- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Identifying compounds: reaction chains and puzzle questions
Work out unknown carbon compounds from the clues given by formulas, tests and reaction products.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A favourite exam question describes some unknown compounds A, B and C through a few observations and asks you to name them and write the equation. The method is simple: every clue narrows the possibilities. Take each clue in order, write down what it tells you about a functional group, and combine them.
Clues and what they mean
| Clue | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| Reacts with sodium to give hydrogen | Contains -OH (alcohol or acid) |
| Effervescence with sodium hydrogencarbonate | Carboxylic acid |
| Decolourises bromine water | Unsaturated (C=C or C≡C) |
| Sweet smell after heating with an alcohol and conc. H2SO4 | An ester has formed, so the compound is a carboxylic acid |
| Burns with a sooty flame | High proportion of carbon: often unsaturated |
| Takes up exactly 1 mol of H2 per mol | One double bond; 2 mol of H2 means a triple bond or two double bonds |
| Formula fits CnH2n+2, CnH2n or CnH2n-2 | Alkane, alkene or alkyne |
Worked examples
Example 1. P has the formula C2H4O2 and gives CO2 with sodium hydrogencarbonate. P heated with ethanol and a little concentrated H2SO4 gives a sweet-smelling Q. Q is heated with sodium hydroxide to give R and ethanol. Identify P, Q and R. Working: P is ethanoic acid. Q is the ester ethyl ethanoate, CH3COOC2H5. Heating the ester with sodium hydroxide gives sodium ethanoate (R), CH3COONa, and ethanol.
Example 2. A gas X burns with a sooty flame and decolourises bromine water. One mole of X adds two moles of hydrogen over nickel to give C2H6. Identify X. Working: adding 2 mol of H2 shows a triple bond. The carbon skeleton is two carbons, so X is ethyne, C2H2, which becomes C2H6 (ethane) on adding two H2.
Example 3. A hydrocarbon burns completely, and 1 mol gives 3 mol of CO2 and 3 mol of H2O. Find its formula and decide whether it is an alkane, alkene or alkyne. Working: 3 mol CO2 means 3 carbon atoms. 3 mol H2O means 6 hydrogen atoms. The formula is C3H6, which fits CnH2n, so it is an alkene (propene).
Example 4. Three colourless liquids are labelled 1, 2 and 3. They are ethanol, ethanoic acid and ethyl ethanoate. How can they be identified? Working: (i) Smell: the one with a sweet fruity smell is the ester (liquid 2, say). (ii) Add sodium hydrogencarbonate to the other two: the one that fizzes is ethanoic acid. (iii) The remaining one gives hydrogen with sodium and is ethanol.
Example 5. Name the reagent and conditions for each change. Working: ethanol to ethene: concentrated H2SO4 at 443 K. Ethene to ethane: H2 with a nickel catalyst. Ethanol to ethanoic acid: alkaline KMnO4 and then acid. Ethanoic acid plus ethanol to ester: a few drops of concentrated H2SO4.
Use each clue to fix a functional group, then find a formula that fits all the clues. Moles of H2 taken up tell the number of pi bonds (a triple bond counts as two).
Common traps
- Naming an ester as an acid because both are made from acid and alcohol.
- Forgetting that alcohols also give hydrogen with sodium.
- Giving only the name and forgetting the equation or the condition when it is asked.
Key takeaways
- Each clue points to a functional group.
- A compound that fizzes with hydrogencarbonate is an acid; one that does not but reacts with sodium is an alcohol.
- Moles of CO2 and H2O from one mole of a hydrocarbon give its formula.
Check your understanding
-
1. A gas decolourises bromine water and burns with a sooty flame. It is most likely:
- methane
- ethane
- carbon dioxide
- ethene
Show answer
Answer: D. Decolourising bromine water shows unsaturation, and a sooty flame fits a high carbon content. Ethene fits.
-
2. One mole of a hydrocarbon burns to give 4 mol CO2 and 4 mol H2O. Its formula is:
- C4H10
- C4H8
- C4H6
- C4H4
Show answer
Answer: B. 4 mol CO2 means 4 carbons; 4 mol H2O means 8 hydrogens: C4H8.
-
3. A compound adds 2 mol of H2 per mole to give propane. It is:
- propane
- propene
- propyne
- propanol
Show answer
Answer: C. Two moles of H2 added shows a triple bond or two double bonds; of the options only propyne, C3H4, fits, and it becomes C3H8.
-
4. A liquid gives CO2 with NaHCO3 and a sweet smell with ethanol and acid. It is:
- ethanol
- ethyl ethanoate
- ethene
- ethanoic acid
Show answer
Answer: D. CO2 with hydrogencarbonate shows a carboxylic acid; forming an ester with ethanol agrees.
-
5. Heating ethyl ethanoate with NaOH gives:
- sodium ethanoate and ethanol
- ethanoic acid and ethane
- sodium ethoxide and water
- ethene and sodium
Show answer
Answer: A. The ester is hydrolysed in alkali to give the sodium salt of the acid and the alcohol: CH3COONa and C2H5OH.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.