- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Progressive, proportional and regressive taxes: average and marginal rates
Calculate a tax from a slab schedule, find average and marginal rates, and tell progressive, proportional and regressive taxes apart with simple examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not all taxes treat rich and poor alike. Some take a larger share of income as income rises; others take the same share; others take a smaller share. To tell which is which, we compare the tax with the income. This lesson shows how to do that, using made-up rates.
Three kinds of tax
| Kind | Rule | Result for rich and poor |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | the share of income paid as tax rises as income rises | the rich pay a higher percentage |
| Proportional | the share of income paid as tax is the same at all incomes | everyone pays the same percentage |
| Regressive | the share of income paid as tax falls as income rises | the poor pay a higher percentage |
Average rate and marginal rate
Average rate = tax paid / income x 100. Marginal rate is the rate on the next rupee earned, that is, the extra tax divided by the extra income. A progressive tax has a marginal rate above the average rate.
Worked example 1: a slab schedule
Suppose the schedule is: nothing on the first Rs 2,00,000; 10 percent on the next Rs 3,00,000 (up to Rs 5,00,000); and 20 percent on income above Rs 5,00,000. These are made-up rates. For an income of Rs 7,00,000:
- First Rs 2,00,000: tax = 0.
- Next Rs 3,00,000 at 10 percent: tax = 30,000.
- Remaining Rs 2,00,000 at 20 percent: tax = 40,000.
Total tax = 0 + 30,000 + 40,000 = Rs 70,000. Average rate = 70,000 / 7,00,000 x 100 = 10 percent. Marginal rate = 20 percent, because the next rupee is taxed at 20 percent.
For an income of Rs 4,00,000, tax = 0 + 10 percent of 2,00,000 = Rs 20,000, an average rate of 5 percent. The average rate rises from 5 to 10 percent as income rises from 4 to 7 lakh, so this tax is progressive.
Worked example 2: a proportional tax
A flat tax of 10 percent takes Rs 1,000 from an income of Rs 10,000, and Rs 10,000 from an income of Rs 1,00,000. In both cases the share is 10 percent, so the tax is proportional. The rich pay more rupees but not a larger percentage.
Worked example 3: a tax that is regressive in effect
A tax of 10 percent is charged on the price of a basic item. A poor family with an income of Rs 10,000 spends Rs 1,000 on the item and pays Rs 100 in tax, or 100 / 10,000 = 1 percent of its income. A rich family with an income of Rs 1,00,000 spends Rs 2,000 on the same item and pays Rs 200, or 200 / 1,00,000 = 0.2 percent of its income. The rich pay more rupees but a smaller share of income, so the tax is regressive in effect. Taxes on goods that everyone must buy are regressive for this reason.
Progressive: average rate rises with income. Proportional: average rate is constant. Regressive: average rate falls with income.
Why governments use progressive taxes
Progressive taxes follow the canon of equity (ability to pay) and reduce inequality. But very high rates may reduce the incentive to earn and save, and may encourage evasion, so governments balance the aims.
Key takeaways: compute the tax slab by slab; use tax divided by income for the average rate; read the marginal rate from the top slab reached; and compare average rates at different incomes to classify the tax.
Check your understanding
-
1. A tax in which the percentage of income paid rises with income is:
- a fine
- proportional
- regressive
- progressive
Show answer
Answer: D. The average rate rising with income is the definition of a progressive tax.
-
2. The tax paid on an income of Rs 20,000 is Rs 2,000. The average rate is:
- 1 percent
- 10 percent
- 20 percent
- 90 percent
Show answer
Answer: B. 2,000 / 20,000 x 100 = 10 percent.
-
3. Income of Rs 6,00,000 under the schedule in this lesson attracts a tax of:
- Rs 30,000
- Rs 60,000
- Rs 50,000
- Rs 1,20,000
Show answer
Answer: C. First 2 lakh: 0. Next 3 lakh at 10 percent: 30,000. Remaining 1 lakh at 20 percent: 20,000. Total 50,000.
-
4. A flat tax of 15 percent on all incomes is:
- progressive
- proportional
- regressive
- a poll tax
Show answer
Answer: B. The same percentage is paid at all incomes, so it is proportional.
-
5. A poor family pays 1 percent of its income and a rich family 0.2 percent as tax on a basic item. The tax is:
- regressive in effect
- progressive in effect
- proportional in effect
- a direct tax
Show answer
Answer: A. The share of income paid falls as income rises, so the tax is regressive in effect.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.