• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Assessing emotional intelligence: ability tests, self-report, 360-degree feedback and their limits

Compare the three main ways of assessing emotional intelligence, read a self-versus-others profile to find a blind spot, and understand why scores should guide development rather than serve as a verdict.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

If emotional intelligence matters, can it be measured? Researchers and organisations have tried for decades, and the answer is: partly, and with care. This lesson describes the three main approaches, shows how to read a simple feedback profile, and explains why a score should be treated as a starting point for learning, not as a final verdict on a person.

Three ways of assessing

ApproachHow it worksStrengthWeakness
Ability testThe person solves emotional problems, such as reading emotions in faces or choosing the most effective way to handle a situation. The Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test (MSCEIT), built on the four-branch model, is the best knownTests what a person can do, not what they say they can doWhat counts as the 'right' answer is debated; answers are scored against expert or group opinion
Self-reportThe person rates statements about themselves, such as 'I stay calm under pressure'. Bar-On's EQ-i is an exampleQuick, cheap and easy to useOpen to flattery and faking; scores can overlap with personality traits
Multi-rater (360-degree)Colleagues, juniors and seniors rate the person on observable behaviours, and the person rates themselves tooShows how behaviour is actually seen by othersTakes time; raters may be biased or afraid to be frank

A fourth, simpler tool is the situational judgement test, which describes a workplace scenario and asks the person to rank possible responses. It sits between an ability test and a self-report: it asks what the person would do, and answers are compared with what experts consider effective.

Reading a 360-degree profile

The most useful number in a 360 profile is often the gap between the self-rating and the average rating given by others. A large positive gap means the person thinks they are better at something than others see them to be, which is called a blind spot. A large negative gap means the person underrates a strength. Small gaps suggest that self-view and reputation agree.

Rule to remember: ability tests show what a person can do, self-reports show what a person says, and 360-degree ratings show how others see the person. The biggest gap between self and others marks the best place to start.

Worked example 1: a blind spot

An officer's profile on a five-point scale reads as follows (illustrative figures).

ComponentSelf-ratingAverage of othersGap (self minus others)
Self-awareness4.23.40.8
Self-regulation3.83.60.2
Motivation4.54.40.1
Empathy4.63.11.5
Social skills3.93.50.4

The average self-rating is (4.2 + 3.8 + 4.5 + 4.6 + 3.9)/5 = 21.0/5 = 4.2, and the average rating by others is (3.4 + 3.6 + 4.4 + 3.1 + 3.5)/5 = 18.0/5 = 3.6. The officer rates himself higher overall, and the biggest gap, 1.5, is in empathy: a blind spot. The profile does not prove that he lacks empathy, but it says that others do not see it. A sensible plan is to ask two trusted colleagues for specific examples, practise listening without interrupting, and rate again after some months.

Worked example 2: choosing the instrument

(a) A department wants private, developmental feedback for its officers: use 360-degree feedback, because it shows how behaviour appears to others. (b) A researcher wants to know how well people recognise emotions from photographs: use an ability test. (c) A trainer wants a quick self-check at the start of a workshop: use a self-report questionnaire, while telling participants that the score reflects how they see themselves.

Worked example 3: the faking problem

A selection panel asks candidates to agree or disagree with 'I never lose my temper.' Almost every candidate agrees. The question has become a test of who knows the desired answer, an example of social desirability. Better evidence comes from a structured interview with behavioural questions such as 'Describe a time you were provoked at work and what you did', from situational judgement tests, and from observed group exercises.

Limits to remember

  • Researchers still debate how far emotional intelligence differs from personality and general intelligence.
  • Popular claims about what emotional intelligence can do often go well beyond the evidence.
  • Scores depend on culture and context: a response that is effective in one setting may not be in another.
  • For these reasons, scores are better used for development than as a single basis for selection.

Key takeaways. Ability tests, self-reports and 360-degree feedback each answer a different question. Compare self with others to find blind spots. Treat a score as a prompt for learning and not as a final judgement.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which approach asks the person to solve emotional problems that have better and worse answers?

    1. Self-report questionnaire
    2. Interest inventory
    3. Personal diary
    4. Ability test
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Ability tests, such as the MSCEIT, present tasks with more and less effective answers and score the responses.

  2. 2. The main weakness of a self-report measure of emotional intelligence is that:

    1. It cannot be scored by hand
    2. It can be inflated by flattery or faking
    3. It is too slow to administer
    4. It measures only intelligence quotient
    Show answer

    Answer: B. People may rate themselves generously or give the answer they think is wanted, so the score can differ from actual behaviour.

  3. 3. In a 360-degree profile, an officer's self-rating for empathy is 4.6 and others rate him 3.1. What does the gap of 1.5 suggest?

    1. A strength others have underrated
    2. That the rating scale is faulty
    3. A possible blind spot in empathy
    4. That he has no empathy
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A large positive gap means he sees himself more favourably than others do. It marks a possible blind spot, not proof of a total lack.

  4. 4. A department wants to find out how colleagues actually see an officer's behaviour. Which tool fits best?

    1. 360-degree feedback
    2. A self-report questionnaire alone
    3. An ability test of face recognition
    4. A numerical aptitude test
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Only ratings from other people show how the behaviour is seen by them, which is the point of multi-rater feedback.

  5. 5. Why is 'I never lose my temper' a poor question in a selection test?

    1. It is too hard for most candidates to understand
    2. It tests mathematical reasoning more than temperament
    3. Candidates know the desired answer, so it invites faking
    4. It always produces a very low score for everyone
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The statement signals the desired answer, so replies reflect social desirability more than real behaviour.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery