• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Beyond taxes: fees, fines, grants and borrowing as sources of public revenue

Distinguish a tax from a fee, fine and special assessment, see what counts as non-tax revenue, and compare the shares of tax, non-tax revenue and borrowing in a government's funds.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Taxes are the biggest source of government money, but not the only one. Governments also earn fees, fines, interest and profits from public enterprises, receive grants, and borrow. Exam questions often ask what counts as a tax and what does not. This lesson sorts the sources into groups.

Tax and non-tax revenue

A tax is compulsory and gives no direct return to the payer. Non-tax revenue includes everything else the government earns without taxing.

Sources of non-tax revenue
SourceMeaningExample
Feepayment for a service from which the payer benefits directly; some public benefit also arisescourt fee, passport fee
Fine or penaltypayment imposed to punish a wrongdoing, not to raise revenuetraffic fine
Special assessmentpayment by property owners whose land gains in value from a public workcharge to owners near a new road
Price or user chargeprice of a service supplied by the governmentwater charges, bus fare
Interest and dividendsearnings on loans given and on shares held in public enterprisesdividend from a public company
Grantsgifts from another government or institutiona grant from the Centre to a state

Tax versus fee

The key difference is the quid pro quo, something in return. A fee is linked to a service the payer receives, while a tax is not. A passport fee is paid by the person who gets a passport. Income tax is paid by earners but the road they use is available to everyone, whether or not they paid.

Worked example 1: shares of public receipts

In a year a government's funds are: tax revenue Rs 700 crore, non-tax revenue Rs 100 crore and borrowing Rs 200 crore. Total = 1,000. Shares: tax 70 percent, non-tax 10 percent, borrowing 20 percent. A government with a larger borrowing share relies more on future repayment and may have a higher interest bill later.

Worked example 2: cost recovery from a user charge

A canal supplies water that costs Rs 200 per hectare to deliver. Farmers are charged Rs 80 per hectare. Cost recovery = 80 / 200 x 100 = 40 percent. The remaining 60 percent, Rs 120 per hectare, is a subsidy paid out of other revenue. For 1,000 hectares the subsidy is 120 x 1,000 = Rs 1,20,000. Charging the full cost would leave out poorer farmers, so governments often accept a partial recovery.

Worked example 3: sort the receipt

  • A fee paid for a birth certificate: non-tax revenue (fee).
  • A fine for breaking a traffic rule: non-tax revenue (fine).
  • A tax on the sale of fuel: tax revenue.
  • A dividend from a public sector company: non-tax revenue.
  • Money raised by selling government bonds: borrowing, a capital receipt.

Borrowing and creating money

When revenue falls short, the government can borrow from the public, banks or abroad. It can also borrow from the central bank, which creates new money. Creating money funds spending at once but can raise prices if the supply of goods does not grow with it.

A tax is compulsory with no direct return. A fee is paid for a service received. A fine is a penalty. Interest, dividends and grants are non-tax receipts.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: separate tax from non-tax revenue; look for the quid pro quo to tell a fee from a tax; compute cost recovery as charge divided by cost; and remember that borrowing is a capital receipt.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A payment made for a particular service received by the payer is called:

    1. a grant
    2. a tax
    3. a fine
    4. a fee
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A fee carries a quid pro quo; the payer receives a specific service.

  2. 2. Which is NOT a tax?

    1. a fine for a traffic offence
    2. income tax on salaries
    3. a duty on imported goods
    4. a tax on goods and services
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A fine is a penalty, not a tax.

  3. 3. A water scheme costs Rs 50 per unit and charges Rs 30 per unit. The cost recovery is:

    1. 167 percent
    2. 30 percent
    3. 40 percent
    4. 60 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 30 / 50 x 100 = 60 percent.

  4. 4. A government raises Rs 600 crore from taxes, Rs 150 crore from non-tax sources and Rs 250 crore by borrowing. The share of borrowing is:

    1. 60 percent
    2. 15 percent
    3. 25 percent
    4. 250 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Total = 1,000. Borrowing share = 250 / 1,000 = 25 percent.

  5. 5. A dividend received from a public sector company is:

    1. tax revenue
    2. non-tax revenue
    3. a penalty fine
    4. capital expenditure
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It is a return on the government's investment, not a tax.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Public finance

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery