- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Nolan Committee's Seven Principles of Public Life, and codes of ethics versus codes of conduct
Learn the seven principles of public life set out in 1995 by the UK's Committee on Standards in Public Life under Lord Nolan, and tell a code of ethics from a code of conduct.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In the early 1990s a series of controversies about conduct in British public life led to the setting up of the Committee on Standards in Public Life, first chaired by Lord Nolan. Its first report, in 1995, set out seven principles that anyone holding public office should follow. They are widely cited far beyond the United Kingdom, including in Indian discussions of ethics in governance, and they make a neat framework for answers. This lesson explains each principle in plain words and then shows how principles are turned into codes.
The seven principles
| Principle | What it asks, in plain words |
|---|---|
| Selflessness | Act solely in the public interest, not for personal gain |
| Integrity | Do not place yourself under financial or other obligations to outsiders who might try to influence your official work; do not act to gain material benefits for yourself, your family or friends |
| Objectivity | Make choices such as appointments, contracts and awards impartially, fairly and on merit, using the best evidence and without bias |
| Accountability | Answer to the public for your decisions and actions, and accept whatever scrutiny your office requires |
| Openness | Act and decide transparently; do not withhold information from the public without clear and lawful reasons |
| Honesty | Be truthful, including declaring private interests that touch your public duties and resolving any conflict in a way that protects the public interest |
| Leadership | Show these principles in your own behaviour, and promote and support them in others |
A simple memory aid is the sentence 'Some Important Officers Always Open Honest Lines': Selflessness, Integrity, Objectivity, Accountability, Openness, Honesty, Leadership, in the order the Committee listed them. The Committee's wording has been refined over the years, so in an exam a clear paraphrase of each principle is what matters.
Worked example 1: which principle is broken?
Case: A municipal commissioner accepts a free foreign holiday from a builder whose building plans her office must approve. Step 1, is she acting purely for the public interest? Doubtful, so selflessness is at risk. Step 2, has she placed herself under an obligation to an outsider who may try to influence her work? Yes, and this is the defining feature of the integrity principle. Step 3, best answer: integrity. Selflessness and objectivity are also endangered, but the obligation is the core breach.
Worked example 2: openness or accountability?
Case: A state agency refuses to disclose the criteria it used to choose beneficiaries of a housing scheme, though no law prevents disclosure. Step 1, is the issue answering for a decision, or making information available? Making information available. Step 2, therefore the principle is openness. Step 3, contrast: if the agency had published the criteria but refused to explain or justify a particular decision to an auditor or the legislature, the breach would be accountability. Openness is about transparency of information; accountability is about answering for decisions and accepting scrutiny.
Principles, codes of ethics and codes of conduct
Principles such as Nolan's are broad statements of value. Organisations turn them into two kinds of documents. A code of ethics states values and ideals in general terms, such as 'we serve the public with fairness and honesty', and guides judgement where no rule exists. A code of conduct lays down specific, enforceable rules of behaviour, for example on accepting gifts, declaring assets or taking part in politics, and breaking them can lead to disciplinary action. In India, government servants are bound by conduct rules framed for their services, such as the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
| Point | Code of ethics | Code of conduct |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Values and ideals | Specific rules of behaviour |
| Language | Broad, aspirational | Precise, prescriptive |
| Enforcement | Mainly moral and professional | Formal, with penalties |
| Use | Guides judgement in new situations | Says what is required or forbidden |
Rule to remember: Nolan's seven, in order, are Selflessness, Integrity, Objectivity, Accountability, Openness, Honesty and Leadership. A code of ethics says what to value; a code of conduct says what to do and not do.
Key takeaways: the UK's Committee on Standards in Public Life under Lord Nolan set out seven principles in 1995; integrity in Nolan's sense centres on avoiding improper obligations and private gain; openness concerns information, accountability concerns answering for decisions; codes of ethics state values, codes of conduct state enforceable rules.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Seven Principles of Public Life were set out in 1995 by:
- A committee of the United Nations General Assembly
- The Committee on Standards in Public Life in the United Kingdom, chaired by Lord Nolan
- India's Central Vigilance Commission
- A committee of the Indian Parliament on ethics
Show answer
Answer: B. The principles come from the first report (1995) of the UK's Committee on Standards in Public Life, whose first chairman was Lord Nolan; hence 'Nolan principles'.
-
2. Which is NOT one of the seven Nolan principles?
- Selflessness
- Openness
- Efficiency
- Leadership
Show answer
Answer: C. The seven are selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership. Efficiency is a desirable quality but is not one of them.
-
3. An official accepts expensive hospitality from a contractor whose bills she must clear. The Nolan principle most directly breached is:
- Leadership
- Integrity
- Openness
- Accountability
Show answer
Answer: B. Nolan's integrity principle forbids placing oneself under obligations to outsiders who might seek to influence one's official work. Accepting the contractor's hospitality creates exactly such an obligation.
-
4. Refusing to explain a decision to an auditor, though the information behind it is already public, mainly breaches:
- Openness
- Selflessness
- Accountability
- Honesty
Show answer
Answer: C. The information is already available, so openness is not the issue. Refusing to answer for the decision and accept scrutiny breaches accountability.
-
5. Which is a feature of a code of conduct rather than a code of ethics?
- Specific rules whose breach can bring disciplinary action
- Broad statements of ideals such as fairness
- Guidance for judgement where no rule exists
- Aspirational language about serving society
Show answer
Answer: A. A code of conduct is precise and enforceable, with penalties. The other three describe a code of ethics, which states values and guides judgement.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.