- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Finding the ethical issue in a case: separating facts, law, self-interest and values
Read a case study and separate its factual, legal, prudential and ethical questions, name the values in conflict, and tell a genuine dilemma from a temptation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The first mark in any ethics case study goes to the candidate who sees the real issue. Many answers fail because they discuss the facts at length, quote the rules, or worry about the officer's career, and never say which values are actually in conflict. This lesson gives you a quick routine to strip a case down to its ethical core.
Four kinds of question hide in every case
| Kind | Asks | Example from a case |
|---|---|---|
| Factual | What happened, and what will happen? | Is the bridge really unsafe? How many families are affected? |
| Legal | What do the rules and laws require? | Does the manual allow a completion certificate before inspection? |
| Prudential | What is good for me? | Will I be transferred if I refuse my superior? |
| Ethical | What is right, considering everyone affected? | Is it right to certify unfinished work to please a superior, when people's safety depends on it? |
Facts and law are inputs, not answers. David Hume pointed out that one cannot move directly from statements about what is to conclusions about what ought to be; some value has to enter the reasoning. Prudential questions are real, and an honest answer can acknowledge them, but they are not the ethical question. The ethical question is usually best written as a clash of two values.
Name the values in conflict
- Honesty versus compassion (telling a hard truth, or softening it)
- Loyalty to a superior or colleague versus integrity
- Rule-following versus discretion to meet genuine need
- Efficiency and speed versus fairness and due process
- Individual rights versus collective welfare
- Short-term relief versus long-term good
Dilemma or temptation?
Rushworth Kidder, writing on everyday ethics, distinguished right-versus-right choices, where both options rest on genuine values, from right-versus-wrong choices, where one option is simply wrong but attractive. Only the first is a true ethical dilemma. A bribe offer is a temptation, not a dilemma: the difficulty is one of will, not of judgement. Calling a temptation a dilemma is a common trap, because it makes a clear wrong sound like a hard choice.
Worked case analysis 1: the unfinished drain
Case: Prakash, a fictional municipal engineer, is told by his executive engineer to sign the completion certificate for a storm-water drain so that the contractor can be paid before the monsoon. Prakash's inspection shows that a third of the drain is incomplete. Step 1, facts: the work is incomplete; flooding risk is real. Step 2, law: certification without completed work is a false record. Step 3, prudence: refusing may annoy his superior. Step 4, ethics: the values in conflict are obedience to a superior versus honesty and public safety. Step 5, classify: is there a right option on both sides? No: certifying falsely is wrong, so this is a temptation under pressure, not a dilemma. Prakash should record his findings in writing, refuse to certify, and suggest a lawful route, such as partial payment for work actually completed.
Worked case analysis 2: the last relief kit
Case: After a cyclone, Fatima, a fictional panchayat secretary, is distributing relief kits on the basis of a ration card. One kit is left. An elderly widow without any documents is plainly destitute; a family with valid documents arrives at the same time. Step 1, facts: both are in need, the widow arguably more. Step 2, law: the rule asks for documents, but the purpose of the rule is to prevent fraud, not to exclude the needy. Step 3, ethics: rule-following and fairness to the documented family versus compassion and need. Step 4, classify: both options rest on real values, so this is a genuine dilemma. A reasonable resolution is to give the kit to the widow, record the reason, and immediately request another kit for the family, so that discretion is used openly and in line with the rule's purpose.
Rule to remember: facts and rules are inputs; the ethical issue is the clash of values. Ask whether both sides are right. If one side is simply wrong, you face a temptation, and the answer is to resist it, not to weigh it.
Common traps
Trap 1: writing the legal position as if it ended the matter. Trap 2: treating the officer's career risk as the main issue. Trap 3: calling a bribe or a false certificate a 'dilemma'. Trap 4: listing values without saying which two are in tension. Trap 5: ignoring a genuine factual uncertainty that should be checked before acting.
Key takeaways: separate factual, legal, prudential and ethical questions; facts cannot settle an 'ought' alone, as Hume noted; state the ethical issue as a conflict of two values; a dilemma is right versus right, a temptation is right versus wrong; when rules and need clash, use discretion openly and in line with the rule's purpose.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a case, 'If I refuse, I may be transferred to a remote posting' is best classified as a:
- Factual question
- Legal question
- Prudential consideration
- Ethical issue
Show answer
Answer: C. It concerns the officer's own interest, so it is prudential. It is a real consideration but not the ethical question, which is about what is right for all affected.
-
2. Which of the following is a genuine ethical dilemma rather than a temptation?
- Whether to accept cash from a contractor in return for passing his file ahead of the others
- Whether to tell a dying patient's family the full prognosis now or let them absorb it gradually
- Whether to falsify attendance records to help a friend who has been absent for a month
- Whether to leak confidential tender details to a bidder in return for an expensive gift
Show answer
Answer: B. Only the prognosis case sets two genuine values against each other: honesty and compassion. The others set a clear wrong against a duty, so they are temptations, right versus wrong.
-
3. The distinction between right-versus-right and right-versus-wrong choices is associated with:
- Rushworth Kidder
- Immanuel Kant
- Jeremy Bentham
- Aristotle
Show answer
Answer: A. Rushworth Kidder, in his work on how good people make tough choices, separated genuine dilemmas (right versus right) from temptations (right versus wrong).
-
4. A candidate writes: 'The rule requires documents, so the officer must refuse; there is no ethical issue.' The main flaw is:
- Ignoring the factual question of whether the documents are really missing
- Overemphasising prudence and the officer's own risk of being blamed
- Using a virtue lens without considering the rule
- Treating the legal position as if it settled the ethical question
Show answer
Answer: D. Rules are inputs. The ethical question asks whether applying the rule here serves its purpose and treats people fairly; the law alone does not end the analysis.
-
5. Hume's point about 'is' and 'ought' implies that in a case study:
- Facts are irrelevant to ethical judgement, which depends only on values
- Facts alone cannot settle what should be done without some value
- Laws always settle ethical questions, so no further reasoning is needed
- Only consequences matter, and values play no part in the reasoning
Show answer
Answer: B. Hume observed that conclusions about what ought to be cannot follow from facts alone. Facts matter, but a value must enter the reasoning to reach an 'ought'.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.