- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Direct and indirect taxes
Learn the difference between direct and indirect taxes, impact versus incidence, and the merits and demerits of each type.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Taxes are most commonly classified into direct and indirect. The distinction is made on one test: can the person who pays the tax to the government shift the burden to someone else?
Impact and incidence
The impact of a tax is on the person who legally pays it to the government. The incidence is on the person who finally bears the burden. When these are the same person, the tax is direct. When the burden can be passed on, it is indirect.
| Feature | Direct tax | Indirect tax |
|---|---|---|
| Burden | Cannot be shifted | Can be shifted to the buyer |
| Levied on | Income, wealth, profits | Goods and services |
| Examples | Income tax, corporation tax | Goods and services tax, customs duty |
| Fairness | Can be progressive | Tends to be regressive |
| Evasion | Easier to evade by hiding income | Harder, because it is collected at the point of sale |
| Awareness | The payer knows he pays | Often hidden inside the price |
Why indirect taxes can be regressive
A rich and a poor person who buy the same kilo of sugar pay the same tax on it. But that tax is a bigger share of the poor person's income. So an indirect tax on essentials takes a larger share of income from the poor than from the rich.
Merits and demerits
- Direct taxes: equitable, can be adjusted to ability to pay, build civic awareness; but they can reduce the incentive to work and save, and can be evaded.
- Indirect taxes: wide base, convenient (paid in small bits with the price), hard to evade; but they raise prices, can be regressive, and the burden is hidden.
Worked example 1
A shopkeeper sells a pair of shoes with a tax of Rs 50 included in a Rs 1,050 price. He pays the Rs 50 to the government but has recovered it from the customer. The impact is on the shopkeeper; the incidence is on the customer. It is an indirect tax.
Worked example 2 - burden on income
A household with income of Rs 20,000 per month spends Rs 10,000 on taxed goods carrying 10% tax in the price. Tax paid is about 10,000 x 0.10 / 1.10 = about Rs 909, or 4.5% of income. A household with income of Rs 1,00,000 spends Rs 30,000 on the same goods, paying about Rs 2,727, which is 2.7% of income. Burden as a share of income is smaller for the rich, so the tax is regressive in effect.
Key takeaways
- Direct: burden cannot be shifted; indirect: burden can be shifted.
- Direct taxes suit equity; indirect taxes suit convenience and wide coverage.
- Indirect taxes on essentials are regressive.
- Impact is on the payer to government; incidence is on who bears it.
Check your understanding
-
1. The incidence of a tax is on
- The person who finally bears the burden
- The person who legally pays it to the government
- The government that collects it
- The official who assesses it
Show answer
Answer: A. Impact is on the legal payer; incidence is on whoever finally bears the burden.
-
2. A shopkeeper pays a tax on shoes to the government but has recovered it from the customer through the price. Which is correct?
- Impact and incidence are both on the shopkeeper
- Impact is on the customer; incidence is on the shopkeeper
- Impact and incidence are both on the government
- Impact is on the shopkeeper; incidence is on the customer
Show answer
Answer: D. The shopkeeper legally pays (impact) but the customer bears it (incidence), so this is an indirect tax.
-
3. Which of these is a direct tax?
- Goods and services tax
- Corporation tax
- Customs duty
- A tax on sale of goods
Show answer
Answer: B. Corporation tax is levied on profits and cannot be shifted; the others are indirect taxes on goods and services.
-
4. Why is an indirect tax on an essential item regressive in effect?
- Rich people pay a higher rate on the same item
- Poor people are exempt from it
- It is levied only on income above a limit
- The same tax takes a larger share of a poor person's income than a rich person's
Show answer
Answer: D. A rich and a poor buyer pay the same tax on the same item, but it is a bigger fraction of the poorer person's income.
-
5. A household earning Rs 30,000 a month spends Rs 12,000 on goods whose price includes a 20% tax. About what share of its income goes in this tax?
- 8%
- About 6.7%
- 20%
- 40%
Show answer
Answer: B. Tax inside the price = 12,000 x 0.20 / 1.20 = Rs 2,000. 2,000 / 30,000 = about 6.7%. Taking 20% of 12,000 (8%) wrongly treats the price as excluding tax.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.