- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Ozone depletion versus global warming: comparison questions and the GWP trap
Practise telling the two problems apart, using ODP and global warming potential (GWP) correctly, and avoiding the traps in statements about HFCs, CFCs and ground-level ozone.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions that compare ozone depletion with global warming are popular because the wrong options are easy to write. Both involve gases made by human activity, both concern the atmosphere, and several chemicals appear in both stories. The safe approach is to keep two separate checklists, one for each problem, and then ask what a particular chemical does on each list.
Two problems, two checklists
| Question to ask | Ozone depletion | Global warming |
|---|---|---|
| What goes wrong? | Less UV-B absorbed in the stratosphere | More infrared trapped in the troposphere |
| Key gases | CFCs, halons, methyl bromide, HCFCs | CO₂, CH₄, N₂O, CFCs, HFCs, water vapour |
| Harm measured by | ODP | GWP |
| Main effects | Skin cancer, cataract, damage to plankton and crops | Rising temperature, sea level, changing climate |
| Main treaty | Montreal Protocol (Kigali also covers HFCs) | Framework convention and later climate agreements |
What ODP and GWP measure
ODP compares a substance with CFC-11 for ozone destruction per kilogram. Global warming potential (GWP) compares the warming effect of a kilogram of a gas over a chosen time, usually 100 years, with a kilogram of carbon dioxide, which has GWP = 1. To express an emission in terms of carbon dioxide, multiply the mass by the GWP to get tonnes of CO₂ equivalent. The two scales are independent: a gas can have a high ODP and a high GWP (CFCs), zero ODP and a high GWP (many HFCs), or a low value on both. The numbers used below are invented for practice, since the real values depend on the time period and on revisions.
Worked example 1: CO₂ equivalent
Example 1. A leak releases 2 tonnes of a refrigerant gas. Its GWP is taken as 1,300 and its ODP as 0 (illustrative values). Find the CO₂ equivalent and say what the leak does to the ozone layer. Working: CO₂ equivalent = 2 × 1,300 = 2,600 tonnes. ODP = 0, so no ozone depletion: 2 × 0 = 0 tonnes CFC-11 equivalent. The leak is a climate problem but not an ozone problem.
Worked example 2: choosing between two substitutes
Example 2. Substitute A has ODP 0.05 and GWP 1,800. Substitute B has ODP 0 and GWP 150. Substitute C has ODP 0 and GWP 4 (all illustrative). Rank them from best to worst for the environment as a whole. Working: C is best because it has no ozone effect and the smallest warming effect. B is next: no ozone effect and a small warming effect. A is worst: it still depletes ozone, if only weakly, and has the highest warming effect. Order: C, B, A. Notice that this ranking uses both scales; a question that asks only about the ozone layer would call B and C equal.
Worked example 3: which problem?
Example 3. For each statement say whether it describes ozone depletion, global warming or both. (a) Sea level rises because warm water expands. (b) Skin cancer cases may rise. (c) CFCs contribute. (d) Ground-level ozone from vehicle emissions traps heat and harms lungs. Working: (a) global warming. (b) ozone depletion, since more UV-B reaches the ground. (c) both, because CFCs destroy ozone and are greenhouse gases. (d) ground-level ozone is a pollutant and also a greenhouse gas, but it is not the stratospheric ozone that is depleted, so this is a global warming and air pollution statement, not an ozone depletion one.
Traps
- 'Banning CFCs fixed global warming.' No: CO₂ is the main driver, though CFC control helped.
- 'HFCs are completely harmless.' No: zero ODP but often high GWP.
- 'The ozone hole lets heat escape.' No: it is a UV problem.
- 'Ground-level ozone is the same as the ozone layer.' Same molecule, different location and effect.
- 'A higher ODP always means a higher GWP.' The scales are independent.
ODP is about ozone and UV-B; GWP is about warming. A gas can score high on one, both, or neither.
Key takeaways: keep separate checklists for the two problems; use the product mass × GWP for CO₂ equivalent and mass × ODP for CFC-11 equivalent; and read the statement carefully to see which problem it describes.
Check your understanding
-
1. 2 tonnes of a gas with GWP 800 (illustrative) are released. What is the CO₂ equivalent?
- 1,600 tonnes
- 400 tonnes
- 802 tonnes
- 0.0025 tonnes
Show answer
Answer: A. CO₂ equivalent = mass × GWP = 2 × 800 = 1,600 tonnes. Dividing the mass by the GWP is the usual error.
-
2. Which gas could have ODP = 0 and still a high GWP?
- CFC-11
- Halon
- An HFC
- Methyl bromide
Show answer
Answer: C. HFCs have no chlorine or bromine, so ODP is zero, but many are strong greenhouse gases. CFC-11 and halons have positive ODP.
-
3. Which statement describes ozone depletion rather than global warming?
- Glaciers melt at a faster rate
- More UV-B reaches the ground
- Sea level rises along the coast
- Nights become warmer everywhere
Show answer
Answer: B. Ozone depletion means more UV-B at the surface. The other effects follow from warming.
-
4. Substitute X has ODP 0 and GWP 2,000; Y has ODP 0 and GWP 20 (illustrative). For the ozone layer alone, which is better?
- X is better as its GWP is higher
- Y is better as its GWP is lower
- X is better as its ODP is zero
- Equal, as both have ODP 0
Show answer
Answer: D. Both have ODP = 0, so they are equal for the ozone layer. The difference between them is in the climate effect, where Y is better.
-
5. Why is the statement 'The ozone hole is the main cause of global warming' wrong?
- Greenhouse gases are the main cause
- The ozone hole cools the whole planet
- Ozone is not found in the air at all
- The ozone hole lies over the Arctic
Show answer
Answer: A. Global warming is driven mainly by carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases that trap infrared radiation. The ozone hole is a UV problem.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.