• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Which theory is speaking? Identifying virtue, duty and consequence reasoning in statements

Recognise virtue, deontological and utilitarian reasoning in exam statements and scenarios, tell rule utilitarianism from deontology, and avoid the 'happiness' and 'rules' traps.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions give a statement or a short scenario and ask which theory it reflects. The answer is usually hidden in the reason given, not in the action, because the same action can be supported by different theories for different reasons. This lesson trains you to find the reason and match it quickly.

Find the 'because'

Underline the reason the speaker gives. If the reason is about outcomes for those affected, it is consequentialist. If it is about a duty, rule, right or respect for persons that holds whatever the outcome, it is deontological. If it is about character, what a good person would be or do, habits and practical wisdom, it is virtue ethics. If it is about the speaker's own benefit only, it is ethical egoism.

Signal words in the reasonTheory
maximise, net benefit, greatest number, results, outcomes, costs and benefitsConsequentialism (utilitarianism)
duty, obligation, rights, never, in principle, universal, using someone, respect for personsDeontology (Kantian)
character, kind of person, habit, role model, virtue, balance, practical wisdom, flourishingVirtue ethics (Aristotelian)
my interest, my benefit, what is good for meEthical egoism

Two distinctions examiners like

Act versus rule utilitarianism. An act utilitarian judges each act by its own consequences. A rule utilitarian follows the rules whose general observance produces the best consequences, even when breaking one would help in a particular case. Rule utilitarianism versus deontology. Both may say 'always keep promises', but for different reasons: the rule utilitarian because a practice of promise-keeping produces the best results overall, the deontologist because the duty binds in itself. If the justification mentions overall results of the rule, it is rule utilitarianism.

Acting in accordance with duty versus from duty. Kant gave the example of a shopkeeper who gives correct change to an inexperienced customer only because cheating would hurt his business. He does the right thing, but from self-interest, so in Kant's view the act lacks moral worth. Questions that stress motive point to Kant.

Worked case analysis 1: four officers, one decision

Four officers each refuse a bribe. Identify the theory behind each reason. (a) 'Taking it would harm many citizens who are made to wait.' Reason: outcomes for others, so utilitarian. (b) 'Accepting it would treat the citizen as a mere means, and I could not will that everyone take bribes.' Reason: universalisability and respect for persons, so Kantian deontology. (c) 'An honest officer simply does not do such things; I have built that habit over years.' Reason: character and habit, so virtue ethics. (d) 'If I am caught I lose my job.' Reason: own interest, so ethical egoism, which is also only prudence. Same action, four theories.

Worked case analysis 2: the tricky one

Statement: 'Doctors must never break patient confidentiality, even when breaking it once would help, because a system in which patients trust doctors produces far better health for everyone.' Step 1: the conclusion sounds deontological ('must never'). Step 2: find the reason: better health for everyone from a general practice. Step 3: the justification is the good results of the rule as a whole. Answer: rule utilitarianism, not deontology. This is the most common trap in this topic.

Rule to remember: ignore the action and read the reason. Results mean consequentialism; duty, rights or respect for persons mean deontology; character means virtue ethics. A firm rule justified by its overall results is rule utilitarianism.

Common traps

The happiness trap: Aristotle's eudaimonia is often translated as 'happiness', but it means flourishing through virtue, not pleasure, so a statement about living a flourishing life is virtue ethics, not utilitarianism. The rules trap: the word 'rule' does not automatically mean deontology. The motive trap: a good action from a selfish motive is not Kantian moral worth. The mixed statement: where a statement contains two reasons, choose the theory of the reason that is said to be decisive.

Key takeaways: identify the reason, not the action; outcomes indicate consequentialism, duties and respect indicate deontology, character indicates virtue ethics; rule utilitarianism defends firm rules by their overall results; Kant's shopkeeper shows that right acts from selfish motives lack moral worth; eudaimonia is flourishing, not pleasure.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'I will not exaggerate my achievements in the report, because I want to be the kind of person whose word can be relied on.' This reasoning reflects:

    1. Act utilitarianism
    2. Rule utilitarianism
    3. Ethical egoism
    4. Virtue ethics
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The reason given is about character: being a reliable, truthful person. That is the focus of virtue ethics.

  2. 2. 'We should always follow the queue system, even when skipping one person would help, because a reliable queue gives the best results for everyone over time.' This is:

    1. Rule utilitarianism
    2. Kantian deontology
    3. Virtue ethics
    4. Act utilitarianism
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A firm rule is defended by the good results of the general practice. That is rule utilitarianism. An act utilitarian would skip the queue where it helps in that case.

  3. 3. In Kant's example, a shopkeeper gives honest change only because cheating would hurt his business. Kant would say the act:

    1. Has full moral worth because the result is honest and customers are not cheated
    2. Is in accordance with duty but not done from duty, so it lacks moral worth
    3. Is immoral because it is profitable to the shopkeeper and his business
    4. Is an example of the golden mean between honesty and cheating
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The act matches what duty requires, but the motive is self-interest. For Kant, moral worth requires acting from duty, so the act lacks moral worth.

  4. 4. A statement says that a good life consists of flourishing through the exercise of virtues. A student marks it 'utilitarian' because it mentions happiness. The student has fallen into:

    1. The motive trap: the student mixed up intentions and results
    2. The rules trap: the student treated a virtue as a rule to obey
    3. The happiness trap: eudaimonia means flourishing, which is virtue ethics
    4. No trap; the statement is utilitarian because it mentions happiness
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Aristotle's eudaimonia is often translated as happiness but means flourishing through virtue, not a sum of pleasures. The statement reflects virtue ethics.

  5. 5. 'Sharing the confidential report would bring a huge benefit to thousands, so in this case it is the right thing to do.' Which theory is speaking?

    1. Act utilitarianism
    2. Deontology
    3. Virtue ethics
    4. Rule utilitarianism
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The act is justified by its own consequences in this particular case. That is act utilitarianism. A rule utilitarian would ask whether a general practice of sharing confidential reports produces the best results.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery