| Kind | Asks | Example from a case |
|---|---|---|
| Factual | What happened, and what will happen? | Is the bridge really unsafe? How many families are affected? |
| Legal | What do the rules and laws require? | Does the manual allow a completion certificate before inspection? |
| Prudential | What is good for me? | Will I be transferred if I refuse my superior? |
| Ethical | What is right, considering everyone affected? | Is it right to certify unfinished work to please a superior, when people's safety depends on it? |
Rule to remember: facts and rules are inputs; the ethical issue is the clash of values. Ask whether both sides are right. If one side is simply wrong, you face a temptation, and the answer is to resist it, not to weigh it.
Key takeaways: separate factual, legal, prudential and ethical questions; facts cannot settle an 'ought' alone, as Hume noted; state the ethical issue as a conflict of two values; a dilemma is right versus right, a temptation is right versus wrong; when rules and need clash, use discretion openly and in line with the rule's purpose.