- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Types of budgets, subsidies and the role of the Finance Commission
Learn balanced, surplus and deficit budgets, zero-based and outcome budgeting ideas, the logic of subsidies, and how the Finance Commission shares revenue.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson rounds off the Budget by covering the kinds of budget, why governments give subsidies, and how tax money is shared between the Centre and the states.
Kinds of budget by balance
| Type | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Balanced | Expenditure equals receipts |
| Surplus | Receipts exceed expenditure |
| Deficit | Expenditure exceeds receipts |
Economists once favoured balanced budgets; modern thinking accepts planned deficits in a slump (to boost demand) and surpluses in a boom (to cool it).
Budgeting approaches
- Line-item budget: the traditional method; money is allotted by item such as salaries and travel.
- Performance budget: links spending to the results expected.
- Zero-based budget: every item must be justified afresh each year and does not simply continue from last year.
- Gender budget: reports how much of public spending benefits women.
Subsidies
A subsidy is a payment by the government that lowers the price paid by the buyer or raises the income of the producer. Reasons include protecting the poor (food), encouraging a desirable activity (fertiliser for farm output) and correcting externalities (clean energy). The costs are the pressure on the deficit, possible wastage, and distorted prices. This is why governments often prefer to deliver subsidies directly to the beneficiary rather than through price cuts.
Worked example 1
A good costs Rs 50 to produce and the government pays Rs 15 per unit as subsidy, so the farmer buys it for Rs 35. If 1,00,000 units are sold, the subsidy bill is 15 x 1,00,000 = Rs 15,00,000. This amount adds to revenue expenditure.
Centre and states: the Finance Commission
India is a federation. The Centre collects some of the larger taxes, while states carry many spending responsibilities. This creates a gap, and the Constitution (Article 280) provides for a Finance Commission, appointed by the President every five years, to recommend how the divisible pool of central taxes is shared between the Centre and the states, and among the states, and the principles for grants to states. Its recommendations are advisory, though they are usually accepted. The percentages it recommended in particular years change from one commission to the next, so learn the role, not the number.
Worked example 2
Suppose the divisible pool of taxes is Rs 1,000 crore and the Commission recommends that states together receive 40% (illustrative). States get Rs 400 crore. If State A's share among the states is 5%, it receives 5% of 400 = Rs 20 crore. The formula for the share among states depends on factors such as population, area and income distance, but the arithmetic is as shown.
Key takeaways
- Budgets can be balanced, surplus or deficit.
- Zero-based and performance budgets tie spending to need and results.
- Subsidies help but add to the deficit.
- The Finance Commission recommends the sharing of taxes between the Centre and states.
Check your understanding
-
1. A budget in which receipts exceed expenditure is a
- Balanced budget
- Deficit budget
- Surplus budget
- Zero-based budget
Show answer
Answer: C. When receipts are more than expenditure the budget is in surplus; equal is balanced; less is deficit.
-
2. A budget in which every item must be justified afresh each year, instead of continuing from last year, is a
- Zero-based budget
- Line-item budget
- Performance budget
- Gender budget
Show answer
Answer: A. Zero-based budgeting starts each item from zero. A performance budget links spending to results, and a gender budget reports benefits to women.
-
3. Which Article of the Constitution provides for the Finance Commission?
- Article 267
- Article 112
- Article 279A
- Article 280
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 280 provides for the Finance Commission. Article 267 is the Contingency Fund, 112 the Annual Financial Statement and 279A the GST Council.
-
4. A good costs Rs 40 per unit to produce and the government pays a subsidy of Rs 12 per unit. If 50,000 units are sold, what is the subsidy bill?
- Rs 20,00,000
- Rs 6,00,000
- Rs 14,00,000
- Rs 60,000
Show answer
Answer: B. Subsidy bill = subsidy per unit x quantity = 12 x 50,000 = Rs 6,00,000. It adds to revenue expenditure.
-
5. Which statement about the Finance Commission is correct?
- It is chaired by the Union Finance Minister and sets tax rates
- Its recommendations bind Parliament and cannot be changed
- It manages the Contingency Fund on behalf of the President
- It is appointed by the President every five years to recommend how central taxes in the divisible pool are shared with the states
Show answer
Answer: D. The Finance Commission (Article 280) recommends sharing of the divisible pool between the Centre and states and among states, and principles for grants. Its recommendations are advisory, though usually accepted.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.