- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Options and their consequences
Generate realistic options for a case, test each against law, ethics, stakeholders and practicality, and avoid the common trap of only two extreme choices.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many case questions ask: 'What options are available to you? Evaluate each.' Strong answers show three or four realistic options, examine merits and demerits honestly, and then choose. Weak answers show only two extremes, such as 'obey' and 'resign'.
Generating options
- The easy option: go along with the pressure.
- The passive option: do nothing, delay or pass the problem on.
- The extreme option: dramatic confrontation, resignation, going to the media.
- The balanced options: one or two middle paths that solve the problem lawfully and fairly.
Listing the easy and extreme options shows you understand the temptations; developing the balanced ones shows judgement.
Four tests for each option
| Test | Question |
|---|---|
| Legal | Is it within the law and rules? |
| Ethical | Does it respect integrity, fairness and the dignity of those affected? |
| Stakeholder | Who gains and who loses? Are the most vulnerable protected? |
| Practical | Can someone in my role actually do it, now? |
Worked example: the flood relief list
Case: 'As a tehsildar, you prepare a list of flood-affected families for relief. A local leader insists that 40 names of his supporters, who were not affected, be added; otherwise he will stop relief work through protests.' Options and evaluation:
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Add the 40 names | Avoids protest; relief continues smoothly | Illegal; diverts aid from victims; rewards pressure |
| Do nothing and wait | Avoids immediate conflict | Delays relief to genuine victims; problem remains |
| Publicly expose the leader through media | Shows firmness | May inflame tension and stop relief; escalates unnecessarily |
| Verify all names openly in a village meeting, display the final list, offer to examine any genuinely missed household, inform the collector and request police support if needed | Lawful, fair, transparent; genuine cases are not missed; pressure is recorded | Takes effort; leader may still protest |
Decision: the fourth option. It passes all four tests. It also includes a fair answer to the leader: any genuinely affected household he points out will be verified and added. That reduces the conflict without giving in.
Common traps
- Only two options, both extreme.
- Options that are not really different (three versions of 'refuse').
- Ignoring the demerits of your preferred option.
- Options outside your role's powers.
Lay out the easy, passive, extreme and balanced options; test each for legality, ethics, stakeholders and practicality; then choose.
Key takeaways
- Show three or four distinct options.
- Evaluate each honestly with merits and demerits.
- The best option is usually balanced, lawful and practical.
- A good option often includes a fair response to the other side's legitimate concerns.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which set of options is weakest for a case answer?
- Obey, delay, escalate, balanced verification
- Obey or resign
- Refuse with reasons, record, escalate
- Verify publicly, inform authority, offer fair review
Show answer
Answer: B. Only two extreme options show little judgement.
-
2. The 'practical' test asks:
- Is it legal under every relevant statute?
- Is it popular with the public and press?
- Can someone in my role actually do it now?
- Does it make me famous in the department?
Show answer
Answer: C. Practicality concerns whether the action is within the role's powers and feasible.
-
3. In the flood relief case, adding the 40 names fails mainly because it:
- Is illegal and diverts aid from genuine victims
- Takes too long to complete before the next distribution
- Requires a meeting of the village committee first
- Needs police support that is not available locally
Show answer
Answer: A. It is unlawful and unfair, and it rewards pressure.
-
4. Why does the chosen option include offering to verify any genuinely missed household the leader points out?
- To give in to the pressure applied by the leader and his supporters at the camp
- To delay relief supplies until the leader and the villagers have calmed down after the dispute
- To punish the leader for making an unlawful demand in front of the villagers
- To answer legitimate concerns fairly and reduce conflict without yielding to unlawful demands
Show answer
Answer: D. Fairness to genuine claims lowers tension while unlawful additions are still refused.
-
5. Which is a common trap when presenting options?
- Stating demerits of each option
- Listing options that are really the same
- Testing options against the law
- Considering vulnerable stakeholders
Show answer
Answer: B. Options must be genuinely different; three versions of 'refuse' add nothing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.