- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Judging actions in cases: intention, means, circumstances and responsibility
Apply a five-step test to judge responsibility in case studies: the act, the intention, the circumstances, knowledge and freedom, and the outcome, including the 'following orders' and outcome-luck traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Foundation-level study taught that an act is judged by what is done, why, and in what circumstances. In case studies you must turn this into a verdict: how responsible is this person, and what should they have done? This lesson gives a five-step test and practises it on cases where the answer is not obvious.
The five-step test
- The act: describe exactly what was done, in neutral words. 'Approved a payment without inspection', not 'helped the contractor'.
- The intention: what was the person trying to achieve? Look for evidence, not just their own claim.
- The circumstances: what alternatives were open? How urgent was it? What was the person's role and duty?
- Knowledge and freedom: did they know, or should they have known? Were they forced, pressured, or free to refuse?
- The outcome: what followed, and was it foreseeable? Judge the choice by what could be foreseen, not only by the result.
| Usually reduces responsibility | Usually does not reduce responsibility |
|---|---|
| Ignorance that could not reasonably be avoided | Ignorance of facts one had a duty to check |
| Genuine threat to life or safety | Fear of a transfer or a bad report |
| No lawful alternative was available | Lawful alternatives existed but were slower |
| Acting in a real emergency with no time to consult | 'Everyone does it' in the office |
Worked case analysis 1: 'I was following orders'
Case: Sanjay, a fictional assistant in a district office, is told orally by his superior to release a payment to a supplier whose goods have not yet been received. He does so. Step 1, act: releasing public money without receipt of goods. Step 2, intention: to obey his superior and avoid trouble, not to steal. Step 3, circumstances: there was no emergency; he could have asked for a written order. Step 4, knowledge and freedom: he knew the goods had not arrived; the pressure was career pressure, not a threat to safety. Step 5, outcome: a loss to the public, which was foreseeable. Verdict: his responsibility is reduced, because the idea came from his superior, but not removed. The right course was to ask for the instruction in writing, record his objection, and refer the matter up if needed. Obedience covers lawful orders only.
Worked case analysis 2: same act, different outcomes
Case: Two fictional site engineers, Anita and Bhaskar, both skip a mandatory load test on two similar footbridges to finish quickly. Anita's bridge stands; Bhaskar's develops cracks and is closed before anyone is hurt. Step 1: the act and intention are identical in both cases. Step 2: circumstances, knowledge and freedom are the same; both knew the test was required. Step 3: the outcome differs only by chance. Verdict: both made the same wrong choice, and both should be held to account for skipping the test. Philosophers Bernard Williams and Thomas Nagel discussed this problem of moral luck: we tend to blame people more for bad outcomes they did not control. In case answers, judge the choice, and treat the outcome as information about the risk that was taken.
Rule to remember: describe the act in neutral words, then test intention, circumstances, knowledge and freedom, and only then the outcome. Pressure reduces blame; it does not erase it. Obedience is owed only to lawful orders.
Common traps
Trap 1, the noble motive: a good intention does not justify a wrong act when lawful means existed. Trap 2, the clean outcome: 'no harm was done' does not make a reckless choice acceptable. Trap 3, blanket obedience: 'my superior told me' is not a full defence; a public servant owes loyalty to the law and the public. Trap 4, all-or-nothing verdicts: in most cases responsibility is shared and graded; say who bears more and why.
Key takeaways: use the five steps in order; neutral description prevents bias; unavoidable ignorance and genuine threats reduce responsibility, but career pressure and negligent ignorance do not remove it; ask for written orders and record objections; judge choices by foreseeable risk rather than by luck in the outcome.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these most clearly reduces a person's responsibility for a wrong act?
- Fear that refusing would lead to a poor annual report
- The fact that colleagues also do it
- Ignorance of facts the person had no reasonable way to discover
- A lawful but slower alternative existed
Show answer
Answer: C. Unavoidable ignorance genuinely reduces responsibility. Career fear, common practice and the existence of a slower lawful route do not excuse the act.
-
2. An officer releases funds on an unlawful oral order from a superior. The best ethical response would have been to:
- Obey, since responsibility for an order lies only with the superior who gave it
- Ask for the order in writing, record objection, and refuse if it remains unlawful
- Leak the matter to the press at once, before telling anyone in the department
- Resign immediately and leave the decision to a successor
Show answer
Answer: B. Obedience is owed to lawful orders. Asking for a written order and recording dissent uses proper channels; going to the press first or resigning are extreme, and blind obedience is not a defence.
-
3. Two engineers make the same careless decision; only one leads to damage, by chance. The ethically sound judgement is:
- Both made the same wrong choice and both are accountable for it
- Only the engineer whose bridge was damaged did wrong
- Neither did wrong, since no one was hurt
- The undamaged case shows the decision was wise
Show answer
Answer: A. The choice, the knowledge and the intention were identical; only luck differed. This is the problem of moral luck discussed by Williams and Nagel. Judge the choice by the foreseeable risk.
-
4. Why should the act be described in neutral words at the first step?
- To make the answer longer and give it more weight in marks
- To show sympathy for the officer before judging what he did
- To make the act appear legal before any analysis has been done
- To avoid building a verdict into the description before analysing it
Show answer
Answer: D. Words such as 'helped' or 'stole' already contain a judgement. Neutral description lets the later steps decide the verdict on evidence.
-
5. A clerk alters a beneficiary list to include his neighbour, saying the neighbour is poor. The neighbour is in fact poor but did not apply in time. The best verdict is:
- Fully justified, since the motive was good and the neighbour truly needed the help
- The act is wrong, since it bypassed fair procedure, though the motive slightly reduces blame
- No issue, since the outcome helped a poor person who deserved the benefit
- Only a legal issue about the list, not an ethical one
Show answer
Answer: B. Altering a list bypasses fairness to other applicants and the rules. A good motive does not justify the act; at most it reduces blame. The proper course was to guide the neighbour to apply in the next round.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.