- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Baseline study and predicting impacts
Describe what a baseline study records, sort impacts into their main types, and use a simple scoring matrix to rank which impacts matter most.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
You cannot say how much a project will change a place unless you know what the place is like now. That is the job of the baseline study. Once the baseline is known, the EIA predicts how the project will change it and judges which changes are serious. This lesson covers both steps in plain language, with a simple scoring method you can do by hand.
What the baseline records
| Part of the environment | Examples of what is recorded |
|---|---|
| Air | Dust and gases in the air, wind direction |
| Water | River flow, water quality, groundwater level |
| Land | Soil type, land use, slopes and erosion |
| Noise | Present noise levels near homes and schools |
| Living things | Plants, animals, birds, fish, any rare species |
| People | Population, jobs, health, homes, cultural sites |
Baseline data should cover the different seasons, because a place in the monsoon, in winter and in summer can look very different. It should also cover the area that the project could reach, not just the site itself: a river carries pollution downstream, and wind carries dust beyond the boundary wall.
Baseline information comes from two sources. Existing records, such as weather data, earlier surveys and maps, give a starting picture. Field surveys fill the gaps: teams take water and air samples, count birds and trees, and talk to local people about how they use the land and water. Local knowledge is especially useful for things that are rare or seasonal, such as a stream that flows only after the rains.
How impacts are predicted
Prediction is an informed estimate, not a guess. Experts use three main tools. They study similar projects elsewhere to see what actually happened there. They use models, which are calculations that estimate, for example, how far dust will spread with the wind or how much a river will be diluted. And they use expert judgement where numbers are hard to get, such as the effect on a rare bird's breeding. Because every prediction carries some uncertainty, a good EIA says how sure it is, and leans towards caution when the possible harm is serious.
Types of impacts
- Positive or negative: jobs and better roads are positive; pollution and loss of forest are negative.
- Direct or indirect: cutting trees for a mine is direct; new shops and houses that spring up along a new road, and their waste, are indirect.
- Short-term or long-term: dust during building is short-term; a reservoir that floods a valley is long-term.
- Reversible or irreversible: noise stops when work stops; the extinction of a species can never be undone.
- Cumulative: small effects from several projects that add up to a large effect in the same area.
Worked example 1: classify the impact
A dam is built. (1) Construction trucks raise dust for two years. (2) A valley with an old temple is permanently flooded. (3) Farmers downstream get irrigation water. Impact 1 is negative, direct, short-term and reversible. Impact 2 is negative, direct, long-term and irreversible. Impact 3 is positive. Seeing which impacts are irreversible is the most important part: those deserve the most attention, because no later action can fix them.
A simple scoring matrix
A matrix is a table that lists the project's actions down one side and parts of the environment along the top. In each box, experts give a score for magnitude (how big the change is) and importance (how much that change matters). Multiplying the two gives a rough significance score, which helps rank the impacts. Scores are judgements, so the method helps organise thinking rather than giving an exact answer.
Worked example 2: ranking with scores
Score each impact from 1 to 5 for magnitude and importance. Dust during building: magnitude 3, importance 2, score 3 × 2 = 6. Loss of a wetland used by migratory birds: magnitude 4, importance 5, score 4 × 5 = 20. Extra traffic: magnitude 3, importance 3, score 9. Ranking from most to least significant: wetland loss (20), traffic (9), dust (6). The study should spend most effort on the wetland. All scores here are made up for practice.
Baseline first: you cannot measure change without knowing the starting point. Significance ≈ magnitude × importance. Irreversible impacts deserve the most attention.
Key takeaways: the baseline records air, water, land, noise, living things and people, across seasons and over the whole area the project could affect; impacts can be positive or negative, direct or indirect, short or long term, reversible or irreversible, and cumulative; a matrix that multiplies magnitude by importance helps rank impacts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why should baseline data cover different seasons?
- Because conditions such as river flow and air quality change with the seasons
- Because projects are built only in summer and need summer data
- Because the law requires exactly one day of data in a single month
- Because seasons do not affect the environment of a site in any way
Show answer
Answer: A. A river or air quality can differ greatly between monsoon, winter and summer, so one season can give a misleading picture.
-
2. New shops and houses that spring up along a new highway, adding waste and traffic, are an example of:
- A direct impact
- A baseline study
- A no-project alternative
- An indirect impact
Show answer
Answer: D. These effects are caused by changes the highway brings, not by the highway itself, so they are indirect.
-
3. Which impact is irreversible?
- Extinction of a plant species found only at the site
- Noise from machines during the construction period
- Dust raised by trucks during the building work
- Traffic jams on the approach road during a festival
Show answer
Answer: A. Extinction can never be undone; the other effects stop when the activity stops.
-
4. An impact has magnitude 4 and importance 3 on a 1 to 5 scale. Its significance score by the method in this lesson is:
- 7
- 1
- 12
- 43
Show answer
Answer: C. Significance = magnitude × importance = 4 × 3 = 12.
-
5. Several small factories each add a little pollution to the same river until together the river is badly polluted. This is called:
- A positive impact
- A cumulative impact
- A reversible impact
- A short-term impact
Show answer
Answer: B. Effects from several projects that add up in the same area are cumulative impacts.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.