• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Bodies for local government: the State Election Commission and the State Finance Commission

Say who runs elections to panchayats and municipalities, who decides how the state shares money with them, and how these bodies differ from the Union Election and Finance Commissions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

India has government at three levels: the Union, the states and local bodies such as village panchayats and city municipalities. In 1992 the 73rd and 74th Amendments gave panchayats and municipalities a place in the Constitution. With that came two constitutional bodies for local government, one to hold their elections and one to look after their money. Both are set up at the level of the state, so the Governor, and not the President, appoints them.

The State Election Commission

The Election Commission of India holds elections to Parliament, to the state legislatures and for the offices of President and Vice-President. It does not hold elections to panchayats and municipalities. These are held by the State Election Commission (Article 243K for panchayats and Article 243ZA for municipalities). The Commission is headed by a State Election Commissioner, appointed by the Governor. It prepares the voters' lists for local elections and supervises the whole election.

To keep the Commissioner independent, the Constitution says the Commissioner can be removed only in the same way, and on the same grounds, as a judge of the High Court. The conditions of service cannot be made worse after the appointment.

The State Finance Commission

Local bodies need money to build roads, run schools and provide water. The Governor therefore sets up a State Finance Commission (Article 243I) to study their finances. It advises how the taxes and fees collected by the state should be shared between the state and the local bodies, which taxes may be given to the local bodies, and what grants the state should make to them. A new Commission is set up at the end of every fifth year. Its recommendations are placed before the state legislature along with a note on the action taken.

Union bodies and their local counterparts
JobUnion levelLocal government level
ElectionsElection Commission of India (Article 324)State Election Commission (Articles 243K, 243ZA)
Sharing moneyFinance Commission (Article 280)State Finance Commission (Article 243I)
Appointed byPresidentGovernor
Head of the election body is removed likeA Supreme Court judgeA High Court judge

Panchayats and municipalities: State Election Commission and State Finance Commission, both appointed by the Governor. Parliament and the Assemblies: Election Commission of India, appointed by the President.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: who holds this election?

Match each election with the body. (a) The Lok Sabha. (b) A village panchayat. (c) A city municipal corporation. (d) A state Legislative Assembly. Working: the Lok Sabha (a) and the Assembly (d) are held by the Election Commission of India. The panchayat (b) and the municipal corporation (c) are held by the State Election Commission. Notice that the line is drawn by the level of the body being elected.

Worked example 2: who appoints and who removes?

The Governor appoints the State Election Commissioner. Can the Governor also dismiss the Commissioner whenever the Governor likes? No. The Constitution says the removal must be by the same method and on the same grounds as for a High Court judge. This protects the Commissioner from pressure. The idea is the same as for the Chief Election Commissioner, who has the protection of a Supreme Court judge.

Worked example 3: counting five-year turns

A State Finance Commission was set up at the end of Year 5. When is the next one due? Article 243I says at the end of every fifth year, so the next is due at the end of Year 10, and the one after that at the end of Year 15. The Governor may set one up earlier if needed.

Key takeaways: local elections are held by the State Election Commission; the State Finance Commission advises on sharing money with local bodies; the Governor appoints both; the State Election Commissioner is removed like a High Court judge; a State Finance Commission is set up every fifth year.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Elections to a village panchayat are held by

    1. The Election Commission of India
    2. The State Election Commission
    3. The Union Public Service Commission
    4. The Governor himself
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 243K gives the superintendence of panchayat elections to the State Election Commission.

  2. 2. A State Election Commissioner is appointed by

    1. The Governor
    2. The President
    3. The Chief Minister
    4. The Chief Justice of India
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 243K says the State Election Commissioner is appointed by the Governor.

  3. 3. A State Election Commissioner can be removed like a judge of

    1. The Supreme Court
    2. A District Court
    3. The High Court
    4. The Rajya Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Constitution gives the State Election Commissioner the protection applicable to a High Court judge.

  4. 4. The State Finance Commission is set up under

    1. Article 280
    2. Article 324
    3. Article 148
    4. Article 243I
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 243I provides for the State Finance Commission. Article 280 is the Union Finance Commission.

  5. 5. The State Finance Commission advises mainly on

    1. Sharing of money between the state and local bodies
    2. Elections to the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha
    3. Auditing the accounts of the Union Government
    4. Appointing High Court judges in the state
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It recommends how taxes and fees are shared, which taxes go to local bodies and what grants the state should give them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery