• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Modals of certainty: exam-style problem set

Practise choosing must, can't, may, might and could (with have + participle for the past) when a sentence draws a conclusion or makes a guess.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Certainty questions give you a situation with evidence and ask what the speaker concludes. They look hard because every option is a modal, but there is a simple routine: decide how sure the speaker is, decide whether the time is now or past, then pick the form. This set drills the routine on five types.

The routine

  1. Is the speaker sure it is true? Use must. Sure it is not true? Use can't. Not sure? Use may, might or could.
  2. Is the time now or past? Now: base verb (or be + -ing). Past: have + participle.
  3. Check the rest of the sentence for words that confirm: probably, perhaps, certainly, clearly.
Quick map
Speaker's viewPresentPast
certain it is true*must be**must have been*
certain it is not true*can't be**can't have been*
possible*may / might / could be**may / might / could have been*
possible it is not*may not / might not be**may not / might not have been*

Type 1: evidence points to yes

Question: The ground is wet. It ___ in the night. Options: must have rained / can't have rained / should rain / may rain. Working: The speaker sees evidence and is sure about the past. Answer: must have rained.

Type 2: evidence points to no

Question: She has just left the house; she ___ at the station already. Options: must be / can't be / may be / needn't be. Working: She has only just left, so it is impossible that she is there. Answer: can't be.

Type 3: a guess without evidence

Question: I have no idea where Hari is. He ___ in the library. Options: must be / can't be / might be / should have been. Working: The speaker does not know, so possibility is expressed. Answer: might be.

Type 4: continuing actions

Question: The house is dark. They ___ asleep. Options: must be sleeping / must have sleep / can't sleeping / may sleeps. Working: A conclusion about now, with an action in progress: modal + be + -ing. Answer: must be sleeping.

Type 5: the strong negative trap

Question: He has not eaten all day, so he ___ hungry. Options: mustn't be / can't be / must be / needn't be. Working: Not eating all day suggests he is hungry. The speaker is sure, so must be. Mustn't be is never used for deduction; can't be would say he is certainly not hungry, which contradicts the evidence. Answer: must be.

Type 6: perfect forms with a clue

Question: His bag is gone; he ___ left already. Options: must have / can't have / shouldn't / needn't. Working: The missing bag is evidence about a finished action, so the speaker concludes with must have + participle. Answer: must have.

Traps

  • Using mustn't for a negative guess. Use can't.
  • Choosing the present form for a past clue: last night needs have + participle.
  • Choosing must when the speaker is guessing and uses words like perhaps or maybe.

Sure yes: must. Sure no: can't. Not sure: may, might, could. Past clue: add have + participle. Never mustn't for deduction.

Key takeaways

  • Measure the speaker's certainty first.
  • Match the time: now or past.
  • Look for confirming words like perhaps and certainly.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The ground is wet. It ___ in the night.

    1. must have rained
    2. can't have rained
    3. may rain
    4. should rain
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The speaker sees evidence about the past and is sure, so must have + participle.

  2. 2. She left only a minute ago; she ___ at the station yet.

    1. must be
    2. can't be
    3. may be
    4. needn't be
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It is impossible for her to be there already, so can't be.

  3. 3. I have no idea where Hari is. He ___ in the library.

    1. can't be
    2. must be
    3. might be
    4. should have been
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The speaker is guessing without evidence, so might be.

  4. 4. The house is dark. They ___ asleep.

    1. should have
    2. can't have
    3. might to be
    4. must be
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A conclusion about now: must be asleep.

  5. 5. He has not eaten all day, so he ___ hungry.

    1. mustn't be
    2. must be
    3. can't be
    4. needn't be
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The evidence supports a strong guess that he is hungry. Mustn't is not used for deduction.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery