• Foundation
  • About 11 min
  • 5 practice questions

What a tax is and why governments levy taxes

Understand the meaning of tax, how it differs from fees and fines, the purposes of taxation, and the canons of a good tax system.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Roads, schools, courts and defence are paid for mostly by taxes. A tax is the price of living in an organised society, but unlike a price it does not buy a particular service for the payer. Understanding what makes a tax different from other payments is the first step in the study of taxation.

Meaning

A tax is a compulsory payment made to the government by individuals and firms, without any direct, specific benefit in return. Compulsion is the key: you cannot refuse to pay. There is no direct quid pro quo: the amount you pay does not match the services you personally receive.

Tax, fee, fine and cess

Tax and related payments
PaymentNatureExample
TaxCompulsory, no direct service in returnIncome tax
FeePayment for a specific service, though in part voluntaryFee for a licence or court filing
Fine / penaltyPunishment for breaking the lawPenalty for a traffic offence
CessA tax collected for a stated purpose, on top of other taxesA levy earmarked for a specific programme
SurchargeAn additional charge on a tax, usually on high payersA percentage on top of the tax payable

Why governments tax

  • To raise revenue for public goods and services.
  • To redistribute income by taxing the better-off more and spending on the poor.
  • To discourage harmful goods (tobacco, alcohol) through high taxes, sometimes called sin taxes.
  • To protect domestic industry through import duties.
  • To stabilise the economy, since taxes affect spending.

Canons of taxation

The economist Adam Smith proposed four canons or principles of a good tax system.

  1. Equity (ability to pay): people should pay in proportion to their ability.
  2. Certainty: the amount, time and manner of payment should be clear to the taxpayer.
  3. Convenience: payment should be easy in time and manner.
  4. Economy: the cost of collection should be small compared with the revenue.

Worked example 1

Ravi pays Rs 200 to a government office for a certificate. This is a fee, since he gets a specific service. His neighbour pays Rs 20,000 as income tax and receives nothing specific for it. This is a tax. Both are paid to the government, but only one has a direct return.

Worked example 2 - economy

Suppose collecting a tax costs Rs 15 crore and brings in Rs 100 crore. The cost of collection is 15 / 100 = 15% of revenue. A tax that costs Rs 2 crore to collect for Rs 100 crore (2%) satisfies the canon of economy better. The first one may still be justified if it has other goals, but the cost has to be weighed.

Key takeaways

  • A tax is compulsory and gives no direct specific return.
  • Fees pay for specific services; fines punish.
  • Taxes raise revenue, redistribute, discourage harm and stabilise.
  • Four canons: equity, certainty, convenience, economy.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which feature distinguishes a tax from a fee?

    1. A tax is voluntary
    2. A tax is compulsory and gives no direct, specific service in return
    3. A tax is paid by the government to citizens
    4. A tax is always a small amount
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A fee pays for a specific service; a tax is compulsory with no direct quid pro quo.

  2. 2. Which of Adam Smith's canons says the amount, time and manner of payment should be clear to the taxpayer?

    1. Equity
    2. Convenience
    3. Economy
    4. Certainty
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Certainty is about clarity of amount, time and manner. Convenience is about ease of payment, economy about low collection cost.

  3. 3. A tax costs Rs 6 crore to collect and brings in Rs 120 crore. What is the cost of collection as a percentage of revenue?

    1. 5%
    2. 20%
    3. 0.5%
    4. 6%
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 6 / 120 x 100 = 5%.

  4. 4. Ravi pays Rs 200 to a government office to get a licence. This payment is a

    1. Tax
    2. Fine
    3. Fee
    4. Surcharge
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He receives a specific service (the licence) for the payment, so it is a fee.

  5. 5. A surcharge is

    1. A payment for a specific service such as a licence
    2. A punishment for breaking the law
    3. An additional charge on the tax payable, usually on high payers
    4. A refund of tax already paid
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A surcharge is levied on top of the tax, typically on high payers. A fee buys a service and a fine punishes.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Direct and indirect taxes

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery