- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Modals of certainty: exam-style problem set
Practise choosing must, can't, may, might and could (with have + participle for the past) when a sentence draws a conclusion or makes a guess.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Certainty questions give you a situation with evidence and ask what the speaker concludes. They look hard because every option is a modal, but there is a simple routine: decide how sure the speaker is, decide whether the time is now or past, then pick the form. This set drills the routine on five types.
The routine
- Is the speaker sure it is true? Use must. Sure it is not true? Use can't. Not sure? Use may, might or could.
- Is the time now or past? Now: base verb (or be + -ing). Past: have + participle.
- Check the rest of the sentence for words that confirm: probably, perhaps, certainly, clearly.
| Speaker's view | Present | Past |
|---|---|---|
| certain it is true | *must be* | *must have been* |
| certain it is not true | *can't be* | *can't have been* |
| possible | *may / might / could be* | *may / might / could have been* |
| possible it is not | *may not / might not be* | *may not / might not have been* |
Type 1: evidence points to yes
Question: The ground is wet. It ___ in the night. Options: must have rained / can't have rained / should rain / may rain. Working: The speaker sees evidence and is sure about the past. Answer: must have rained.
Type 2: evidence points to no
Question: She has just left the house; she ___ at the station already. Options: must be / can't be / may be / needn't be. Working: She has only just left, so it is impossible that she is there. Answer: can't be.
Type 3: a guess without evidence
Question: I have no idea where Hari is. He ___ in the library. Options: must be / can't be / might be / should have been. Working: The speaker does not know, so possibility is expressed. Answer: might be.
Type 4: continuing actions
Question: The house is dark. They ___ asleep. Options: must be sleeping / must have sleep / can't sleeping / may sleeps. Working: A conclusion about now, with an action in progress: modal + be + -ing. Answer: must be sleeping.
Type 5: the strong negative trap
Question: He has not eaten all day, so he ___ hungry. Options: mustn't be / can't be / must be / needn't be. Working: Not eating all day suggests he is hungry. The speaker is sure, so must be. Mustn't be is never used for deduction; can't be would say he is certainly not hungry, which contradicts the evidence. Answer: must be.
Type 6: perfect forms with a clue
Question: His bag is gone; he ___ left already. Options: must have / can't have / shouldn't / needn't. Working: The missing bag is evidence about a finished action, so the speaker concludes with must have + participle. Answer: must have.
Traps
- Using mustn't for a negative guess. Use can't.
- Choosing the present form for a past clue: last night needs have + participle.
- Choosing must when the speaker is guessing and uses words like perhaps or maybe.
Sure yes: must. Sure no: can't. Not sure: may, might, could. Past clue: add have + participle. Never mustn't for deduction.
Key takeaways
- Measure the speaker's certainty first.
- Match the time: now or past.
- Look for confirming words like perhaps and certainly.
Check your understanding
-
1. The ground is wet. It ___ in the night.
- must have rained
- can't have rained
- may rain
- should rain
Show answer
Answer: A. The speaker sees evidence about the past and is sure, so must have + participle.
-
2. She left only a minute ago; she ___ at the station yet.
- must be
- can't be
- may be
- needn't be
Show answer
Answer: B. It is impossible for her to be there already, so can't be.
-
3. I have no idea where Hari is. He ___ in the library.
- can't be
- must be
- might be
- should have been
Show answer
Answer: C. The speaker is guessing without evidence, so might be.
-
4. The house is dark. They ___ asleep.
- should have
- can't have
- might to be
- must be
Show answer
Answer: D. A conclusion about now: must be asleep.
-
5. He has not eaten all day, so he ___ hungry.
- mustn't be
- must be
- can't be
- needn't be
Show answer
Answer: B. The evidence supports a strong guess that he is hungry. Mustn't is not used for deduction.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.