Revision notes

Case Study Approach: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What an ethics case study is

Theory questionCase study
Tests knowledge of conceptsTests application of concepts to a situation
Often has a standard answerSeveral reasonable answers; quality of reasoning matters
Example: define integrityExample: a senior asks you to change a report; what will you do?
Marks for accuracy and clarityMarks for identifying issues, weighing options and a practical, ethical decision

A case study tests judgement, not memory: see the facts, name the issues, see everyone affected, weigh options, decide and explain.

  • Case studies test application, not recall.
  • There can be several reasonable answers; reasoning earns marks.
  • Examiners look for issues, stakeholders, options, a clear decision and practicality.
  • Some cases have no villain and test fairness under scarcity.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Reading the case: facts and stakeholders

Stakeholder map for a factory pollution case
StakeholderInterest
Villagers downstreamClean water, health, livelihood from farming and fishing
Factory workersJobs and wages
Factory ownersProfit, continued operation
You, the pollution control officerDoing your duty, career, safety from pressure
Pollution control boardCredibility, enforcing law
Local political leadersVotes from both villagers and workers
Future generationsA river that remains usable

Read twice, use only given facts, know your role and powers, and map stakeholders in rings from the closest to future generations.

  • Do not invent facts; verify what is unclear.
  • Your course of action must fit your role's powers.
  • Stakeholders include those affected indirectly and in the future.
  • Note each stakeholder's interest, not just their name.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Naming the ethical issues

IssueTypical signal in the case
Integrity and corruptionBribe, gift, kickback, falsified record
Conflict of interestRelative, friend, shares, future job
Misuse of public resourcesGovernment vehicle, funds, staff used privately
Fairness and impartialityFavour to some applicants, discrimination
TransparencyHidden lists, unexplained decisions
AccountabilityNobody answers for a failure; blame-shifting
Compassion versus rulesNeedy person who does not meet a requirement
Loyalty versus honestySenior or colleague asks you to cover up
Public interest versus private interestDevelopment project harming a community; profit versus safety
Professional duty versus personal safetyThreats for doing the job

Name the issue precisely, tie it to a fact, and for a dilemma name both values: X versus Y.

  • An issue involves right and wrong; a dilemma sets values against each other.
  • Use a checklist to spot issues quickly.
  • Phrase issues with value names linked to facts.
  • Order issues by importance.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Options and their consequences

TestQuestion
LegalIs it within the law and rules?
EthicalDoes it respect integrity, fairness and the dignity of those affected?
StakeholderWho gains and who loses? Are the most vulnerable protected?
PracticalCan someone in my role actually do it, now?
OptionMeritsDemerits
Add the 40 namesAvoids protest; relief continues smoothlyIllegal; diverts aid from victims; rewards pressure
Do nothing and waitAvoids immediate conflictDelays relief to genuine victims; problem remains
Publicly expose the leader through mediaShows firmnessMay inflame tension and stop relief; escalates unnecessarily
Verify all names openly in a village meeting, display the final list, offer to examine any genuinely missed household, inform the collector and request police support if neededLawful, fair, transparent; genuine cases are not missed; pressure is recordedTakes effort; leader may still protest

Lay out the easy, passive, extreme and balanced options; test each for legality, ethics, stakeholders and practicality; then choose.

  • Show three or four distinct options.
  • Evaluate each honestly with merits and demerits.
  • The best option is usually balanced, lawful and practical.
  • A good option often includes a fair response to the other side's legitimate concerns.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Writing the answer: a reliable structure

Approximate share for a 250-word answer
PartShare
IntroductionAbout 10 percent
Stakeholders and issuesAbout 25 percent
OptionsAbout 25 percent
Course of action and justificationAbout 30 percent
ConclusionAbout 10 percent

Issue, stakeholders, ethical issues, options, numbered course of action, justification, conclusion: protect people first, verify, record, involve authority, fix the system.

  • Use the seven-part structure as a default.
  • Adapt the word share to what the question asks.
  • Courses of action should be numbered, timed and within your role.
  • Always end with a lasting system fix.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery