- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
What a tax is: direct and indirect taxes and the canons of taxation
Learn what a tax is, tell direct taxes from indirect taxes by who bears the burden, and apply Adam Smith's four canons to judge whether a tax is good.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A government cannot build roads, run schools or pay for defence without money. Its chief source of money is taxes. A tax is a compulsory payment made by people and firms to the government, with no direct payment in return for the particular person who pays. Because everyone benefits from public services, everyone must pay. This lesson explains the two main kinds of tax and the rules that make a tax good.
Direct and indirect taxes
The test is simple: can the person who pays the tax pass the burden on to someone else?
- Direct tax: the burden falls on the person who pays it, who cannot shift it. Examples: income tax and corporation tax.
- Indirect tax: the person who pays the tax to the government can pass the burden to others through a higher price. Examples: tax on goods and services, customs duty and excise duty.
The person on whom the tax is imposed is said to bear the impact. The person who finally bears the burden bears the incidence. For a direct tax, impact and incidence fall on the same person. For an indirect tax, the impact is on the seller but the incidence may fall on the buyer.
| Feature | Direct tax | Indirect tax |
|---|---|---|
| Who bears the burden | the person who pays | usually the buyer |
| Linked to | income or wealth | price of goods and services |
| Can the burden be shifted? | no | yes, wholly or partly |
| Feel of the tax | clearly visible | often hidden in the price |
Worked example 1: who pays?
A shopkeeper pays a tax of Rs 5 on each packet of biscuits he sells and raises the price by Rs 5. The shopkeeper hands the tax to the government (impact), but the customer bears the Rs 5 (incidence). That is an indirect tax. A salaried worker pays income tax from her salary; she cannot raise a price to recover it. That is a direct tax.
Adam Smith's four canons of taxation
Adam Smith set out four rules for a good tax system, called the canons of taxation.
| Canon | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Equity | people should pay according to their ability | a richer person pays more tax |
| Certainty | the amount, time and manner of payment should be clear | a published rate and due date |
| Convenience | payment should be made at a time and in a way that suits the taxpayer | tax deducted from the salary each month |
| Economy | the cost of collecting should be small compared with the tax collected | if collection costs more than the tax, it is a poor tax |
Worked example 2: collection cost
A tax raises Rs 500 crore, and it costs Rs 25 crore to collect. The cost of collection is 25 / 500 x 100 = 5 percent of the revenue. Another tax raises Rs 100 crore but costs Rs 40 crore to collect, a cost of 40 percent. The second tax breaks the canon of economy, because a large part of the revenue is lost in collecting it.
Worked example 3: which canon?
A tax that changes its rate several times a year so that nobody knows what to expect breaks the canon of certainty. A tax payable in one lump on a date when farmers have no cash breaks the canon of convenience. A tax that takes the same rupee amount from a poor family and a rich one breaks the canon of equity.
Direct tax: the burden stays with the payer. Indirect tax: the burden can be shifted. Smith's canons: equity, certainty, convenience, economy.
Key takeaways: a tax is a compulsory payment; use the shifting test to separate direct from indirect taxes; and judge a tax by the four canons.
Check your understanding
-
1. A tax whose burden the payer cannot pass on to someone else is called:
- a direct tax
- an indirect tax
- a fee
- a fine
Show answer
Answer: A. The burden of a direct tax stays with the person who pays it to the government.
-
2. A tax on goods that the seller adds to the price is mainly:
- a wealth tax
- a direct tax on income
- an indirect tax
- a tax on profits only
Show answer
Answer: C. The seller passes the tax on to the buyer through the price.
-
3. A tax that raises Rs 200 crore at a collection cost of Rs 10 crore has a collection cost of:
- 5 percent
- 20 percent
- 2 percent
- 50 percent
Show answer
Answer: A. 10 / 200 x 100 = 5 percent.
-
4. The canon of 'certainty' means that:
- the tax should be collected by force
- the tax should be kept very low
- the tax should apply only to the rich
- the taxpayer knows the amount and date
Show answer
Answer: D. Certainty requires that the amount, time and manner of payment be clear to the taxpayer.
-
5. Which is one of Adam Smith's four canons?
- elasticity of supply
- inflation
- economy
- depreciation
Show answer
Answer: C. The four canons are equity, certainty, convenience and economy.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.