- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Emotional intelligence and IQ, with Gardner's interpersonal and intrapersonal intelligences
Compare emotional intelligence with IQ, explain why they complement each other, and link Gardner's interpersonal and intrapersonal intelligences to the components of EI.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A frequent short question asks how emotional intelligence differs from IQ, and whether one is more important. Answering well needs clear definitions, a fair comparison and an awareness of Howard Gardner's theory, which helped open the door to the idea that intelligence comes in more than one form.
What IQ measures
IQ (intelligence quotient) is a score from tests of general mental ability: reasoning, verbal understanding, working with numbers, spotting patterns and solving new problems. Such ability is generally regarded as fairly stable through adult life. It helps a person learn a subject, analyse a file or design a scheme.
What EI covers
EI concerns a different territory: perceiving, understanding, using and managing emotions in oneself and others. Many of its skills, such as listening, pausing before reacting or reading a tense room, can be improved with deliberate practice and feedback.
| Point | IQ | EI |
|---|---|---|
| Core focus | Reasoning and problem-solving with information | Recognising and handling emotions in self and others |
| Typical use | Analysing data, learning rules, planning | Calming conflict, motivating teams, handling grievances |
| Change over adult life | Generally regarded as fairly stable | Many component skills can be developed with practice |
| Typical measurement | Standardised ability tests | Ability tasks or self-report questionnaires, depending on the model |
Complementary, not rivals
Popular writing sometimes claims that EI matters more than IQ. Treat such slogans with care. A sound answer says the two do different work and an administrator needs both: IQ helps find the right solution, and EI helps people accept and carry it out. A plan that is technically perfect but announced in a way that insults the affected community may fail; a warm officer with a poorly reasoned plan also fails.
Gardner's personal intelligences
In 1983 Howard Gardner proposed a theory of multiple intelligences, arguing that people have several relatively distinct kinds of intelligence, such as linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, musical and bodily-kinesthetic, and two 'personal' intelligences:
- Intrapersonal intelligence: understanding oneself, one's feelings, motives, strengths and limits.
- Interpersonal intelligence: understanding other people, their moods, intentions and motivations, and working well with them.
These two map neatly onto EI. Intrapersonal intelligence is close to Goleman's self-awareness and self-regulation; interpersonal intelligence is close to empathy and social skills. Gardner did not use the term emotional intelligence; his work is background that made EI easier to accept.
Worked example 1: two officers, one problem
A district must shift a weekly market to a new site. Officer Kavya prepares a flawless traffic and space analysis but announces the move by notice without meeting vendors. Officer Sunil prepares a weaker analysis but meets vendors, hears their fear about lost customers and agrees a trial week. Step 1: Kavya shows strong reasoning (IQ-type ability) but little attention to feelings. Step 2: Sunil shows strong EI but a weaker plan. Step 3: the best result needs Kavya's analysis delivered with Sunil's engagement. Conclusion: the two capacities complement each other.
Worked example 2: intrapersonal or interpersonal?
Classify each. (a) 'Deepa knows that she makes hasty decisions when tired, so she avoids signing files late at night.' Reasoning: the knowledge is about herself, so it is intrapersonal. (b) 'Harish can tell from a colleague's short replies that the colleague feels left out of a project.' Reasoning: the knowledge is about another person, so it is interpersonal. (c) 'Nandini sorts out a quarrel between two clerks by helping each see the other's concern.' Reasoning: understanding and working with others, so interpersonal.
Rule to remember: IQ helps you find the right answer; EI helps you work with people to make it happen. Intra means within (yourself); inter means between (you and others).
Key takeaways: IQ concerns general reasoning ability, EI concerns emotions; they complement each other and slogans ranking one above the other should be treated with caution; Gardner's intrapersonal intelligence is about oneself and interpersonal intelligence about others; both foreshadow components of EI.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about IQ and EI is the most balanced?
- EI has been proved to be always more important than IQ
- IQ makes EI unnecessary
- They are different capacities and effective administrators need both
- EI and IQ are two names for the same ability
Show answer
Answer: C. IQ and EI do different work. Claims that one always outweighs the other are slogans, not settled facts; the balanced view is that they complement each other.
-
2. Gardner's intrapersonal intelligence is closest to which component of Goleman's model?
- Social skills
- Self-awareness
- Empathy
- Interpersonal influence
Show answer
Answer: B. Intrapersonal intelligence is understanding oneself, which corresponds most closely to self-awareness.
-
3. 'Suresh realises from a junior's silence in meetings that the junior feels ignored.' Gardner would call this:
- Intrapersonal intelligence
- Logical-mathematical intelligence
- Interpersonal intelligence
- Spatial intelligence
Show answer
Answer: C. Suresh is understanding another person's feelings, which is interpersonal intelligence.
-
4. Which of the following is generally true of EI compared with IQ?
- EI cannot change at all after childhood
- EI is measured only by standard reasoning tests
- EI concerns solving numerical problems
- Many EI skills can be developed with deliberate practice
Show answer
Answer: D. Skills such as pausing, listening and reading a room can improve with practice and feedback. IQ tests measure reasoning, not emotional skills.
-
5. Who proposed the theory of multiple intelligences?
- Howard Gardner
- Daniel Goleman
- John Mayer
- Edward Thorndike
Show answer
Answer: A. Howard Gardner proposed multiple intelligences in 1983, including interpersonal and intrapersonal intelligence.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.