- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
ODP-weighted emissions and chained percentage problems
Practise the two calculation types that mix up students most: weighting emissions by ozone depletion potential, and combining successive percentage changes without adding them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Numerical questions on ozone usually come in two flavours. In the first, several chemicals with different strengths are released and you must compare their total effect. In the second, ozone or an allowed quantity changes by one percentage after another and you must combine them. Neither needs more than multiplication, but both have a classic wrong answer that appears among the options. This lesson gives a method for each and a list of traps.
ODP-weighted emissions
The ozone depletion potential (ODP) of a substance compares the ozone destroyed by a given mass of it with the ozone destroyed by the same mass of CFC-11, which is the reference with ODP = 1. To compare emissions of different substances, multiply each mass by its ODP and add. The answer is in tonnes of CFC-11 equivalent. A substance with a very small mass but a high ODP can matter more than a large mass of a weak one. A substance with ODP = 0, such as an HFC, adds nothing to this total however large its mass. The ODP values in the examples below are invented for practice; real values depend on the substance and the method of calculation.
CFC-11 equivalent = Σ (mass × ODP). Zero ODP adds zero, whatever the mass.
Combining percentage changes
When a quantity changes by successive percentages, convert each change into a multiplier and multiply them. A fall of 20% is a multiplier of 0.80; a fall of 25% is 0.75; a rise of 10% is 1.10. Never add the percentages, because the second change is taken on the new value. The same logic explains why a recovery needs a bigger percentage rise than the fall that caused it.
| Situation | Wrong method | Right method |
|---|---|---|
| Two successive falls of 20% then 25% | Add: total fall 45% | Multiply: 0.80 × 0.75 = 0.60, so total fall 40% |
| Fall of 40% then recovery to the start | Recovery of 40% | Start 100, now 60; rise needed = 40 ÷ 60 = 66.7% |
| Allowed amount falls from 80% to 30% of baseline | 'Fell by 30%' | Fell 50 percentage points; relative cut = 50 ÷ 80 = 62.5% |
Worked example 1: weighting emissions
Example 1. Three substances are released (all values illustrative). Substance X: 200 t with ODP 1.0. Substance Y: 1,000 t with ODP 0.05. Substance Z: 30 t with ODP 10. Find the total in CFC-11 equivalent and say which substance contributes most. Working: X gives 200 × 1.0 = 200 t. Y gives 1,000 × 0.05 = 50 t. Z gives 30 × 10 = 300 t. Total = 200 + 50 + 300 = 550 t of CFC-11 equivalent. Z contributes the most (300 of 550, about 55%), although it has the smallest mass. The mistake to avoid is adding the masses (1,230 t) and ignoring the ODPs.
Worked example 2: successive falls and recovery
Example 2. Total ozone over a place is 300 DU. In one decade it falls 20%, and in the next the fall is 25% of the value at the start of that decade (illustrative figures). Find the final value and the total percentage fall. Working: after the first fall, 300 × 0.80 = 240 DU. After the second, 240 × 0.75 = 180 DU. Total fall = 300 − 180 = 120 DU, which is 120 ÷ 300 × 100 = 40%. Now, how much must it rise to return to 300 DU? Rise = 120 DU on a base of 180 DU, so 120 ÷ 180 × 100 = 66.7%. The recovery percentage is larger than the fall because it is measured from a smaller base.
Worked example 3: percentage points
Example 3. A protocol allows a country 80% of its baseline consumption in one stage and 30% in the next. What is the cut? Working: in percentage points of baseline, 80 − 30 = 50 points. As a percentage of the earlier allowance, 50 ÷ 80 × 100 = 62.5%. If the baseline is 1,600 t, the allowance falls from 1,280 t to 480 t, a drop of 800 t, which is 50% of the baseline and 62.5% of the earlier allowance. A question will say which of these it wants; read the wording.
Traps in this topic
- Adding successive percentages instead of multiplying the multipliers.
- Using the end value as the base when asked for the percentage fall.
- Ignoring the ODP and adding raw masses.
- Treating a large tonnage of a zero-ODP gas as a large ozone problem; it may be a climate problem instead.
- Mixing percentage points and percent.
Key takeaways: weight by ODP before adding; combine percentage changes by multiplying the multipliers; take every percentage change from its own starting value; and keep percentage points apart from percent.
Check your understanding
-
1. Substances (illustrative): P 300 t with ODP 1, Q 500 t with ODP 0.1, R 40 t with ODP 5. What is the total in CFC-11 equivalent?
- 840 t
- 550 t
- 350 t
- 1,540 t
Show answer
Answer: B. P gives 300 × 1 = 300, Q gives 500 × 0.1 = 50, R gives 40 × 5 = 200. Total = 550 t. The 840 t option adds the raw masses.
-
2. Ozone falls by 10%, then by a further 10% of the new value. What is the total fall?
- 20%
- 21%
- 10%
- 19%
Show answer
Answer: D. The multiplier is 0.9 × 0.9 = 0.81, so the total fall is 1 − 0.81 = 19%. Adding 10% + 10% to get 20% ignores the smaller base.
-
3. A halon has ODP 10 and a mass of 10 t; an HFC of ODP 0 has a mass of 1,000 t (both illustrative). Which statement is correct?
- Halon adds 100 t CFC-11 equivalent, HFC none
- The HFC harms ozone more because of its mass
- Both add equally to the loss of ozone
- Neither one can harm the ozone layer
Show answer
Answer: A. Halon: 10 × 10 = 100 t CFC-11 equivalent. HFC: 1,000 × 0 = 0. The HFC may still warm the climate, but it does not deplete ozone.
-
4. Allowed consumption falls from 80% to 30% of baseline. By what percentage of the earlier allowance does it fall?
- 50%
- 37.5%
- 62.5%
- 80%
Show answer
Answer: C. The fall is 50 percentage points; 50 ÷ 80 × 100 = 62.5% of the earlier allowance. 50% is the number of percentage points, not the share of the earlier allowance.
-
5. Ozone falls from 300 DU to 225 DU and then recovers to 300 DU. What is the percentage rise during recovery?
- 25.0%
- 75.0%
- 20.0%
- 33.3%
Show answer
Answer: D. The rise is 75 DU on a base of 225 DU: 75 ÷ 225 × 100 = 33.3%. Using 300 as the base would give the wrong 25%.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.