- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Screening and scoping: deciding what to study
Explain how projects are sorted by size and location in screening, and how scoping chooses the issues and alternatives an EIA must study.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every project needs the same amount of study. A small bakery and a large dam are obviously different. The first two stages of EIA, screening and scoping, make sure that effort matches the risk: big, risky projects get careful study, small harmless ones are not buried in paperwork, and every study focuses on what really matters.
Screening: sorting projects
Screening decides whether a project needs an EIA and, if so, how detailed it should be. Countries usually sort projects into categories by scale and likely impact. Large projects, or projects of a polluting type, go to the highest level of study and are often decided at a higher level of government. Medium projects may get a lighter study. Small projects with little impact may need no EIA at all. The exact limits are set by each country's rules and change from time to time, so for exams the idea matters more than any number.
Size is not the only test. Location matters too. A modest project next to a national park, a wetland, a coastline, a drinking-water source or a crowded town may need more study than a bigger project in a less sensitive place. Screening therefore asks two questions together: how big and what kind is the project, and how sensitive is the place?
Worked example 1: screening with a made-up rule
Suppose an imaginary country's rule says: a factory using more than 100 units of land needs a full EIA; one using 20 to 100 units needs a short EIA; one below 20 units needs none, but any factory within 5 km of a protected area moves up one level. Factory P uses 150 units, far from any protected area: full EIA. Factory Q uses 60 units, far away: short EIA. Factory R uses 15 units but sits 2 km from a protected area: it would need none, but location moves it up one level, so it needs a short EIA. The numbers here are invented for practice; real limits are in each country's rules.
Scoping: choosing the issues
Once a project is screened in, scoping decides what the study must cover. Experts, officials and often the public list the possible effects, then pick out the significant ones. The result is usually written as terms of reference, a work plan for the study. Scoping saves time and money by dropping trivial issues, and it protects quality by making sure no major issue is forgotten.
Scoping also lists alternatives to be compared: other sites, other designs, other technologies, and the no-project alternative, which means what would happen if the project were not built at all. Comparing with the no-project case shows how much change the project itself causes.
Worked example 2: scoping a highway
A new four-lane highway is planned across farmland and a forest edge. Possible issues: loss of farmland, cutting of trees, wild animals crossing the road, noise near a village school, dust during building, and the colour of the road signs. Scoping keeps the first five because they could be significant, and drops the colour of the signs because it has no real environmental effect. Alternatives to study: a route that avoids the forest edge, an elevated section with animal underpasses, and the no-project case.
Screening = whether and how much study (by size, type and location). Scoping = what to study (key issues and alternatives, including the no-project option).
Key takeaways: screening sorts projects into categories by scale and type, and a sensitive location can raise the level; exact thresholds belong to each country's rules and change over time; scoping chooses the significant issues and writes them into terms of reference; alternatives, including the no-project option, are part of scoping.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which two things does screening mainly look at?
- The colour, shape and architectural style of the buildings
- The size and type of the project, and the sensitivity of its location
- The company's expected profit and its share price on the stock market
- The number of workers employed and their monthly salaries
Show answer
Answer: B. Screening considers how big and what kind the project is, and whether the site is sensitive.
-
2. What is the 'no-project alternative' in an EIA?
- Building the project at once without any environmental study
- A smaller version of the project run with fewer workers
- Cancelling the EIA after the baseline has been recorded
- What would happen if the project were not built at all
Show answer
Answer: D. The no-project alternative is the baseline future without the project, used to compare with the options.
-
3. Using the made-up rule from this lesson (more than 100 units: full EIA; 20 to 100: short EIA; below 20: none; within 5 km of a protected area moves up one level), a factory using 70 units placed 3 km from a protected area needs:
- No EIA
- A full EIA
- A short EIA
- Only monitoring
Show answer
Answer: B. 70 units alone gives a short EIA; being within 5 km of a protected area moves it up one level, to a full EIA.
-
4. The written work plan that comes out of scoping is usually called:
- Terms of reference
- Monitoring report
- Baseline data
- Final approval
Show answer
Answer: A. Scoping produces terms of reference that say what the EIA study must cover.
-
5. Why is scoping useful?
- It replaces the need for a baseline study of the site's air and water
- It focuses the study on significant issues and makes sure none is forgotten
- It gives final approval to the project once the report is read
- It measures pollution after the project has started operating
Show answer
Answer: B. Scoping drops trivial issues and keeps important ones, saving effort and improving quality.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.