- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Related rates: ladders, cones, shadows and moving objects
Solve exam-style related-rate problems with a sliding ladder, a filling cone, a moving shadow and two moving objects, and avoid substituting values before differentiating.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course linked rates through one formula such as A = πr². Exam problems add a geometric step first: Pythagoras for a sliding ladder, similar triangles for a cone or a shadow. The method stays the same; marks are usually lost by substituting numbers too early or by losing a minus sign.
The method, with the trap marked
- Sketch the situation at a general moment and label every changing length with a letter, not a number.
- Write an equation linking them that holds at every moment (Pythagoras, similar triangles, a volume formula). If there are too many variables, eliminate one using a fixed ratio.
- Differentiate with respect to t. Only now substitute the numbers for the given instant.
- Give the answer with units and the right sign: a length that is shrinking has a negative rate.
Worked example 1: a sliding ladder
A 13 m ladder leans against a vertical wall. Its foot slides away from the wall at 2 m/s. How fast is the top sliding down when the foot is 5 m from the wall? Let x be the distance of the foot from the wall and y the height of the top. Then x² + y² = 169 at every moment, so 2x(dx/dt) + 2y(dy/dt) = 0. When x = 5, y = √(169 − 25) = 12. So 5 × 2 + 12 × dy/dt = 0, giving dy/dt = −10/12 = −5/6 m/s: the top slides down at 5/6 m/s.
Worked example 2: filling a conical tank
A tank is an inverted cone (vertex down) with radius 5 m and height 10 m. Water flows in at 9 m³/min. How fast is the level rising when the water is 6 m deep? The water forms a smaller cone of radius r and depth h. By similar triangles r/h = 5/10, so r = h/2 at every moment. Then V = (1/3)πr²h = (1/3)π(h/2)²h = πh³/12. Differentiating, dV/dt = (πh²/4)(dh/dt). At h = 6: 9 = (36π/4)(dh/dt) = 9π(dh/dt), so dh/dt = 1/π m/min (about 0.32 m/min). The trap is to treat r as the constant 5: the water surface widens as it rises, so r must be replaced by h/2 before differentiating.
Worked example 3: a moving shadow
A man 2 m tall walks away from a 6 m lamp post at 5 km/h. How fast does his shadow lengthen? Let x be his distance from the post and s the length of his shadow. Similar triangles give 6/(x + s) = 2/s, so 6s = 2x + 2s and s = x/2. Then ds/dt = (1/2)(dx/dt) = 2.5 km/h, the same at every moment. The tip of the shadow is x + s from the post, so it moves at 5 + 2.5 = 7.5 km/h. Read the question: the rate at which the shadow lengthens and the speed of its tip are different answers.
Write the relation at a general moment, eliminate extra variables using a fixed ratio, differentiate with respect to t, then substitute. Ladder: x(dx/dt) + y(dy/dt) = 0. Cone with r = kh: V = (1/3)πk²h³.
Worked example 4: two ships
Ship A sails east from a port at 30 km/h and ship B sails north from the same port at 40 km/h, both starting together. After t hours A is 30t km east and B is 40t km north, so their distance apart is D = √((30t)² + (40t)²) = 50t, and dD/dt = 50 km/h at every moment. In general, from D² = a² + b², differentiating gives D(dD/dt) = a(da/dt) + b(db/dt), which also works when the two rates are not constant.
Key takeaways: label changing lengths with letters, link them with Pythagoras or similar triangles, reduce to the variables whose rates you know or want, then differentiate. Substitute only after differentiating, keep signs for shrinking quantities, and check whether the question wants a length's rate or a point's speed.
Check your understanding
-
1. A 10 m ladder leans against a wall. Its foot slides away from the wall at 3 m/s. How fast is the top sliding down the wall when the foot is 6 m from the wall?
- 4 m/s
- 2.25 m/s
- 3 m/s
- 1.8 m/s
Show answer
Answer: B. x² + y² = 100, so x(dx/dt) + y(dy/dt) = 0. When x = 6, y = 8. So 6 × 3 + 8 × dy/dt = 0, giving dy/dt = −18/8 = −2.25 m/s: the top slides down at 2.25 m/s.
-
2. Water is poured at 8π cm³/s into a conical vessel, vertex down, whose radius equals its height at every level. How fast is the water level rising when the depth is 4 cm?
- 2 cm/s
- 1/8 cm/s
- 1/2 cm/s
- 1/6 cm/s
Show answer
Answer: C. With r = h, V = (1/3)πh³, so dV/dt = πh²(dh/dt). At h = 4: 8π = 16π(dh/dt), so dh/dt = 1/2 cm/s.
-
3. A girl 1.5 m tall walks away from a 9 m lamp post at 2 m/s. How fast is her shadow lengthening?
- 2.4 m/s
- 1.2 m/s
- 0.33 m/s
- 0.4 m/s
Show answer
Answer: D. Similar triangles: 9/(x + s) = 1.5/s, so 9s = 1.5x + 1.5s, 7.5s = 1.5x and s = x/5. So ds/dt = (1/5) × 2 = 0.4 m/s. (2.4 m/s is the speed of the tip of the shadow.)
-
4. Car A is 3 km from a crossroads, driving towards it at 60 km/h. Car B is on the perpendicular road, 4 km from the crossroads, driving towards it at 30 km/h. How is the distance between the cars changing at this moment?
- Decreasing at 90 km/h
- Increasing at 60 km/h
- Decreasing at 60 km/h
- Decreasing at 300 km/h
Show answer
Answer: C. D² = a² + b², so D(dD/dt) = a(da/dt) + b(db/dt). Here a = 3, b = 4, D = 5, and both distances shrink: da/dt = −60, db/dt = −30. So 5(dD/dt) = −180 − 120 = −300 and dD/dt = −60 km/h.
-
5. A spherical snowball melts so that its volume decreases at 1 cm³/min. How fast is its diameter decreasing when the diameter is 10 cm?
- 1/(25π) cm/min
- 1/(100π) cm/min
- 1/(200π) cm/min
- 1/(50π) cm/min
Show answer
Answer: D. In terms of the diameter D, V = (4/3)π(D/2)³ = πD³/6, so dV/dt = (πD²/2)(dD/dt). At D = 10: −1 = 50π(dD/dt), so dD/dt = −1/(50π) cm/min. (1/(100π) is the rate for the radius, half as fast.)
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.