• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Deciding with integrity: a seven-step method and five quick tests

Work through a dilemma in seven steps, test each option against the law, the publicity, universal-rule, fairness and role-reversal tests, and record reasons so that a decision can be explained.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A dilemma is a situation where each choice has a cost and no option is perfect. Public servants meet them often: a deadline against accuracy, a senior's request against a rule, kindness to one person against fairness to others. Integrity does not mean never feeling torn. It means having a method that keeps the decision honest and explainable. This lesson sets out a seven-step method and five quick tests that can be applied to each option.

The seven steps

  • Get the facts. What exactly has happened, and what do you not yet know? Do not decide on rumour.
  • Identify who is affected. List everyone with something at stake, including those who are not present.
  • Find the rules and values. Which laws, orders, codes and values apply? Do any of them conflict?
  • List real options. Include middle courses, such as 'do it, but with a written note' or 'do part now and ask for time'. Few dilemmas have only two answers.
  • Test each option with the five tests below.
  • Decide and act. Choose the option that best passes the tests, and carry it out with courtesy and without delay.
  • Record and review. Write your reasons briefly. Later, ask what you would do differently.

Five quick tests

TestThe question to ask
Rule testIs it lawful and consistent with the rules and the codes that bind me?
Publicity testWould I be comfortable if my act and my reasons were reported openly?
Universal-rule testIf everyone in my position did this, would the system still work and be fair?
Fairness testDoes it treat all the people affected with equal concern, with no hidden favour?
Role-reversal testWould I accept this decision if I were on the receiving end?

The tests draw on the three lenses of the previous lesson: the rule and universal tests come from duty ethics, the fairness and role-reversal tests from respect for persons, and the publicity test from character and accountability. An option that fails two or more tests is almost never the right choice. If every option fails something, choose the one that causes the least harm and be ready to explain why.

Rule to remember: facts, people, rules, options, tests, decision, record. If you could not explain the decision to the people it affects, or would hide it from the public, think again.

Worked example 1: a report due today

A branch must send a data report today. The new figures will not arrive until next week. A colleague suggests copying last year's figures without saying so. The officer lists three options. A: copy the old figures silently. B: send the report marked 'provisional', stating which figures are from last year, and ask for an extension for the final version. C: refuse to send anything. Mark each option 1 for pass and 0 for fail on four of the tests (rule, publicity, universal rule and fairness) and on a fifth check, whether it meets the duty to deliver on time.

OptionRulePublicityUniversalFairDeliversTotal
A: copy silently000011
B: provisional with a note111115
C: send nothing110002

Option B passes all five checks with a total of 5, against 1 for A and 2 for C. The officer chooses B, tells the colleague why, and records the reasoning in the file.

Worked example 2: a senior's request

A senior asks an assistant to put an earlier date on a note so that a file appears to have been processed on time. Step 1: the facts are clear. The date would be false. Step 2: those affected include the applicant, the department and the assistant himself. Step 3: the rule is that records must be accurate. Step 4: options are to comply, to refuse and say nothing, or to decline politely, offer to prepare a note explaining the delay, and keep a record of the request. Step 5: comply fails every test; the third option passes the rule, publicity and fairness tests. Step 6: the assistant declines politely and offers the explanatory note. Step 7: he writes a short record, and if the pressure continues, he reports the matter through the proper channel.

Key takeaways. Use the method when you are torn, not only when the case is easy. Look for real middle options. Test each option against the five tests, and keep a short record of the reasons.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the seven-step method, which step comes immediately after listing the real options?

    1. Record and review
    2. Decide and act
    3. Test each option
    4. Get the facts
    Show answer

    Answer: C. After the options are listed, each is tested with the quick tests. Only then does the officer decide.

  2. 2. Which test asks whether you would be comfortable if your act and reasons were reported openly?

    1. The publicity test
    2. The rule test
    3. The role-reversal test
    4. The fairness test
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The publicity test checks that an act could be explained in public without embarrassment.

  3. 3. An assistant asks: 'Would I accept this decision if I were the applicant?' Which test is this?

    1. The publicity test
    2. The universal-rule test
    3. The rule test
    4. The role-reversal test
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Imagining oneself in the position of the person affected is the role-reversal test.

  4. 4. Why does the lesson recommend looking for middle options?

    1. Because a middle option is certain to satisfy both sides fully
    2. Many dilemmas have a better third course than either extreme
    3. Because the first option listed is always the wrong one
    4. Because rules and codes never apply to a real dilemma
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Options such as a provisional report with a note often meet the real needs of both sides. They are not guaranteed to be right, but they should be considered.

  5. 5. In the report example, option B scores 5, option A scores 1 and option C scores 2. What is the sum of all three totals?

    1. 8
    2. 7
    3. 9
    4. 10
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 1 + 5 + 2 = 8.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery