- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Finance Commission and the Comptroller and Auditor General
Explain how the Finance Commission shares tax money between the Union and the States, and how the CAG audits public money and reports to the legislature.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Two constitutional bodies deal with public money. The Finance Commission decides how tax money should be shared between the Union and the States. The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) checks whether money has been spent lawfully and properly. One looks forward at how money should be divided; the other looks back at how it was spent.
The Finance Commission: Article 280
The President constitutes a Finance Commission every five years, or earlier if he thinks it necessary. It has a chairman and four other members, appointed by the President. Parliament decides their qualifications and the manner of their selection by law. Its main duty is to recommend to the President how the net proceeds of taxes that are to be shared should be divided between the Union and the States, and how the States' share should be divided among the States. It also recommends the principles for grants-in-aid to States from the Consolidated Fund of India, and measures to help States support their panchayats and municipalities.
The Commission's recommendations are advisory, not binding. Under Article 281, the President lays them before each House of Parliament with a memorandum explaining what action has been taken.
Worked example 1: an illustration of tax sharing
Suppose, purely as an illustration, that the shareable taxes collected in a year come to ₹1,000 crore and a Finance Commission recommends that the States together get 40% of it. Step 1: the States' share is 40% of 1,000 = ₹400 crore. Step 2: the Union keeps ₹600 crore. Step 3: the ₹400 crore is then divided among the States using the formula the Commission recommends, which looks at things like population, area and need. The real percentages change from one Commission to the next, which is why you should never memorise them as fixed facts.
The CAG: Articles 148 to 151
- Appointed by the President by warrant under his hand and seal (Article 148).
- Removed only in the same manner and on the same grounds as a Supreme Court judge.
- Holds office for six years or until 65 years of age, whichever is earlier, under the law made by Parliament.
- Not eligible for any further office under the Government of India or any State after leaving office.
- Salary and the administrative expenses of the office are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
- The form in which the accounts of the Union and States are kept is prescribed by the President on the CAG's advice (Article 150).
Reports of the CAG: Article 151
The CAG audits all receipts and spending of the Union and the States and of bodies largely financed by them. Reports on the Union's accounts go to the President, who has them laid before Parliament. Reports on a State's accounts go to the Governor, who has them laid before the State legislature. In Parliament, these reports are examined by the Public Accounts Committee, which is why the CAG is often described as the guide of the Public Accounts Committee and the guardian of the public purse.
Worked example 2: tracing a CAG report
The CAG audits spending by a State's health department and finds money spent on equipment that was never used. Step 1: since it is a State's account, the report goes to the Governor (Article 151(2)). Step 2: the Governor causes it to be laid before the State legislature. Step 3: the legislature's Public Accounts Committee examines it and can question officials. If the spending had been by a Union ministry, the report would go to the President and then to Parliament.
Finance Commission (Art 280): every five years or earlier, chairman + 4 members, advises on sharing taxes; advice only. CAG (Art 148): removed like a Supreme Court judge, no later government office; Union reports to the President, State reports to the Governor (Art 151).
Key takeaways
The Finance Commission divides; the CAG checks. Both are protected so they can work without fear: the Finance Commission through its fixed constitutional role, and the CAG through strong security of tenure and a ban on later government jobs. Remember where each report goes and who examines it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who constitutes the Finance Commission?
- The Prime Minister
- The President
- The Parliament
- The Reserve Bank of India
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 280(1): the President constitutes the Finance Commission.
-
2. How often is a Finance Commission constituted?
- Every five years, or earlier if the President thinks necessary
- Every ten years
- Every year
- Only during a financial emergency
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 280(1): at the end of every fifth year or at such earlier time as the President considers necessary.
-
3. To whom does the CAG submit reports on the accounts of a State?
- The President
- The Chief Minister
- The State Finance Minister
- The Governor
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 151(2): reports on a State's accounts are submitted to the Governor, who causes them to be laid before the State legislature.
-
4. After leaving office, the CAG:
- may become a Governor
- may be appointed to the Finance Commission
- is not eligible for any further office under the Government of India or any State
- may return as CAG for a second term
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 148(4): the CAG is not eligible for further office under the Government of India or of any State after he ceases to hold office.
-
5. Which parliamentary committee examines the CAG's audit reports?
- Estimates Committee
- Public Accounts Committee
- Committee on Petitions
- Business Advisory Committee
Show answer
Answer: B. The Public Accounts Committee examines the CAG's reports on the appropriation and finance accounts of the government.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.