- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Parliament and the Budget: Money Bills, vote on account and cut motions
Follow how Parliament controls money: Money Bills, demands for grants, the Appropriation Bill, supplementary grants, vote on account and the three kinds of cut motion.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The Budget is not law the moment it is read out. Parliament must authorise both the taxes and the spending, and the Constitution lays down the steps. Exams ask which house does what, which article covers which case, and what each kind of motion means. This lesson sets out these rules as they stand in the Constitution.
No tax without law
Article 265 says that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. Article 266 says that money cannot be taken from the Consolidated Fund of India except under a law of Parliament. Taxes and spending both need Parliament's consent.
Money Bills and the two houses
- A Money Bill (defined in Article 110) deals only with matters such as taxes, borrowing and spending from the Consolidated Fund. The Speaker certifies whether a bill is a Money Bill.
- It can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha (Article 109), and only on the recommendation of the President.
- The Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days. It can only recommend changes, and the Lok Sabha may accept or reject them. If the Rajya Sabha does nothing in 14 days, the bill is deemed passed by both houses.
Demands for grants and cut motions
Expenditure is put to the Lok Sabha as demands for grants (Article 113). Only the Lok Sabha votes on them; the Rajya Sabha may discuss the Budget but does not vote on demands. Expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund is discussed but not voted. Members may move cut motions to reduce a demand:
| Cut motion | Reduces the demand to / by | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Policy cut | To ₹1 | Disapproval of the policy behind the demand |
| Economy cut | By a stated amount | Savings can be made in expenditure |
| Token cut | By ₹100 | To air a specific grievance |
From demand to law: the Appropriation Bill
After the demands are voted, the Appropriation Bill (Article 114) is passed to authorise withdrawal from the Consolidated Fund. The Finance Bill (Article 110 and 117) gives effect to tax proposals. Two further articles cover special cases. Article 115 allows supplementary, additional or excess grants when the sanctioned amount is not enough. Article 116 allows a vote on account, an advance grant to meet expenses for part of the year while the full Budget is still being passed.
Worked example 1: which route?
Example 1. A flood forces a ministry to spend ₹200 crore more than Parliament sanctioned for the year. The extra money is sought through a supplementary grant under Article 115. Example 2. Elections are due and the full Budget cannot be passed before the new financial year begins. Parliament passes a vote on account under Article 116 so that salaries and running costs continue.
Worked example 2: size of a vote on account
A ministry's annual estimate is ₹1,200 crore. A vote on account covers four months, spent at an even rate. Amount = 1,200 x 4 / 12 = ₹400 crore. The full year's demand is voted later, and the advance is adjusted against it.
Worked example 3: the 14-day rule
A Money Bill passes the Lok Sabha and is sent to the Rajya Sabha on 3 March. The Rajya Sabha recommends three changes on 12 March, within 14 days. The Lok Sabha may accept none, some or all of them. Had the Rajya Sabha sent nothing back by 17 March, the bill would be deemed passed in the form the Lok Sabha passed it.
Money Bill: Lok Sabha only; Rajya Sabha has 14 days and can only recommend. Demands for grants: voted by the Lok Sabha. Article 115 is extra money; Article 116 is the vote on account.
Key takeaways
- Taxes need law (Article 265); spending from the Consolidated Fund needs Parliament's authority.
- The Lok Sabha has the final say on a Money Bill.
- Cut motions: policy (₹1), economy (stated amount), token (₹100).
- Appropriation Bill authorises spending; Finance Bill gives effect to taxes.
- Article 115 covers extra grants; Article 116 covers a vote on account.
Check your understanding
-
1. A Money Bill can be introduced only in
- either house
- the Rajya Sabha
- the Lok Sabha
- a joint sitting
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 109 allows a Money Bill to be introduced only in the Lok Sabha.
-
2. The Rajya Sabha must return a Money Bill, with any recommendations, within
- 7 days
- 14 days
- 30 days
- 3 months
Show answer
Answer: B. The Rajya Sabha has 14 days. After that the bill is deemed passed by both houses in the form the Lok Sabha passed it.
-
3. A motion to reduce a demand by ₹100 to air a specific grievance is a
- token cut
- economy cut
- policy cut
- charged cut
Show answer
Answer: A. A token cut reduces the demand by ₹100 and is used to air a specific grievance. A policy cut reduces it to ₹1.
-
4. An advance grant covering part of the year's spending, passed before the full Budget, is made under
- a supplementary grant
- a Finance Bill
- a Money Bill
- a vote on account
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 116 provides the vote on account. Supplementary grants under Article 115 add to an amount already sanctioned.
-
5. A ministry's annual estimate is ₹900 crore. A vote on account for 2 months at an even rate is
- ₹450 crore
- ₹300 crore
- ₹150 crore
- ₹180 crore
Show answer
Answer: C. 900 x 2 / 12 = ₹150 crore.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.