• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Emotions in decisions, emotional labour and conflict handling: the Thomas-Kilmann modes

Treat emotions as information in a decision, understand emotional labour in front-line work, and choose among the five Thomas-Kilmann conflict modes using self-awareness, empathy and self-regulation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Public servants decide under pressure, face people in distress and settle disputes between colleagues and departments. Emotions are present in all of it. Emotional intelligence does not remove them. It helps an officer use them as information, carry the strain of dealing with people, and handle conflict in a way that suits the situation. This lesson takes up these three tasks in turn.

Emotions as information

Each emotion carries a message. Anger often signals that something seems unfair or blocked. Fear points to a possible danger. Guilt signals that one has broken one's own standard. Sadness marks a loss. The message is a starting point, not a verdict, because the first reading can be wrong: a person who is angry at a colleague may have misunderstood what happened. A simple routine is to name the feeling, ask what it is telling you, check the facts, and only then decide. In this way the emotion is heard, but it does not take the decision.

Emotional labour

The sociologist Arlie Hochschild used the term emotional labour for the effort of managing one's own feelings to show the expression a job requires: the patient smile at a counter, the calm voice with an angry caller. She distinguished surface acting, in which one only changes the outward display while feeling otherwise, from deep acting, in which one works on the feeling itself, for example by recalling that the visitor is frightened and not hostile. Long periods of surface acting can leave people drained. Breaks, colleague support and reframing the other person's behaviour help.

The five conflict modes

Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann described five ways of handling a conflict, arranged by two questions: how much you assert your own concern, and how much you cooperate with the other party's concern.

ModeAssertivenessCooperativenessSuits when
CompetingHighLowA quick, firm decision is needed, for example in an emergency or a safety matter
CollaboratingHighHighThe issue is important and both sides share goals, so a joint solution is worth the time
CompromisingMediumMediumTime is short and both sides can give up part of their demand
AvoidingLowLowThe matter is trivial, or tempers need time to cool
AccommodatingLowHighThe issue matters more to the other side, or preserving the relationship is worth more than winning

No mode is always right. A person has a favourite, but an officer with emotional intelligence knows their own habit (self-awareness), stays calm (self-regulation), understands what the other side needs (empathy) and then picks the mode that fits (social skill).

Rule to remember: feelings are information, not orders; emotional labour is a real cost that needs recovery; and each conflict mode has its place: compete in emergencies, collaborate on shared goals, compromise under time pressure, avoid trivial fights, accommodate when the relationship matters more.

Worked example 1: using the message of anger

A section officer reads a note that appears to blame her office for a delay, and feels anger. Step 1: name it ('I am angry'). Step 2: ask what it signals ('I feel unfairly blamed'). Step 3: check the facts. She reads the note again and sees that it blames the pending clearance from another office, not hers. Step 4: she writes a polite query, instead of the sharp reply she first drafted. The emotion was a signal, but the facts changed the response.

Worked example 2: choosing a conflict mode

(a) Smoke is seen from a store room and a staff member argues about who should call the fire service. Time matters and safety is at stake, so a firm competing instruction is right: 'You call now; I will evacuate.' (b) Two sections dispute the booking of one shared vehicle, but both want the same outcome, timely field visits. The best mode is collaborating: share the schedules and find a rota that serves both. (c) Two departments each need the conference hall at the same hour tomorrow and cannot wait: compromise, with one using the first half and the other the second.

Worked example 3: surface and deep acting

A counter clerk faces a shouting visitor whose pension has stopped. If the clerk only forces a smile while seething, she is surface acting. If she reminds herself that the visitor is worried about money, takes a slow breath and lets her feeling of irritation turn into concern, she is deep acting. Deep acting often lasts better, though neither removes the need for rest.

Key takeaways. Treat emotion as a signal to check, not as a command. Emotional labour wears people down unless it is balanced by rest and support. The five conflict modes are competing, collaborating, compromising, avoiding and accommodating, and choosing among them is itself an emotional-intelligence skill.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An officer feels a surge of anger on reading a note. Which first step best reflects emotional intelligence?

    1. Reply at once to show strength
    2. Suppress the feeling and pretend it is absent
    3. Name the feeling and ask what it signals
    4. Decide that the sender is hostile
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The routine is to notice and name the emotion, understand its message, and check the facts before acting.

  2. 2. In Hochschild's terms, an employee who changes only her outward expression while feeling differently inside is engaged in:

    1. Surface acting
    2. Deep acting
    3. Active listening
    4. Compromising
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Surface acting changes the display without changing the feeling. Deep acting works on the feeling itself.

  3. 3. Which Thomas-Kilmann mode is high in assertiveness and low in cooperativeness?

    1. Collaborating
    2. Avoiding
    3. Accommodating
    4. Competing
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Competing pursues one's own concern firmly at the expense of the other. Collaborating is high in both, avoiding is low in both and accommodating is low in assertiveness.

  4. 4. Two sections want the same outcome but dispute how to share one vehicle. Which mode is most suitable?

    1. Competing
    2. Collaborating
    3. Avoiding
    4. Accommodating
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The issue matters and the goals are shared, so working out a joint solution, such as a rota, is the best use of time.

  5. 5. When might avoiding be the sensible conflict mode?

    1. When the matter is trivial or tempers need time to cool
    2. When the matter is a safety emergency needing quick action
    3. When the relationship with the other side does not matter
    4. When the other party is certain to agree with every demand
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Avoiding postpones a conflict. It suits minor matters or heated moments, but it is wrong for urgent or serious issues.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery