- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Naming the ethical issues
Turn the facts of a case into precisely named ethical issues and conflicts of values, using a checklist of common issues in public and corporate settings.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
After reading the case and mapping stakeholders, the next step is to name the ethical issues. Examiners give marks for precision: 'conflict of interest' is better than 'something wrong', and 'conflict between compassion and rule-based fairness' is better than 'it is a dilemma'.
Issue or dilemma?
An ethical issue is any matter where right and wrong are at stake, such as a bribe offer. An ethical dilemma is a situation where two or more values pull in opposite directions, so that honouring one means sacrificing part of another, such as keeping a promise of confidentiality versus preventing harm. Many cases contain both: a clear wrong to resist and a genuine dilemma about how to respond.
Checklist of common issues
| Issue | Typical signal in the case |
|---|---|
| Integrity and corruption | Bribe, gift, kickback, falsified record |
| Conflict of interest | Relative, friend, shares, future job |
| Misuse of public resources | Government vehicle, funds, staff used privately |
| Fairness and impartiality | Favour to some applicants, discrimination |
| Transparency | Hidden lists, unexplained decisions |
| Accountability | Nobody answers for a failure; blame-shifting |
| Compassion versus rules | Needy person who does not meet a requirement |
| Loyalty versus honesty | Senior or colleague asks you to cover up |
| Public interest versus private interest | Development project harming a community; profit versus safety |
| Professional duty versus personal safety | Threats for doing the job |
How to phrase issues
- Use the value names: 'integrity', 'impartiality', 'accountability', 'compassion'.
- For dilemmas, name both sides: 'X versus Y'.
- Link to the facts: 'conflict of interest, since the bidder is the officer's brother-in-law'.
- List three to five issues, most important first.
Worked example 1
Case: 'A hospital superintendent learns that a senior doctor, a friend, regularly sends patients to his private clinic for tests that the hospital could do free.' Issues: (1) conflict of interest, since the doctor profits from referrals; (2) misuse of public office and resources; (3) harm to poor patients who pay for free services; (4) loyalty to a friend versus duty to patients and the institution, a dilemma for the superintendent. Precise, linked to facts, ordered by importance.
Worked example 2
Case: 'A journalist asks a police officer for the names of minors arrested in a riot.' Issues: (1) transparency and the public's right to know versus (2) privacy and protection of minors, which law and ethics strongly protect; (3) the officer's duty to be accurate if information is released. The dilemma is real but resolved here by the strong protection owed to children: the officer can share the facts of the incident and action taken without naming minors.
Name the issue precisely, tie it to a fact, and for a dilemma name both values: X versus Y.
Key takeaways
- An issue involves right and wrong; a dilemma sets values against each other.
- Use a checklist to spot issues quickly.
- Phrase issues with value names linked to facts.
- Order issues by importance.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is an ethical dilemma rather than a simple ethical issue?
- A contractor offers a bribe to clear a pending bill quietly
- An officer is tempted to use a government car for a family holiday trip
- Keeping a promise of confidentiality versus warning someone of serious harm
- A clerk falsifies attendance records to cover his absence
Show answer
Answer: C. A dilemma sets two genuine values against each other; the others are wrongs to resist.
-
2. A doctor in a public hospital refers patients to his own private clinic for tests. The most precise issue is:
- Conflict of interest
- Political neutrality
- Tolerance
- Ministerial responsibility
Show answer
Answer: A. The doctor's private interest conflicts with his public duty to patients.
-
3. Which phrasing of an issue is strongest?
- Something is seriously wrong here and the matter needs to be looked into
- It is a problem for the department and for the people
- Bad behaviour by the officer, which is not acceptable to anyone
- Conflict of interest, since the bidder is the officer's brother-in-law
Show answer
Answer: D. Precise value names linked to facts earn marks.
-
4. A journalist asks for the names of arrested minors. The best resolution is to:
- Release all names in the interest of transparency and the public right to know
- Share facts of the incident and action taken without naming minors
- Refuse to say anything at all about the incident or the action taken
- Release the names off the record to a trusted reporter
Show answer
Answer: B. Transparency is served without breaching the strong protection owed to children.
-
5. A senior colleague asks you to hide his mistake. The dilemma is best named:
- Loyalty versus honesty
- Efficiency versus speed
- Tolerance versus compassion
- Neutrality versus objectivity
Show answer
Answer: A. The pull of loyalty to a colleague conflicts with honesty and accountability.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.