Revision notes

Integrity: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 9 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What integrity means: wholeness of values, words and actions

Three settings in which integrity is tested
KindWhat it meansEveryday sign
Personal integrityLiving by one's own moral principles in private lifeKeeping a promise to a friend even when breaking it would be easier
Professional integrityLiving by the values and standards of one's role or professionAn engineer refusing to approve a weak bridge design despite pressure from a contractor
Intellectual integrityHonesty in thinking, reasoning and handling evidenceA researcher reporting results that go against her own theory; never passing off another's work as one's own

Rule to remember: integrity is wholeness. Values, words and actions point the same way, in public and in private, whether or not anyone is watching.

Key takeaways: integrity comes from the Latin for 'whole'; it means consistency of values, words and actions; it is checked by the consistency test and the unobserved test; personal, professional and intellectual integrity are distinct and can come apart; a public servant needs all three.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Honesty and integrity: related but not the same

Honesty and integrity compared
PointHonestyIntegrity
Core ideaTruthfulness; not deceivingConsistency of values, words and actions
ScopeMainly speech and dealingsWhole character and conduct over time
Can it exist without the other?Yes: a person can be truthful yet unreliable or unfairNo: integrity always includes honesty
Typical failureLying, cheating, concealingHypocrisy, double standards, bending under pressure
Tested byWhether statements match factsWhether conduct matches values, especially at a cost

Rule to remember: honesty matches words to facts; integrity matches the whole of one's conduct to one's values. Every person of integrity is honest, but not every honest person has integrity.

Key takeaways: honesty is truthfulness; integrity is wider and includes honesty; honesty without integrity is possible (candid favouritism, broken commitments), integrity without honesty is not; moral courage is what carries integrity into costly action, through lawful and proportionate means.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Foundational values for civil service: what each one asks of an officer

Foundational values of civil service
ValuePlain meaningExample in an office
IntegrityValues, words and actions consistent; no misuse of officeRefusing a 'gift' from a firm whose tender is pending
ImpartialityTreating every citizen alike, without favour or prejudiceTaking up applications strictly in order of receipt
Non-partisanshipServing whichever government is in office, without taking political sides in official workGiving the same frank advice to any minister
ObjectivityDeciding on facts, evidence and merit, not on feelings or pressureChoosing a school site from data on enrolment and distance
Dedication to public serviceCommitment to the public good beyond the minimum dutyStaying back to finish relief lists during a flood
EmpathyUnderstanding a situation from the other person's point of viewSeeing why an elderly widow finds an online form impossible
ToleranceRespecting views, faiths and ways of life different from one's ownHearing fairly a complaint from a group whose beliefs one does not share
CompassionFeeling for another's suffering together with the wish to relieve itArranging a ramp so a disabled applicant can reach the counter

Rule to remember: impartiality is about persons, non-partisanship is about parties, objectivity is about evidence; empathy understands, compassion acts, and all of them work inside integrity.

Key takeaways: know the eight values and one line on each; separate impartiality (persons), non-partisanship (parties) and objectivity (evidence); separate empathy (understanding) from compassion (understanding plus action); values support one another, and compassion works within the limits set by integrity and law.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The Nolan Committee's Seven Principles of Public Life, and codes of ethics versus codes of conduct

Seven Principles of Public Life (Committee on Standards in Public Life, UK, 1995)
PrincipleWhat it asks, in plain words
SelflessnessAct solely in the public interest, not for personal gain
IntegrityDo not place yourself under financial or other obligations to outsiders who might try to influence your official work; do not act to gain material benefits for yourself, your family or friends
ObjectivityMake choices such as appointments, contracts and awards impartially, fairly and on merit, using the best evidence and without bias
AccountabilityAnswer to the public for your decisions and actions, and accept whatever scrutiny your office requires
OpennessAct and decide transparently; do not withhold information from the public without clear and lawful reasons
HonestyBe truthful, including declaring private interests that touch your public duties and resolving any conflict in a way that protects the public interest
LeadershipShow these principles in your own behaviour, and promote and support them in others
Code of ethics and code of conduct
PointCode of ethicsCode of conduct
NatureValues and idealsSpecific rules of behaviour
LanguageBroad, aspirationalPrecise, prescriptive
EnforcementMainly moral and professionalFormal, with penalties
UseGuides judgement in new situationsSays what is required or forbidden

Rule to remember: Nolan's seven, in order, are Selflessness, Integrity, Objectivity, Accountability, Openness, Honesty and Leadership. A code of ethics says what to value; a code of conduct says what to do and not do.

Key takeaways: the UK's Committee on Standards in Public Life under Lord Nolan set out seven principles in 1995; integrity in Nolan's sense centres on avoiding improper obligations and private gain; openness concerns information, accountability concerns answering for decisions; codes of ethics state values, codes of conduct state enforceable rules.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Conflict of interest, probity, corruption and whistle-blowing: the basic vocabulary

Two ways to classify corruption
BasisTypeExample
ScalePetty corruptionA small bribe to a clerk to get a certificate issued
ScaleGrand corruptionRigging the terms of a large contract or a policy at a high level
Who gainsCoercive corruptionA citizen is forced to pay for a service he is already entitled to
Who gainsCollusive corruptionBoth the payer and the official gain at public cost, such as a bribe to under-assess tax

Rule to remember: when private interest meets public duty, declare it, step aside and, if needed, give it up. Coercive corruption has a victim who can complain; collusive corruption has two winners and a silent public loser.

Key takeaways: a conflict of interest can be actual, potential or perceived; disclosure, recusal and divestment are the remedies; probity is integrity built into procedures; corruption is petty or grand by scale, coercive or collusive by who gains; whistle-blowing is internal or external, with internal channels usually tried first.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 6

Three lenses on a moral choice: consequences, duties and character

LensKey questionAssociated thinkersMain weakness
ConsequencesWhat will do the most good?Bentham, MillResults are hard to predict; may overlook minorities
DutiesWhat rule or duty applies?KantCan be rigid; duties may conflict
CharacterWhat would a person of good character do?AristotleGives less direct guidance on specific rules

Rule to remember: consequences ask what will happen, duties ask what is required, character asks what kind of person I become by doing it. When all three agree, the choice is clear; when they differ, say so and explain your reasoning.

Key takeaways. Consequentialism looks at results, deontology at duties and universal rules, and virtue ethics at character. Each has strengths and weaknesses. A strong answer in an ethics paper names the lenses accurately and applies them to the case instead of just listing them.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 7

Deciding with integrity: a seven-step method and five quick tests

TestThe question to ask
Rule testIs it lawful and consistent with the rules and the codes that bind me?
Publicity testWould I be comfortable if my act and my reasons were reported openly?
Universal-rule testIf everyone in my position did this, would the system still work and be fair?
Fairness testDoes it treat all the people affected with equal concern, with no hidden favour?
Role-reversal testWould I accept this decision if I were on the receiving end?

Rule to remember: facts, people, rules, options, tests, decision, record. If you could not explain the decision to the people it affects, or would hide it from the public, think again.

OptionRulePublicityUniversalFairDeliversTotal
A: copy silently000011
B: provisional with a note111115
C: send nothing110002

Key takeaways. Use the method when you are torn, not only when the case is easy. Look for real middle options. Test each option against the five tests, and keep a short record of the reasons.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 8

Accountability and transparency: kinds, tools and their link to public trust

KindTo whomTypical tool
PoliticalThe people, through the legislature and electionsQuestions and debates in the legislature, committees, elections
Administrative (hierarchical)Superiors within the organisationOrders, reviews, annual reports, departmental inquiry
Legal (judicial)The courts and the lawJudicial review, criminal and civil proceedings
ProfessionalPeers and professional bodiesCodes of practice, professional councils
SocialCitizens and the communityPublic hearings, audits by citizens' groups, a free press

Rule to remember: accountability is answerability plus enforceability; transparency makes accountability possible; withholding is allowed only for a stated reason that can be reviewed.

Key takeaways. Accountability means giving reasons and facing consequences; transparency lets others see what was done. The kinds of accountability are political, administrative, legal, professional and social. Withholding information needs a stated ground and can be reviewed.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 9

How good people drift: rationalisation, moral disengagement and the fraud triangle

MechanismWhat it doesExample in an office
Moral justificationMakes harmful conduct look worthy'It is for a good cause, so the rule can wait.'
Euphemistic labellingRenames the act in softer words'It is only speed money.'
Advantageous comparisonCompares the act with something worse'Others take far more than this.'
Displacement of responsibilityPuts the responsibility on an authority'The senior told me to do it.'
Diffusion of responsibilitySpreads it across a group so that no one owns it'It was a committee decision.'
Disregard or distortion of consequencesPlays down the harm'Nobody is really hurt by this.'
DehumanisationTreats the victims as less than persons'These people do not matter.'
Attribution of blamePuts the blame on the victim'They brought this on themselves.'

Rule to remember: the fraud triangle asks what pressure, opportunity and rationalisation are present; moral disengagement lists the eight ways of talking oneself out of conscience. Name the excuse plainly and the grip loosens.

Key takeaways. Cressey's triangle shows that wrongdoing needs pressure, opportunity and rationalisation, so each can be reduced. Bandura's eight mechanisms show how people explain wrongs away. The cure begins with plain words and early refusal.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery