- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Choosing the right modal by situation: mixed problem set
Practise picking the modal that fits a described situation of ability, permission, advice, duty, offer, habit or prediction.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A well-set modals paper does not announce the topic. One question might ask about ability, the next about advice, the next about a past habit. The skill that is tested is recognising the situation, so this lesson trains exactly that. For each sentence, first name the situation, then match the modal.
Situation map
| Situation | Usual modals |
|---|---|
| ability (present) | can; be able to |
| ability (past) | could (general); was able to (one occasion) |
| permission | can, may, could |
| advice | should, ought to, had better |
| duty (rule) | must, have to |
| offer | shall, can, would |
| request | could, would, can |
| past habit | used to, would |
| prediction | will, may, might |
Situation 1: ability
Question: When she was five, she ___ read simple stories. Options: can / could / may / must. Working: General ability in the past: could.
Question: The firefighters ___ rescue everyone from the building. Options: could / were able to / can / may. Working: One occasion in the past, with a success: were able to.
Situation 2: permission and rules
Question: ___ I use your phone for a minute? Options: Must / Shall / May / Need. Working: Permission: May.
Question: Drivers ___ stop at a red light. Options: might / must / may / could. Working: A legal rule: must.
Situation 3: advice and warning
Question: You look pale. You ___ see a doctor. Options: should / will / would / used to. Working: Advice: should.
Situation 4: past habit
Question: When we were children, we ___ swim in the river every summer. Options: would / should / must / might. Working: A repeated past action: would (or used to).
Situation 5: offers
Question: ___ I help you with your bags? Options: Shall / Must / May / Ought. Working: An offer from the speaker: Shall.
Situation 6: prediction and request
Question: Look at those dark clouds. It ___ rain soon. Options: will / could / shall / ought. Working: The speaker predicts from evidence. Will is the firm prediction. Answer: will.
Question: ___ you lend me your pen, please? Options: Could / Must / Might / Need. Working: A polite request. Answer: Could.
| Modal | Meanings |
|---|---|
| could | past ability; polite request; possibility |
| may | permission; possibility |
| will | prediction; promise; request |
| should | advice; expectation |
| must | duty; strong deduction |
Speed method
- Read the whole sentence and name the situation in one word.
- Cross out options that belong to another situation.
- If two remain, check the form of the verb that follows: base verb, have + participle, -ing.
- Read your choice back in the sentence.
Traps
- Would for a past habit needs a repeated action; for a state (I used to be shy), use used to.
- May for permission is formal; for a possibility it is neutral. The meaning comes from the sentence.
- Could can be ability, a polite request or possibility; the surrounding words decide.
Name the situation first: ability, permission, advice, duty, offer, habit, prediction. Then match the modal.
Key takeaways
- Many modals have several meanings; the situation decides.
- Use was able to for a single past success.
- Would is only for repeated past actions, not for states.
Check your understanding
-
1. When she was five, she ___ read simple stories.
- must
- can
- may
- could
Show answer
Answer: D. General ability in the past takes could.
-
2. ___ I use your phone for a minute?
- May
- Must
- Need
- Ought
Show answer
Answer: A. Permission is asked with may.
-
3. Drivers ___ stop at a red light.
- might
- must
- could
- may
Show answer
Answer: B. A legal rule takes must.
-
4. You look pale. You ___ see a doctor.
- would
- will
- should
- used to
Show answer
Answer: C. Advice takes should.
-
5. When we were children, we ___ swim in the river every summer.
- might
- should
- must
- would
Show answer
Answer: D. A repeated past action takes would (or used to).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.