• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Modals with the perfect: must have, should have, could have

Use modal + have + past participle to talk about past possibility, missed advice and certainty.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

To speak about the past with a modal, use modal + have + past participle. This pattern appears often in exams.

Meanings

FormMeaningExample
must have + ppstrong belief about the pastHe must have missed the bus.
should have + ppsomething that was right to do but not doneYou should have told me.
could have + pppast possibility that did not happenShe could have won.
may/might have + pppast possibilityHe may have gone home.
needn't have + ppdid something unnecessaryYou needn't have come.

Never use the past form of the main verb after have. It must be the past participle.

Worked example 1

Correct: You should have went earlier. Step 1: after have use the past participle, gone. Answer: You should have gone earlier.

Worked example 2

Choose: The road is wet. It ___ have rained last night. Step 1: a strong conclusion from evidence. Answer: must.

Modal + have + past participle talks about the past.

Key takeaways

  • Modal + have + past participle.
  • Should have: missed duty. Must have: strong guess.
  • Can't have: impossible in the past.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Correct the error: He must have forgot his keys.

    1. He must had forgotten his keys.
    2. He must have forget his keys.
    3. He must has forgotten his keys.
    4. He must have forgotten his keys.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. After have use the past participle forgotten, and after must use have (never has or had).

  2. 2. The road is wet. It ___ rained last night.

    1. must have
    2. should have
    3. needn't have
    4. can't have
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Wet roads are strong evidence, so the conclusion is must have rained. Can't have would deny it, which the evidence contradicts.

  3. 3. Which sentence means the action was unnecessary?

    1. You must have come.
    2. You should have come.
    3. You needn't have come.
    4. You may have come.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Needn't have + past participle says someone did something that was not necessary.

  4. 4. She was in Chennai all of last week, so she ___ attended the meeting in Delhi on Monday.

    1. must have
    2. can't have
    3. should have
    4. needn't have
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Being in another city makes it impossible, and past impossibility is can't have + past participle. Must have would claim she did attend.

  5. 5. Fill in the blank: You ___ locked the door; now a thief has got in.

    1. must have
    2. can't have
    3. needn't have
    4. should have
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The door was not locked and that was a mistake: should have + past participle expresses a right action not taken.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Mixed modals practice

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery