• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Best-buy, equivalent-dose and reverse problems with fertiliser mixtures

Compare fertilisers by cost per kilogram of nutrient, find the equivalent amount of one fertiliser for another, and work backwards from a mixture's analysis to its composition.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Not every fertiliser question gives you the doses. Some ask which product is the better buy, some ask how much of one fertiliser equals another, and some give you the analysis of a mixture and ask what is in it. These reverse problems are common in tests because they catch students who can only calculate in one direction. Each of them rests on the same idea: nutrient mass is fertiliser mass times the nutrient fraction.

Equivalent amounts

To get the same amount of nutrient from two fertilisers, set nutrient masses equal: m1 × f1 = m2 × f2. So m2 = m1 × f1 / f2.

Worked example 1. How much urea (46% N) gives the same nitrogen as 100 kg of ammonium nitrate (35% N)? Nitrogen in the nitrate = 100 × 0.35 = 35 kg. Urea needed = 35 / 0.46 = 76.1 kg. Quick check: urea is richer, so less of it is needed.

Best buy

The cost per kilogram of nutrient is price divided by nutrient fraction. For a compound fertiliser, such as DAP, which carries two nutrients, give credit for the second nutrient at the price you would have paid for it elsewhere.

Worked example 2: DAP or urea plus phosphate? (illustrative prices). DAP (graded 18-46-0) costs ₹28 per kg. Urea costs ₹6 per kg. To supply 100 kg of P2O5 by DAP, you need 100 / 0.46 = 217.4 kg of DAP, costing 217.4 × 28 = ₹6,087. This DAP also carries 217.4 × 0.18 = 39.1 kg of nitrogen. The same nitrogen as urea would cost 39.1 / 0.46 × 6 = ₹510. So the effective cost of the P2O5 is 6,087 - 510 = ₹5,577, which is ₹55.8 per kilogram of P2O5. A product on its own can never be judged by price per bag.

Reverse problems: finding the mixture

Worked example 3. A mixture of urea (46% N) and ammonium sulphate (21% N) is found to contain 30% N. What fraction is urea? Let the urea fraction be x. Then 46x + 21(1 - x) = 30, so 25x = 9 and x = 0.36. The mixture is 36% urea and 64% ammonium sulphate. Check: 0.36 × 46 = 16.56 and 0.64 × 21 = 13.44, and 16.56 + 13.44 = 30.00.

The same answer follows from alligation: the amounts are in the ratio (30 - 21) : (46 - 30) = 9 : 16 of urea to ammonium sulphate, which is 9/25 = 36% urea.

Worked example 4: ratios from a grade. A compound fertiliser is graded 12-32-16. Its N : P2O5 : K2O ratio is 12 : 32 : 16 = 3 : 8 : 4, found by dividing by 4. A crop needing 60 kg of P2O5 per hectare from this fertiliser needs 60 / 0.32 = 187.5 kg, which also supplies 187.5 × 0.12 = 22.5 kg of N and 187.5 × 0.16 = 30 kg of K2O.

Nutrient mass = fertiliser mass × nutrient fraction. Equivalent amount: m2 = m1 × f1/f2. Mixture: sum of (fraction × grade) = overall grade.

— Rule to remember

Traps

  • Dividing by the price of nutrient fraction instead of by the fraction: cost per kg of nutrient = price per kg / fraction.
  • Treating a percentage as a whole number in 46x + 21(1 - x) = 30. Keep the grade as percent on both sides, or convert both to fractions.
  • Forgetting the second nutrient in a compound fertiliser.

Key takeaways

  • Equal nutrient: set m × f equal on both sides.
  • Judge fertilisers by cost per kilogram of nutrient, with credit for extra nutrients.
  • For a mixture of two components, solve a linear equation or use alligation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. How much ammonium sulphate (21% N) supplies the same nitrogen as 42 kg of urea (46% N)?

    1. 19.3 kg
    2. 42 kg
    3. 92 kg
    4. 200 kg
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Nitrogen from urea = 42 × 0.46 = 19.32 kg. Ammonium sulphate needed = 19.32 / 0.21 = 92 kg.

  2. 2. Fertiliser X costs ₹30 per kg and holds 20% of a nutrient. Its cost per kg of nutrient is

    1. ₹6
    2. ₹150
    3. ₹50
    4. ₹120
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 30 / 0.20 = ₹150.

  3. 3. A mixture of urea (46% N) and ammonium sulphate (21% N) has 33.5% N. The fraction of urea is

    1. 0.25
    2. 0.40
    3. 0.60
    4. 0.50
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 46x + 21(1 - x) = 33.5 gives 25x = 12.5, so x = 0.50.

  4. 4. The grade 10-26-26 has an N : P2O5 : K2O ratio of

    1. 5 : 13 : 13
    2. 1 : 3 : 3
    3. 5 : 26 : 26
    4. 10 : 13 : 13
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Dividing all three by 2 gives 5 : 13 : 13.

  5. 5. How much N is in 80 kg of a 12-32-16 fertiliser?

    1. 25.6 kg
    2. 12 kg
    3. 9.6 kg
    4. 38.4 kg
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 80 × 0.12 = 9.6 kg.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery