• Practice
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Optimisation problems: boxes, cylinders and tanks

Set up and solve exam-style optimisation problems such as the largest open box, the cylinder or tank that uses the least material, and the cheapest box, avoiding the usual traps.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Optimisation word problems are where applications of derivatives earn the most marks. The calculus is short; marks are lost in setting up the function, in choosing the allowed range of the variable, and in answering a different question from the one asked. This lesson works through the standard shapes and collects results worth remembering for speed.

Setting up

  1. Draw and label the figure, naming the variable you will change (a cut, a radius, a side).
  2. Write the quantity to optimise and the constraint (a fixed volume, area or length).
  3. Use the constraint to write the quantity in one variable, and note the allowed range of that variable.
  4. Differentiate, solve, reject roots outside the allowed range, and confirm with the second derivative or by comparing values.
  5. Answer exactly what is asked: a dimension, the best value, or a ratio.

Worked example 1: the open box

Equal squares of side x are cut from the corners of a square sheet of side 18 cm, and the sides are folded up to make an open box. Find the largest volume. The base is (18 − 2x) by (18 − 2x) and the height is x, so V = x(18 − 2x)² with 0 < x < 9. V′ = (18 − 2x)² − 4x(18 − 2x) = (18 − 2x)(18 − 6x), which is zero at x = 9 (outside the range, and the volume would be 0) or x = 3. V″ = 24x − 144 = −72 < 0 at x = 3, so V = 3 × 12² = 432 cm³ is the maximum. For any square sheet of side a, the best cut is x = a/6.

Worked example 2: a rectangular sheet and the range trap

Repeat with a 16 cm by 10 cm sheet: V = x(16 − 2x)(10 − 2x) with 0 < x < 5. Expanding, V = 4x³ − 52x² + 160x, so V′ = 12x² − 104x + 160 = 4(3x − 20)(x − 2). The roots are x = 2 and x = 20/3, but 20/3 is more than 5 (half the short side), so it is rejected. At x = 2, V = 2 × 12 × 6 = 144 cm³.

Worked example 3: the closed cylinder

A closed cylindrical can must hold 54π cm³. Find the radius that uses the least metal. With radius r and height h, πr²h = 54π, so h = 54/r². The surface area is S = 2πr² + 2πrh = 2πr² + 108π/r. S′ = 4πr − 108π/r² = 0 gives r³ = 27, so r = 3 cm and h = 6 cm. S″ = 4π + 216π/r³ > 0 confirms a minimum, S = 18π + 36π = 54π cm². Notice h = 2r: the height equals the diameter.

Worked example 4: an open tank

An open tank with a square base must hold 32 m³. Find the dimensions that need the least sheet metal. With base x by x and depth h, x²h = 32. The area is S = x² + 4xh = x² + 128/x. S′ = 2x − 128/x² = 0 gives x³ = 64, so the base is 4 m by 4 m and the depth is 32/16 = 2 m. S″ = 2 + 256/x³ > 0, a minimum, with S = 16 + 32 = 48 m². Here the depth is half the side of the base.

Results worth remembering: square sheet of side a, best cut a/6. Closed cylinder of fixed volume, least surface when h = 2r. Open cylinder (no lid), h = r. Open tank with a square base, depth = half the base side. Fixed perimeter, the largest rectangle is a square.

Three traps account for most lost marks: keeping a root that is outside the physical range; giving the value of x when the question asks for the volume, or the other way round; and using the closed-can result h = 2r for a can without a lid.

Key takeaways: reduce the quantity to one variable using the constraint, find its allowed range, differentiate and keep only the roots inside the range, confirm the maximum or minimum, and answer the actual question. The standard results above let you check an answer in seconds.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Equal squares are cut from the corners of a square sheet of side 24 cm and the sides folded up to make an open box. What is the largest possible volume?

    1. 972 cm³
    2. 864 cm³
    3. 1152 cm³
    4. 1024 cm³
    Show answer

    Answer: D. V = x(24 − 2x)², V′ = (24 − 2x)(24 − 6x) = 0 gives x = 4 (x = 12 gives no box). V = 4 × 16² = 1024 cm³. Shortcut: the best cut is 24/6 = 4 cm.

  2. 2. A closed cylinder has a fixed volume. For the least total surface area, what is the ratio of its height to its radius?

    1. 1 : 1
    2. 1 : 2
    3. 2 : 1
    4. π : 1
    Show answer

    Answer: C. S = 2πr² + 2V/r, S′ = 4πr − 2V/r² = 0 gives V = 2πr³. Since V = πr²h, h = 2r, so h : r = 2 : 1 (the height equals the diameter).

  3. 3. An open cylindrical can (no lid) must hold 27π cm³ using the least metal. What is its radius?

    1. 3/∛2 cm
    2. 9 cm
    3. √3 cm
    4. 3 cm
    Show answer

    Answer: D. S = πr² + 2πrh with πr²h = 27π, so S = πr² + 54π/r. S′ = 2πr − 54π/r² = 0 gives r³ = 27, r = 3 cm (and h = 3 cm, so h = r for an open can). 3/∛2 is the closed-can answer.

  4. 4. Two positive numbers have sum 15. What is the greatest possible value of x²y, where x and y are the numbers?

    1. 421.875
    2. 500
    3. 250
    4. 1125
    Show answer

    Answer: B. With y = 15 − x, f(x) = x²(15 − x) = 15x² − x³. f′(x) = 30x − 3x² = 0 gives x = 10 (x = 0 gives 0), and f″(10) = 30 − 60 < 0. So x = 10, y = 5 and x²y = 500. (421.875 comes from wrongly splitting equally, 7.5 and 7.5.)

  5. 5. An open tank with a square base must hold 108 m³. Which dimensions need the least sheet metal?

    1. Base 3 m × 3 m, depth 12 m
    2. Base 6 m × 6 m, depth 3 m
    3. A cube of side ∛108 m
    4. Base 9 m × 9 m, depth 4/3 m
    Show answer

    Answer: B. S = x² + 4xh with x²h = 108, so S = x² + 432/x. S′ = 2x − 432/x² = 0 gives x³ = 216, x = 6 m and h = 108/36 = 3 m (depth half the base side). S = 36 + 72 = 108 m², less than the other choices (153, about 113 and 129 m²).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery