Revision notes

Foundations of Ethics: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Finding the ethical issue in a case: separating facts, law, self-interest and values

KindAsksExample from a case
FactualWhat happened, and what will happen?Is the bridge really unsafe? How many families are affected?
LegalWhat do the rules and laws require?Does the manual allow a completion certificate before inspection?
PrudentialWhat is good for me?Will I be transferred if I refuse my superior?
EthicalWhat is right, considering everyone affected?Is it right to certify unfinished work to please a superior, when people's safety depends on it?

Rule to remember: facts and rules are inputs; the ethical issue is the clash of values. Ask whether both sides are right. If one side is simply wrong, you face a temptation, and the answer is to resist it, not to weigh it.

Key takeaways: separate factual, legal, prudential and ethical questions; facts cannot settle an 'ought' alone, as Hume noted; state the ethical issue as a conflict of two values; a dilemma is right versus right, a temptation is right versus wrong; when rules and need clash, use discretion openly and in line with the rule's purpose.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Which theory is speaking? Identifying virtue, duty and consequence reasoning in statements

Signal words in the reasonTheory
maximise, net benefit, greatest number, results, outcomes, costs and benefitsConsequentialism (utilitarianism)
duty, obligation, rights, never, in principle, universal, using someone, respect for personsDeontology (Kantian)
character, kind of person, habit, role model, virtue, balance, practical wisdom, flourishingVirtue ethics (Aristotelian)
my interest, my benefit, what is good for meEthical egoism

Rule to remember: ignore the action and read the reason. Results mean consequentialism; duty, rights or respect for persons mean deontology; character means virtue ethics. A firm rule justified by its overall results is rule utilitarianism.

Key takeaways: identify the reason, not the action; outcomes indicate consequentialism, duties and respect indicate deontology, character indicates virtue ethics; rule utilitarianism defends firm rules by their overall results; Kant's shopkeeper shows that right acts from selfish motives lack moral worth; eudaimonia is flourishing, not pleasure.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Judging actions in cases: intention, means, circumstances and responsibility

Excuses in practice
Usually reduces responsibilityUsually does not reduce responsibility
Ignorance that could not reasonably be avoidedIgnorance of facts one had a duty to check
Genuine threat to life or safetyFear of a transfer or a bad report
No lawful alternative was availableLawful alternatives existed but were slower
Acting in a real emergency with no time to consult'Everyone does it' in the office

Rule to remember: describe the act in neutral words, then test intention, circumstances, knowledge and freedom, and only then the outcome. Pressure reduces blame; it does not erase it. Obedience is owed only to lawful orders.

Key takeaways: use the five steps in order; neutral description prevents bias; unavoidable ignorance and genuine threats reduce responsibility, but career pressure and negligent ignorance do not remove it; ask for written orders and record objections; judge choices by foreseeable risk rather than by luck in the outcome.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Stakeholder analysis step by step for ethics case studies

StakeholderInterest or rightWeight in this case
Workers' settlementRight to life; urgent rescueHighest: most immediate danger
Leader's villageSafety; timely rescueReal but less urgent
Local leaderPolitical standingNot a ground for priority
Rescue teamsClear orders, safetyNeed a transparent plan
Public at largeFair, trusted administrationHigh

Rule to remember: list everyone affected, including those without a voice; generate at least three options; test each against law, consequences, duties and character; then choose, justify and say how you will carry it out.

Key takeaways: follow facts, stakeholders, interests, values, options, evaluation, decision and implementation; weight stakeholders by urgency and rights, not influence; a balanced, lawful middle option often serves most interests; documentation and follow-up show that a decision is real.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Private ties, public duty: conflicts of interest, gifts and loyalty in exam cases

Type of optionExampleVerdict
Unlawful or dishonestAccept the gift quietly; adjust the recordEliminate first
PassiveDo nothing and wait; it is not my businessUsually eliminate
ExtremeResign at once; go to the media first; publicly humiliate the personUsually eliminate
Lawful, proportionate, documentedDecline politely, report as the rules require, record itUsually the best

Rule to remember: decline what you could not defend in public, disclose every private tie that touches a decision, and step aside from that decision. Loyalty goes to the law and the public first, to persons second.

Key takeaways: test gifts by giver, value, timing and publicity; loyalty is owed to lawful purposes and the public; eliminate unlawful, passive and extreme options; prefer lawful, proportionate, documented responses through proper channels; disclose and recuse whenever private ties meet public duty.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery