• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Public goods, merit goods and why governments spend

Use the tests of rivalry and excludability to classify goods, explain the free-rider problem, and see how taxes and subsidies correct externalities.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Markets work well when buyers pay and sellers deliver. For some goods they fail, and that is the economic reason for much government spending. This lesson gives the tests that sort goods into groups, and the simple tools that governments use when a market gives too little or too much.

Two tests: rivalry and excludability

A good is rival if one person's use leaves less for others (an apple). A good is excludable if a non-payer can be kept from using it (a cinema ticket). Combining the two tests gives four groups.

GroupRival?Excludable?Example
Private goodYesYesBread, a bicycle
Public goodNoNoStreet lighting, national defence
Club goodNoYesAn uncrowded toll road, a cable channel
Common resourceYesNoFish in the open sea, a village pasture

The free-rider problem

Because nobody can be stopped from enjoying a public good, each person has a reason to let others pay. This is the free-rider problem. If everyone thinks this way, the good is not supplied at all, so the government supplies it and pays by taxation.

Merit and demerit goods

Merit goods, such as school education and vaccination, are goods that the community believes people should have, and that people would otherwise buy too little of. Governments provide or subsidise them. Demerit goods, such as tobacco, are consumed too much, so governments tax or restrict them.

Externalities

An externality is a cost or benefit that falls on people who are not part of the deal. Pollution is a negative externality; a neighbour's well-kept garden, or immunisation that stops a disease spreading, is a positive one. The government can tax a negative externality (the amount of the tax is set equal to the damage) and subsidise a positive one.

Worked example 1: sorting goods

Example 1. Classify (a) a lighthouse, (b) a packet of biscuits, (c) fish in the open sea, (d) a paid streaming channel. Step 1: ask if one user reduces what is left for others. Biscuits and fish: yes. Lighthouse and channel: no. Step 2: ask if non-payers can be excluded. Biscuits and the channel: yes. Lighthouse and fish: no. Result: lighthouse = public; biscuits = private; fish = common resource; channel = club good.

Worked example 2: should the government build it?

Example 2. A lane of 100 households needs a street light that costs ₹3,000 to install. Each household would gain benefit worth ₹50. Total benefit = 100 x 50 = ₹5,000, which is more than the cost of ₹3,000, so the light is worth building. If installation is left to voluntary payment, each household hopes its neighbours will pay. A tax of 3,000 / 100 = ₹30 per household gets the light built, and every household is better off by 50 - 30 = ₹20.

Worked example 3: taxing a negative externality

Example 3. A factory's private cost is ₹100 per unit, but the smoke harms neighbours by ₹20 per unit. Social cost = 100 + 20 = ₹120. A tax of ₹20 per unit makes the firm bear the full ₹120, so it produces the right amount.

Public good: not rival and not excludable, so it needs the government. Negative externality: tax it. Positive externality and merit goods: subsidise or provide them.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Rivalry and excludability sort goods into private, public, club and common resources.
  • The free-rider problem is why public goods are tax-funded.
  • Merit goods are under-consumed; demerit goods are over-consumed.
  • A tax equal to the external damage corrects a negative externality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A good that is both non-rival and non-excludable is a

    1. common resource
    2. private good
    3. club good
    4. public good
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Public goods such as street lighting are non-rival (one user does not reduce supply) and non-excludable.

  2. 2. The free-rider problem arises because

    1. public goods are always wasteful to produce
    2. every buyer must pay exactly the same price
    3. nobody can be kept from using the good
    4. taxes on goods are collected too late
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Where non-payers cannot be excluded, each person is tempted to let others pay, and the good is under-supplied.

  3. 3. Fish in the open sea are an example of a

    1. public good
    2. common resource
    3. private good
    4. demerit good
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Fish are rival (one catch reduces what remains) and non-excludable, which defines a common resource.

  4. 4. A factory's smoke harms neighbours by ₹15 per unit. A tax that corrects this externality is

    1. ₹15 per unit
    2. ₹150 per unit
    3. ₹5 per unit
    4. no tax at all
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The tax should equal the external damage, so the firm faces the full social cost.

  5. 5. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Street light: private good
    2. Tobacco: merit good
    3. Vaccination: merit good
    4. Bread: public good
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Vaccination is a merit good. Tobacco is a demerit good, street lights are public goods, and bread is a private good.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery