- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Modals with the perfect: must have, should have, could have
Use modal + have + past participle to talk about past possibility, missed advice and certainty.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
To speak about the past with a modal, use modal + have + past participle. This pattern appears often in exams.
Meanings
| Form | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| must have + pp | strong belief about the past | He must have missed the bus. |
| should have + pp | something that was right to do but not done | You should have told me. |
| could have + pp | past possibility that did not happen | She could have won. |
| may/might have + pp | past possibility | He may have gone home. |
| needn't have + pp | did something unnecessary | You needn't have come. |
Never use the past form of the main verb after have. It must be the past participle.
Worked example 1
Correct: You should have went earlier. Step 1: after have use the past participle, gone. Answer: You should have gone earlier.
Worked example 2
Choose: The road is wet. It ___ have rained last night. Step 1: a strong conclusion from evidence. Answer: must.
Modal + have + past participle talks about the past.
Key takeaways
- Modal + have + past participle.
- Should have: missed duty. Must have: strong guess.
- Can't have: impossible in the past.
Check your understanding
-
1. Correct the error: He must have forgot his keys.
- He must had forgotten his keys.
- He must have forget his keys.
- He must has forgotten his keys.
- He must have forgotten his keys.
Show answer
Answer: D. After have use the past participle forgotten, and after must use have (never has or had).
-
2. The road is wet. It ___ rained last night.
- must have
- should have
- needn't have
- can't have
Show answer
Answer: A. Wet roads are strong evidence, so the conclusion is must have rained. Can't have would deny it, which the evidence contradicts.
-
3. Which sentence means the action was unnecessary?
- You must have come.
- You should have come.
- You needn't have come.
- You may have come.
Show answer
Answer: C. Needn't have + past participle says someone did something that was not necessary.
-
4. She was in Chennai all of last week, so she ___ attended the meeting in Delhi on Monday.
- must have
- can't have
- should have
- needn't have
Show answer
Answer: B. Being in another city makes it impossible, and past impossibility is can't have + past participle. Must have would claim she did attend.
-
5. Fill in the blank: You ___ locked the door; now a thief has got in.
- must have
- can't have
- needn't have
- should have
Show answer
Answer: D. The door was not locked and that was a mistake: should have + past participle expresses a right action not taken.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.