• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Reading the case: facts and stakeholders

Read a case carefully to separate facts from assumptions, identify your role and powers, and list every stakeholder with their interests.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many weak answers start going wrong in the first minute, because the student misreads the case: adds facts that are not there, forgets what role they are in, or misses someone affected. This lesson teaches careful reading and stakeholder mapping.

Step 1: separate facts from assumptions

Read the case twice. The first time, understand the story. The second time, underline what is actually stated. Then note what is not stated. If the case does not say a senior is corrupt, do not assume it; he may be under pressure himself. Good answers work with given facts and, where something is unclear, say 'I would first verify...' rather than inventing details.

Step 2: identify your role and powers

  • Who are you in the case: a district collector, a junior engineer, a company manager, a citizen?
  • What can someone in that role actually do: order an inquiry, report to a senior, refuse to sign, call a meeting?
  • What can you not do: a junior engineer cannot transfer his superior; a citizen cannot suspend an official.

Your course of action must fit your role. A frequent mistake is to act like a minister when the case makes you a section officer.

Step 3: list stakeholders

A stakeholder is anyone who affects or is affected by the decision. Think in rings: people directly involved; the organisation; the people served; society and future generations. For each, note their interest, meaning what they want or stand to lose.

Stakeholder map for a factory pollution case
StakeholderInterest
Villagers downstreamClean water, health, livelihood from farming and fishing
Factory workersJobs and wages
Factory ownersProfit, continued operation
You, the pollution control officerDoing your duty, career, safety from pressure
Pollution control boardCredibility, enforcing law
Local political leadersVotes from both villagers and workers
Future generationsA river that remains usable

Worked example 1: reading carefully

Case line: 'Your superior asks you to clear the file by evening without the site report.' Facts: a request to clear without a site report, with a deadline. Not stated: why he asked, whether it is legal in this kind of case, whether he benefits. Good reading: 'I would first check whether the rules allow clearance without a site report. If not, I would explain this to my superior and ask for time or written instructions.' Poor reading: 'My corrupt superior wants a bribe.'

Worked example 2: finding hidden stakeholders

Case: a school principal must decide whether to expel a student caught selling answer keys. Obvious stakeholders: the student, the principal, the teachers. Less obvious: other students whose exam was unfair; the student's family; future students who will learn what the school tolerates; the exam board's credibility. Including hidden stakeholders makes your analysis fuller and often changes the best decision, for example by adding a fair re-test for affected students.

Read twice, use only given facts, know your role and powers, and map stakeholders in rings from the closest to future generations.

Key takeaways

  • Do not invent facts; verify what is unclear.
  • Your course of action must fit your role's powers.
  • Stakeholders include those affected indirectly and in the future.
  • Note each stakeholder's interest, not just their name.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A case says your senior asked you to clear a file quickly. The best approach is to:

    1. Assume he is corrupt and refuse to clear the file at all
    2. Work with stated facts and verify whether the request is lawful
    3. Ignore the request and leave the file lying with the clerk
    4. Report him to the police immediately without checking any facts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Good answers do not invent facts; they verify what is unclear before acting.

  2. 2. As a junior engineer in a case, which action is outside your powers?

    1. Refusing to sign a false certificate of work
    2. Recording your objection in writing to the senior
    3. Transferring your superior to another district
    4. Reporting the matter to a higher authority
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A junior engineer cannot transfer a superior; the other actions are within his role.

  3. 3. A stakeholder is best defined as:

    1. Anyone who affects or is affected by the decision
    2. Only people who have money invested in the matter
    3. Only government officials working on the matter
    4. Only the person making the final decision
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Stakeholders include everyone who affects or is affected, directly or indirectly.

  4. 4. In a case about a student selling answer keys, which is a hidden stakeholder?

    1. The student who sold the answer keys
    2. The principal of the school
    3. The teacher who caught him with the keys
    4. Other students whose exam was made unfair
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Other students were harmed by the leak; including them may change the best decision.

  5. 5. Why include future generations in a pollution case?

    1. They can vote now and so will influence this decision
    2. They will bear the long-term effects of damage to the river
    3. They own the factory that is polluting the river
    4. Examiners require them to be named in every case
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Environmental harm often falls on people not yet born; good analysis includes them.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Naming the ethical issues

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery