists each summer, but nobody lives there in winter and it follows the laws of the country it lies in. Is it a state? Check: permanent population - no; own sovereignty - no (it follows another country's laws). Conclusion: it is not a state; it is just a place within a state.

Worked example 2: state or government?

Statement: 'After the election, a new set of ministers took charge.' Reasoning: the people running the country changed, but the country's territory, people and sovereignty did not. Conclusion: the government changed; the state stayed the same.

Key takeaways: A state has four features: a permanent population, a defined territory, a government and sovereignty. The government is one part of the state; it can change, while the state continues. The police, part of the state government, keep law and order but must respect constitutional rights.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is NOT one of the four features of a state?

    1. Sovereignty
    2. A defined territory
    3. A single religion
    4. A permanent population
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The four features are population, territory, government and sovereignty. A state does not need a single religion.

  2. 2. What does sovereignty mean?

    1. Full power to make and carry out its own laws without outside control
    2. Having a king or queen
    3. Having many tourists
    4. Having a large army
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sovereignty means the state controls its own affairs and no other state or outside body can interfere in its internal matters.

  3. 3. In the school analogy, the government is like:

    1. The school building
    2. The students' families
    3. The playground
    4. The principal and teachers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The state is like the school, which continues; the government is like the principal and teachers, who may change over time.

  4. 4. The police in India are part of which level of government?

    1. The local panchayat
    2. The state government
    3. The judiciary
    4. Foreign governments
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The police maintain law and order within each state and are part of the state government.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The state remains the same even when the government changes. Reason (R): The government is only one part of the state and can change after elections.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is true but R is false
    4. A is false but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Because the government is only one part of the state, replacing it after an election leaves the population, territory and sovereignty unchanged. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery