• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Who can levy which tax: the Union, the States and local bodies

Explain the constitutional rule that no tax may be levied without law, sort common taxes into Union, State and local taxes, and describe how shareable taxes are divided.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

India is a federation, so more than one government raises taxes. The Constitution decides which government may tax what, so that people are not taxed twice for the same thing by different authorities and no authority taxes without legal backing. In this lesson you will learn the main rule, sort the most common taxes by level of government and see how money is shared. All sums of money are illustrative.

No tax without law

Article 265 of the Constitution states that no tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law. A government cannot create a tax by an order, a circular or a notice alone: Parliament (for the Union) or a State Legislature (for a State) must pass a law. This protects citizens from arbitrary demands and is the legal basis of the canon of certainty that you studied earlier.

Three levels of government

The Seventh Schedule lists subjects on which the Union and the States can make laws. Taxes are named in the Union List and the State List, and powers not listed anywhere (residuary powers) belong to the Union. In broad terms:

Who levies what
LevelExamples of taxes and leviesWhy this level
Union (Centre)Tax on income other than agricultural income, corporation tax, customs dutiesIncome and foreign trade are national in character
StateTax on agricultural income, land revenue, State excise on alcoholic drinks for human consumptionLand and local resources belong to the States
Local bodies (municipalities, panchayats)Property tax, water and drainage charges, licence feesServices such as roads, water supply and sanitation are local

Since the goods and services tax was introduced, the Centre and States levy it together on the same base under one framework (CGST and SGST), as you saw earlier. Several older, separate State and Union levies on goods and services were merged into it.

Sharing the proceeds

The Centre collects a large share of the tax revenue, while the States are responsible for many costly services such as health, police and school education. This gap between the revenue raised and the spending needed at the State level is called the vertical imbalance. The Constitution addresses it through a Finance Commission (Article 280), appointed by the President every five years, which recommends how the net proceeds of shareable taxes should be divided between the Centre and the States and among the States themselves. Parliament may also give grants to States in need.

Worked example 1: sorting taxes

(a) A shop owner pays customs duty on imported machines: Union. (b) A farmer pays tax on income from farming: State, because agricultural income is outside the Union's income tax. (c) A town council charges a yearly tax on houses: local property tax. (d) A salaried employee has income tax deducted: Union. (e) A company pays corporation tax on its profit: Union. (f) The State charges excise on liquor sold in its territory: State. Notice that each level has a tax base linked to the services it provides.

Worked example 2: dividing a shareable pool

Suppose the net proceeds of shareable Union taxes in a year are ₹2,000 crore and the Commission recommends that States receive 40%. Total for all States = 40% of 2,000 = ₹800 crore; the Centre keeps ₹1,200 crore. If one State is given 5% of the States' pool, it receives 5% of 800 = ₹40 crore. The Commission also considers fairness between States, such as their income levels and population, so different States receive different percentages.

No tax without law (Article 265). Income tax and customs duties: Union. Tax on agricultural income and State excise: State. Property tax: local. A Finance Commission recommends how shareable taxes are divided.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • A tax needs the authority of a law (Article 265).
  • Each level of government has taxes matched to its responsibilities.
  • Local bodies depend mainly on property tax, fees and grants.
  • The Finance Commission recommends the sharing of shareable taxes between the Centre and the States.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article of the Constitution says that no tax may be levied or collected except by authority of law?

    1. Article 280
    2. Article 265
    3. Article 246
    4. Article 279A
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 265 is the rule 'no tax without law'. Article 280 deals with the Finance Commission and Article 279A with the GST Council.

  2. 2. Which of these is a Union tax?

    1. Tax on agricultural income
    2. Property tax on houses
    3. Customs duty on imports
    4. Municipal water charge
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Customs duties are Union levies. Tax on agricultural income is a State matter and property tax is a local body tax.

  3. 3. Which tax is typically levied by a municipality?

    1. Tax on non-agricultural income
    2. Corporation tax on companies
    3. Customs duty
    4. Property tax on buildings
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Local bodies charge property tax and fees for local services. The others are Union taxes.

  4. 4. What does the Finance Commission recommend?

    1. The retail price of essential goods in each State
    2. How much tax each citizen must pay in the coming year
    3. How shareable taxes are divided between the Centre and States
    4. Which new taxes the courts should impose on citizens
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Commission, appointed under Article 280, recommends the sharing of the net proceeds of shareable taxes, and principles for grants to States.

  5. 5. Net shareable proceeds are ₹2,000 crore and States receive 40% of them. A State gets 5% of the States' share. How much does it receive?

    1. ₹40 crore
    2. ₹100 crore
    3. ₹80 crore
    4. ₹400 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: A. States' pool = 0.40 × 2,000 = ₹800 crore. The State receives 0.05 × 800 = ₹40 crore.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery