- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
How constitutional bodies report and stay accountable
Say to whom the main constitutional bodies send their reports, who places them before the legislature, and what the Public Service Commissions must explain.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A body with powers should answer to someone. The Constitution therefore tells each body to send a report to the President or to the Governor, and the report is then placed before Parliament or the state legislature. This means that the elected representatives of the people can see what these independent bodies have done.
The simple rule
Bodies working for the Union send their reports to the President, and the President has them laid before both Houses of Parliament. Bodies working for a state send their reports to the Governor, and the Governor has them laid before the state legislature.
| Body | Sends the report to | Placed before |
|---|---|---|
| Comptroller and Auditor General (Article 151) | President (Union accounts), Governor (state accounts) | Parliament or the state legislature |
| Union Public Service Commission (Article 323) | President, every year | Both Houses of Parliament |
| State Public Service Commission (Article 323) | Governor, every year | State legislature |
| Finance Commission (Article 281) | President | Both Houses, with a note on action taken |
| Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities (Article 350B) | President | Both Houses, and sent to the states |
What the Public Service Commissions must explain
The Public Service Commissions give advice to the government on recruitment and service matters. The government usually accepts it, but not always. When the advice is not accepted, the report placed before the legislature must carry a memorandum giving the reasons. In this way the legislature can see when and why the government went against the advice.
Who looks at the CAG's report?
The CAG audits the accounts of the government and reports whether the money was spent as the legislature allowed. In Parliament the report is usually studied by the Public Accounts Committee, a committee of members of Parliament.
Union body: report to the President, laid before Parliament. State body: report to the Governor, laid before the state legislature. If advice of a Public Service Commission was not accepted, the reasons must be given.
Worked example 1: whom does the report go to?
The CAG audits the accounts of a state. To whom does the report go? Because the accounts belong to the state, the report goes to the Governor, who has it laid before the state legislature. If the CAG audits the accounts of the Union, the report goes to the President.
Worked example 2: advice not accepted
The government does not follow the advice of the Union Public Service Commission on a service matter. What must be done? When the annual report of the Commission is laid before Parliament, a memorandum must explain the cases where the advice was not accepted and the reasons. The government cannot simply ignore the advice without anyone knowing.
Worked example 3: matching
Match (a) State Public Service Commission, (b) the CAG on Union accounts, (c) Finance Commission with (1) report to the Governor, (2) report to the President, laid before Parliament with a note on action taken, (3) report to the President, laid before Parliament. Working: (a) is a state body, so (1). (b) reports to the President, so (3). (c) has the memorandum on action taken, so (2). Answer: a-1, b-3, c-2.
Key takeaways: Union bodies report to the President and state bodies to the Governor; the report is placed before the legislature; the Public Service Commissions must explain advice that was not accepted; the Finance Commission's recommendations are laid with a note on action taken.
Check your understanding
-
1. The CAG's report on the Union accounts is submitted to
- The Governor
- The Prime Minister
- The Speaker
- The President
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 151(1) provides that the CAG's report on the Union accounts goes to the President.
-
2. A State Public Service Commission submits its annual report to
- The Governor
- The President
- The Chief Justice
- The Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 323 says the State Commission presents its report to the Governor.
-
3. When the advice of the UPSC is not accepted, the report laid before Parliament must carry
- A fresh set of advice from the members
- A list of the members and their salaries
- A memorandum giving reasons for non-acceptance
- A copy of the budget of the Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 323 requires a memorandum explaining the cases of non-acceptance and the reasons.
-
4. The Finance Commission's recommendations are laid before Parliament with
- An audit report
- A note on the action taken
- A list of the states
- The Governor's report
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 281 requires an explanatory memorandum on the action taken.
-
5. The CAG's report on a state's accounts is laid before
- Parliament
- The Supreme Court
- The state legislature
- The Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. The Governor causes the report relating to a state to be laid before the state legislature.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.