- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
How good people drift: rationalisation, moral disengagement and the fraud triangle
Understand Cressey's fraud triangle of pressure, opportunity and rationalisation, recognise Bandura's eight mechanisms of moral disengagement in everyday speech, and learn safeguards against a slow slide into wrongdoing.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Most people who commit serious wrongs in office did not start as villains. They began with a small step, felt uneasy, found a reason that quieted the unease, and took another step. Understanding this slide is one of the best protections against it. This lesson uses two well-known ideas from social science: Donald Cressey's fraud triangle, and Albert Bandura's account of how people switch off their moral standards.
The fraud triangle
Donald Cressey interviewed people convicted of breach of financial trust and found three conditions that tended to be present together. Pressure: a need that seems too embarrassing to share, such as debt or a demand from family. Opportunity: a weak point in the system, such as unchecked cash or a file only one person can approve. Rationalisation: a story that lets the person see the act as acceptable, such as 'I am only borrowing it'. The triangle is useful because it shows three places to intervene. An organisation can lower pressure by setting realistic targets and giving staff a safe place to ask for help; it can lower opportunity by dual control, audits and rotation of duties; and it can weaken rationalisation through a culture where wrongdoing is named plainly.
Moral disengagement
Albert Bandura described how people normally regulate their conduct by their own moral standards, and how they can switch this regulation off in certain ways. He called the process moral disengagement. Eight mechanisms are usually listed.
| Mechanism | What it does | Example in an office |
|---|---|---|
| Moral justification | Makes harmful conduct look worthy | 'It is for a good cause, so the rule can wait.' |
| Euphemistic labelling | Renames the act in softer words | 'It is only speed money.' |
| Advantageous comparison | Compares the act with something worse | 'Others take far more than this.' |
| Displacement of responsibility | Puts the responsibility on an authority | 'The senior told me to do it.' |
| Diffusion of responsibility | Spreads it across a group so that no one owns it | 'It was a committee decision.' |
| Disregard or distortion of consequences | Plays down the harm | 'Nobody is really hurt by this.' |
| Dehumanisation | Treats the victims as less than persons | 'These people do not matter.' |
| Attribution of blame | Puts the blame on the victim | 'They brought this on themselves.' |
Rule to remember: the fraud triangle asks what pressure, opportunity and rationalisation are present; moral disengagement lists the eight ways of talking oneself out of conscience. Name the excuse plainly and the grip loosens.
Worked example 1: name the mechanism
Match each remark to a mechanism. (a) 'It is not a bribe, it is only a facilitation charge.' This renames the act: euphemistic labelling. (b) 'The minister told me to sign, so it is his responsibility.' This places the blame on an authority: displacement of responsibility. (c) 'Look at what the other departments are doing; ours is nothing.' This compares the act with worse conduct: advantageous comparison. (d) 'Those applicants never read the notice, so they only have themselves to blame.' This puts the fault on the victim: attribution of blame. (e) 'The project will benefit thousands, so a few shortcuts are fine.' This calls harmful conduct worthy: moral justification.
Worked example 2: a slow slide
A store-keeper begins by taking home a few sheets of office paper for his child's schoolwork ('hardly worth a rupee'). Later he lets a friendly supplier deliver short quantities and keeps the difference ('everyone does it; the stock never gets checked'). In time he starts to sell surplus stock on the side ('the department wastes more anyway'). Apply the triangle. Pressure: a loan and a sense that his pay is unfair. Opportunity: nobody counts the stock. Rationalisation: three stories, each a form of disengagement: 'hardly worth a rupee' disregards (minimises) the consequences, 'everyone does it' spreads the responsibility across a group (diffusion of responsibility), and 'the department wastes more anyway' is an advantageous comparison. Safeguards would include a regular independent stock check (opportunity), a channel for staff to raise financial or pay problems (pressure), and a culture in which even small thefts are called theft (rationalisation).
What you can do
- Say it plainly: describe the act in plain words, without euphemism, as you would to a stranger.
- Watch the first step: small steps are easier to refuse than large ones, and each step makes the next one seem smaller.
- Use a trusted listener: an excuse that sounds fine in your head often sounds weak when said aloud.
- Set bright lines: decide in advance what you will never do, so that you need not argue with yourself under pressure.
- Build safeguards: controls that reduce opportunity protect honest people from temptation.
Key takeaways. Cressey's triangle shows that wrongdoing needs pressure, opportunity and rationalisation, so each can be reduced. Bandura's eight mechanisms show how people explain wrongs away. The cure begins with plain words and early refusal.
Check your understanding
-
1. The three corners of Cressey's fraud triangle are:
- Pressure, opportunity and rationalisation
- Greed, power and fear of being caught
- Motive, means and method of concealment
- Authority, obedience and silence in the group
Show answer
Answer: A. Cressey found that pressure, opportunity and rationalisation tended to be present together when people broke financial trust.
-
2. 'It is only speed money' is an example of which mechanism?
- Displacement of responsibility
- Attribution of blame
- Euphemistic labelling
- Dehumanisation
Show answer
Answer: C. The act is renamed with a softer phrase, which is euphemistic labelling.
-
3. An officer says: 'I only signed because the senior ordered me to.' This is mainly:
- Diffusion of responsibility
- Displacement of responsibility
- Moral justification
- Advantageous comparison
Show answer
Answer: B. Responsibility is placed on an authority figure, which is displacement. Diffusion would spread it across a group.
-
4. Which safeguard mainly reduces opportunity?
- Setting a realistic workload for all staff
- A culture of naming wrongs plainly and early
- An open channel to share personal worries
- Dual control of cash and regular audits
Show answer
Answer: D. Controls such as dual signatures and audits make wrongdoing harder to carry out unnoticed.
-
5. Which step best reduces the power of rationalisation?
- Wait for the others to speak first
- Describe the act plainly, as to a stranger
- Compare the act with worse conduct elsewhere
- Say the matter is too small to be counted
Show answer
Answer: B. Stating the act plainly removes the euphemism and the excuse. The other options are forms of rationalisation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.