- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Assessing emotional intelligence: ability tests, self-report, 360-degree feedback and their limits
Compare the three main ways of assessing emotional intelligence, read a self-versus-others profile to find a blind spot, and understand why scores should guide development rather than serve as a verdict.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
If emotional intelligence matters, can it be measured? Researchers and organisations have tried for decades, and the answer is: partly, and with care. This lesson describes the three main approaches, shows how to read a simple feedback profile, and explains why a score should be treated as a starting point for learning, not as a final verdict on a person.
Three ways of assessing
| Approach | How it works | Strength | Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ability test | The person solves emotional problems, such as reading emotions in faces or choosing the most effective way to handle a situation. The Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test (MSCEIT), built on the four-branch model, is the best known | Tests what a person can do, not what they say they can do | What counts as the 'right' answer is debated; answers are scored against expert or group opinion |
| Self-report | The person rates statements about themselves, such as 'I stay calm under pressure'. Bar-On's EQ-i is an example | Quick, cheap and easy to use | Open to flattery and faking; scores can overlap with personality traits |
| Multi-rater (360-degree) | Colleagues, juniors and seniors rate the person on observable behaviours, and the person rates themselves too | Shows how behaviour is actually seen by others | Takes time; raters may be biased or afraid to be frank |
A fourth, simpler tool is the situational judgement test, which describes a workplace scenario and asks the person to rank possible responses. It sits between an ability test and a self-report: it asks what the person would do, and answers are compared with what experts consider effective.
Reading a 360-degree profile
The most useful number in a 360 profile is often the gap between the self-rating and the average rating given by others. A large positive gap means the person thinks they are better at something than others see them to be, which is called a blind spot. A large negative gap means the person underrates a strength. Small gaps suggest that self-view and reputation agree.
Rule to remember: ability tests show what a person can do, self-reports show what a person says, and 360-degree ratings show how others see the person. The biggest gap between self and others marks the best place to start.
Worked example 1: a blind spot
An officer's profile on a five-point scale reads as follows (illustrative figures).
| Component | Self-rating | Average of others | Gap (self minus others) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-awareness | 4.2 | 3.4 | 0.8 |
| Self-regulation | 3.8 | 3.6 | 0.2 |
| Motivation | 4.5 | 4.4 | 0.1 |
| Empathy | 4.6 | 3.1 | 1.5 |
| Social skills | 3.9 | 3.5 | 0.4 |
The average self-rating is (4.2 + 3.8 + 4.5 + 4.6 + 3.9)/5 = 21.0/5 = 4.2, and the average rating by others is (3.4 + 3.6 + 4.4 + 3.1 + 3.5)/5 = 18.0/5 = 3.6. The officer rates himself higher overall, and the biggest gap, 1.5, is in empathy: a blind spot. The profile does not prove that he lacks empathy, but it says that others do not see it. A sensible plan is to ask two trusted colleagues for specific examples, practise listening without interrupting, and rate again after some months.
Worked example 2: choosing the instrument
(a) A department wants private, developmental feedback for its officers: use 360-degree feedback, because it shows how behaviour appears to others. (b) A researcher wants to know how well people recognise emotions from photographs: use an ability test. (c) A trainer wants a quick self-check at the start of a workshop: use a self-report questionnaire, while telling participants that the score reflects how they see themselves.
Worked example 3: the faking problem
A selection panel asks candidates to agree or disagree with 'I never lose my temper.' Almost every candidate agrees. The question has become a test of who knows the desired answer, an example of social desirability. Better evidence comes from a structured interview with behavioural questions such as 'Describe a time you were provoked at work and what you did', from situational judgement tests, and from observed group exercises.
Limits to remember
- Researchers still debate how far emotional intelligence differs from personality and general intelligence.
- Popular claims about what emotional intelligence can do often go well beyond the evidence.
- Scores depend on culture and context: a response that is effective in one setting may not be in another.
- For these reasons, scores are better used for development than as a single basis for selection.
Key takeaways. Ability tests, self-reports and 360-degree feedback each answer a different question. Compare self with others to find blind spots. Treat a score as a prompt for learning and not as a final judgement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which approach asks the person to solve emotional problems that have better and worse answers?
- Self-report questionnaire
- Interest inventory
- Personal diary
- Ability test
Show answer
Answer: D. Ability tests, such as the MSCEIT, present tasks with more and less effective answers and score the responses.
-
2. The main weakness of a self-report measure of emotional intelligence is that:
- It cannot be scored by hand
- It can be inflated by flattery or faking
- It is too slow to administer
- It measures only intelligence quotient
Show answer
Answer: B. People may rate themselves generously or give the answer they think is wanted, so the score can differ from actual behaviour.
-
3. In a 360-degree profile, an officer's self-rating for empathy is 4.6 and others rate him 3.1. What does the gap of 1.5 suggest?
- A strength others have underrated
- That the rating scale is faulty
- A possible blind spot in empathy
- That he has no empathy
Show answer
Answer: C. A large positive gap means he sees himself more favourably than others do. It marks a possible blind spot, not proof of a total lack.
-
4. A department wants to find out how colleagues actually see an officer's behaviour. Which tool fits best?
- 360-degree feedback
- A self-report questionnaire alone
- An ability test of face recognition
- A numerical aptitude test
Show answer
Answer: A. Only ratings from other people show how the behaviour is seen by them, which is the point of multi-rater feedback.
-
5. Why is 'I never lose my temper' a poor question in a selection test?
- It is too hard for most candidates to understand
- It tests mathematical reasoning more than temperament
- Candidates know the desired answer, so it invites faking
- It always produces a very low score for everyone
Show answer
Answer: C. The statement signals the desired answer, so replies reflect social desirability more than real behaviour.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.