• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Making and carrying out laws: the legislature and the executive

Explain the role of the legislature, distinguish the political executive from the permanent executive, and describe what civil servants do, with the example of C. B. Muthamma.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what the legislature does.
  • Distinguish the political executive from the permanent executive.
  • Describe the functions of the bureaucracy and why C. B. Muthamma's case matters.

Look around on your way to school: boards for the electricity office, the water department, the health centre, the post office. These offices belong to the executive, the part of government we meet most often. In this lesson we see how the legislature and the executive divide their work.

The legislature: the law-making body

The legislature makes laws for the country. In a democracy it represents the people and makes rules that apply to everyone, so that the country is governed by well-defined laws rather than by anyone's personal wishes or random decisions. Parliament makes laws for the whole country, and each state has its own legislature (for example, a Vidhan Sabha) that makes laws only for that state.

The executive: carrying out laws and making policy

The executive implements the laws made by the legislature, takes policy decisions (a policy is a set of ideas or actions an institution decides on) and manages the day-to-day running of government. It has two parts that work together. The Constitution does not use these two terms, but the distinction is part of how India's parliamentary system works.

Two parts of the executive

  • Political executive
    • Elected leaders: prime minister, chief ministers, ministers
    • President and governors (mostly formal roles)
    • Make big decisions, propose laws, set goals
    • Fixed term, usually five years; depend on people's trust
  • Permanent executive
    • Officers selected through examinations, e.g. by the UPSC
    • Called bureaucrats or civil servants
    • Stay whichever party is in power
    • Advise, implement policies, run public services

Key functions of the bureaucracy include implementing laws, policies and schemes across the country; linking citizens and the government through departments and field offices that deliver schools, roads and hospitals and address complaints; and keeping records of government work and decisions. It is hierarchical, with levels from the state headquarters down to the district and block. Well-known services include the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), Indian Foreign Service (IFS), Indian Revenue Service (IRS) and Indian Forest Service (IFoS). Most of us meet the bureaucracy through grassroots workers: government school teachers, anganwadi workers, health workers, sanitation workers and bus conductors. The bureaucracy also runs huge tasks such as the census, national elections, disaster relief and vaccination drives.

Political executive decides, permanent executive delivers: elected leaders set direction for a fixed term, while civil servants carry out the work continuously, whichever party is in power.

C. B. Muthamma: fighting for equality in public service

Chonira Belliappa Muthamma (1924-2009), from Karnataka, was the first woman to clear the public services examination (1948) and the first woman to join the Indian Foreign Service (1949). At that time women faced strong bias; she later wrote that women had to promise to resign if they married. She still built a distinguished career and became India's first woman ambassador in several countries. When she was unfairly denied promotion, she went to the Supreme Court. A bench led by Justice V. R. Krishna Iyer struck down the gender-biased rules as violating the Constitution. Her struggle is a milestone for gender equality in public service. She also wrote that the freedom of thought and belief found in Indian religions was a key reason democracy works in India.

Worked example 1: which part of the executive?

PersonElected or selected?Part of the executive
A state's chief ministerElectedPolitical executive
A District Education OfficerSelected by examinationPermanent executive
A Union ministerElectedPolitical executive
A government school teacherSelectedPermanent executive (grassroots)

Rule used: if a person holds office because they won an election, they belong to the political executive; if they were recruited and stay regardless of elections, they belong to the permanent executive.

Worked example 2: following a law from start to finish

How a school law reaches a classroom

  1. Legislature Makes a law, e.g. every school must have separate toilets for girls and boys.
  2. Political executive Ministers guide policy, make rules and approve budgets.
  3. Permanent executive District and block officers check schools and get toilets built.
  4. Judiciary Courts and child-rights bodies act if children's rights are denied.

Key takeaways: The legislature (Parliament and state legislatures) makes laws. The executive carries them out: the elected political executive sets direction for a fixed term, and the permanent executive of civil servants delivers services whatever party is in power. C. B. Muthamma's Supreme Court victory removed gender bias from the Foreign Service rules.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is the main job of the legislature?

    1. Settling disputes in court
    2. Making laws
    3. Collecting garbage
    4. Selecting civil servants
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The legislature is the law-making body; Parliament makes laws for the whole country and state legislatures for their own states.

  2. 2. Which of these belongs to the permanent executive?

    1. The prime minister
    2. A chief minister
    3. A state minister
    4. An IAS officer selected through the UPSC examination
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Civil servants such as IAS officers are selected through examinations and stay in service whichever party wins; ministers belong to the political executive.

  3. 3. Why is the permanent executive called 'permanent'?

    1. Its officers are not replaced after every election
    2. Its members are elected for life
    3. It never makes any decisions
    4. It is part of the judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Civil servants keep their jobs through changes of government, keeping administration running smoothly no matter which party is in power.

  4. 4. C. B. Muthamma is remembered for:

    1. Founding the UPSC
    2. Being India's first prime minister
    3. Being the first woman in the Indian Foreign Service and winning a Supreme Court case against gender-biased rules
    4. Writing the Arthashastra
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Muthamma was the first woman to join the IFS (1949); when denied promotion she went to the Supreme Court, which struck down gender-biased provisions.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Elected leaders hold office only for a fixed period. Reason (R): Their power depends on the trust and support of the people, which is tested in elections.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
    3. A is false but R is true
    4. A is true but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The political executive is chosen in elections and must face voters again after its term, usually five years, because its power rests on people's support. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery